L

Lord Redwood (Con)

Speaking in the House of Lords on 20 October 2026

Debate

EU, Euratom and UK Agreement on Gibraltar

Contribution

My Lords, Gibraltar has done extremely well over the years, with a very successful service sector-led economy, a very happy relationship with the United Kingdom, and as the possessor of a crucial base for the United Kingdom and NATO. I have always welcomed the close collaboration between Gibraltar and the United Kingdom. I rise to ask some questions of the Minister, because I fear for Gibraltar’s future under some of the details and terms of this agreement with the European Union. It seems to me very one-sided, with plenty of give to the European Union and not very much take for Gibraltar. There are a number of areas where I think we need to scrutinise it very carefully. The first is the money. Can the Minister give us more information about what the social cohesion payment would be? How much tax do the Gibraltarians have to pay to improve adjacent parts of Spain? Under the alignment mechanisms, is it not the case that business in Gibraltar could find itself the subject of more levies or taxes, which would start to undermine the excellent competitiveness which Gibraltar has enjoyed through her own sensible choices? Part of the success of Gibraltar is relatively light taxation and an effective, but not oppressive, regulatory regime for the services she trades with the world. It would be a great worry if that was impaired or demolished by maybe inadvertent crazy EU actions. If you look at Gibraltar’s sovereignty, it is clearly badly impaired because Gibraltar will now be under European Union law and will have to adopt all European law in the relevant areas as it comes forward. That seems to me very foolish, given the excellence of Gibraltar as a self-regulating territory within the United Kingdom family; it has put together very good business and economic success, but how can it be sure that that will not be impaired by bad laws and oppressive regulation? After all, Signor Draghi, a great hero of saving the euro and the European scheme, has himself penned an excoriating report about the lack of economic progress and growth in the European Union. He blames excessive lawmaking and overregulation, and has been one of the influences trying to persuade the EU that it should be reducing the number of regulations it imposes. Although there have been warm words to that effect at the Council of Ministers and from the Commission, there is absolutely no evidence that they going to do it, because we see every month that more laws are passed, more regulations imposed and higher costs made mandatory. Let us look, for example, at the energy situation, where adopting the acquis in energy means carbon pricing, emissions trading and large carbon taxes to guarantee that the EU—and Gibraltar attached to it—will be hopelessly uncompetitive with, for example, the United States of America, which does not impose similar burdens on its own activities. There is then the issue of the control, or non-control, of the border. We know that the land border will be treated very differently from the air and maritime border. The land border removes its controls, but it will of course be shaped by Schengen. It is very clear that the main driver of land border decisions, made jointly by Spanish EU officials and Gibraltarian officials, will be under European control and will clearly be designed mainly to favour the movement of Spanish and EU citizens across the border in Gibraltar. I appreciate that there are some restrictions on them then gaining citizenship of Gibraltar, but Gibraltar needs to think very carefully about how it provides even temporary accommodation. Gibraltar is providing a great asset to the part of Spain adjacent to Gibraltar, which tends to be an area of rather low incomes and higher unemployment. Gibraltar is a more prosperous area with much fuller employment and much higher incomes. The transfers are daily and will continue to be one-way, favouring the EU and Spain. We are told that joining the customs union is no problem, because Gibraltar does not export many goods. However, the main problem with a customs union is that it requires often hefty tariffs on imports. That will affect Gibraltar fundamentally, because part of the lifestyle of Gibraltarians rests on being able to import good-value products from around the world. Being forced into the EU customs union will mean that they then can buy only dear European goods or alternatives from elsewhere in the world with high tariffs, in many cases designed by the European Union to thwart the Gibraltarian customer and get them to buy the inferior or dearer EU product. The customs union is a particular blow to Gibraltar. I have long been an advocate that the United Kingdom should not go anywhere near the customs union again—how proud I was that we stripped tariffs from 2,000 line items when we came out of the European Union. We had a rule that, if we did not make or grow the thing ourselves, there should be no tariff on it. Why burden yourself with extra costs for something that you cannot make or grow? In Gibraltar’s case, there are many things, naturally, that a small population cannot make or grow. It would be silly to burden it with very high tariffs in the way that the EU would demand for its own purposes. I am also concerned about the airport. It is an MoD base, and I believe it is leased for commercial and civilian purposes. We should understand that its primary task was as a very important air base as part of NATO. That needs to be fully baked in. I am told that people who have read the legal detail are reassured that the MoD will continue to be able to take priority if needs arise. However, it seems an unnecessary encumbrance to put this under some kind of joint management and control when it is very clearly a Gibraltar-UK facility and very important part of the NATO arrangements. The idea will be to manage the airport in a way that encourages aviation within the EU and makes aviation more difficult with the rest of the world, which is not necessarily a good thing for a population trading international services in the English language, where they are more likely to do that with places that are not in the EU itself. Looking at these various problems—I will not give the Committee many more—this seems to me a very one-sided transaction. I can see why the EU wants it: it will get money from Gibraltar; it will tax and regulate Gibraltar to bring it more into line with EU practice; and it will want to develop and change Gibraltar’s economy so that it is more dependent on imports from Spain and the rest of the EU. It will want to undermine Gibraltarian consumers trying to buy cheaper and better things more widely from the rest of the world. As alignment of laws is ever more detailed, it is highly likely that the way in which people conduct services and business, set up businesses and are taxed will be adversely affected, so I strongly recommend a great dose of scepticism about this transaction. Gibraltarians should be very careful about it because, despite the immediate joy of removing a few of the barriers on the land frontier and allowing people to come to Gibraltar from Spain and do their jobs more easily, there will be all sorts of other consequences, of which I have mentioned a few, which could be extremely damaging to the long-term economic future of what is a priceless jewel: a very successful free-trading service economy, of which many of us are proud.

More from Lord Redwood (Con)

Other recent Hansard contributions by the same speaker.

About Hansard

Hansard is the official verbatim record of proceedings in the UK Parliament. Every word spoken in the Commons and Lords is recorded and published — this page is a single contribution from that record.