L

Lord Tugendhat (Con)

Speaking in the House of Lords on 20 October 2026

Debate

EU, Euratom and UK Agreement on Gibraltar

Contribution

My Lords, I begin by welcoming the Gibraltarian delegation attending our debate and saying how very much I appreciate the fact that they are taking so much interest in our deliberations. I had the pleasure of hearing the Chief Minister when he gave evidence to our committee, and that was a very convincing performance. For my part, I not only support the resolution in front of us but I go further and, like my friend, the noble Lord, Lord Hannay, I certainly commend this agreement to the Committee. It must be seen in the context of the United Kingdom’s Brexit vote. This, of course, ran contrary to the wishes of the people of Gibraltar, who believed, rightly in my view, that it was against their own best interests. That, in my view, imposes on the UK Government an obligation to mitigate as far as possible what the people of Gibraltar regard as the harmful consequences to them of Brexit. I think we have a duty to do that. It is against this criterion that we should judge this treaty. The answer is clear, as the unanimous decision of the Gibraltar Parliament shows. Really, the Gibraltar Parliament is the best judge of the interests of the Gibraltar people, and I was very uneasy to hear my noble friend Lord Redwood explaining to them how they did not see seem to understand what their own best interests were—we in London must not assume that we know better than other people what their own best interests are. The people best able to judge the best interests of Gibraltar are those in the Gibraltar Parliament and not those of us sitting in London. I congratulate the Gibraltar Parliament on its decision and to go against it would be an act of some impertinence on our part. I congratulate the Government on the agreement, in particular the officials who have negotiated it. I cannot remember a time when disagreements over Gibraltar have not caused trouble for the British-Spanish relationship and difficulties for the people of Gibraltar. The number of officials who have devoted years of their career to working on this problem is legion, and I take heart from the fact that this agreement is an example of what the UK and the EU can achieve when they approach a negotiation in what might be called a success-oriented frame of mind. I hope that the success of reaching agreement over this matter will act as an indication that agreement between us and the EU is possible on other matters as well, and that this will create a precedent. In conclusion, I recognise, of course—how could I not, after listening to my noble friend speak?—that some noble Lords see the creation of the EU-Gibraltar customs union, and all that follows from it, as a derogation of sovereignty. It is certainly new, in so far as the policy areas covered by the treaty are concerned, that Gibraltar will be subject to a different set of rules from the rest of the UK. I remind noble Lords of what Geoffrey Howe so wisely pointed out, goodness knows how many years ago, when he explained that one of the attributes of sovereignty is the ability it gives to share with others, if we believe that that is in the best interests of the UK or of some part of the UK. That is not a surrender of sovereignty, it is a constructive use of sovereignty. This agreement is a very good example. I certainly commend this agreement. I congratulate those who negotiated it; I wish the people of Gibraltar success and prosperity as the years go forward under the aegis of this agreement.

More from Lord Tugendhat (Con)

Other recent Hansard contributions by the same speaker.

About Hansard

Hansard is the official verbatim record of proceedings in the UK Parliament. Every word spoken in the Commons and Lords is recorded and published — this page is a single contribution from that record.