L

Lord Barrow (CB)

Speaking in the House of Lords on 20 October 2026

Debate

EU, Euratom and UK Agreement on Gibraltar

Contribution

My Lords, my noble and gallant friend Lord Stirrup asked me to pass on his apologies, because he cannot be with us today, and to speak on his behalf. I can only imagine the disappointment, if your Lordships were expecting the military and a diplomat turned up, but that is how we are today. The one recompense I can give is that I will not, therefore, intervene later in the debate. Before I speak on behalf of my noble and gallant friend, I need to declare my interests: I was not only negotiating many of the agreements that may be referred to but was part of the early days of this negotiation. If your Lordships look carefully at the evidence, I think they will find that witnesses gently allude to that role when they were asked why it took so long to get an agreement. However, I think one of the reasons was that success was not inevitable, and we should approach this debate in that light. On behalf of my noble and gallant friend Lord Stirrup, and with his permission, I am introducing the debate today. On 14 July, the UK Government laid before Parliament their agreement with the European Union on Gibraltar. In accordance with the Constitutional Reform and Governance Act 2010, Parliament has 21 sitting days to scrutinise the agreement. This period expires on 22 October. Since this is an agreement with the European Union, it came for consideration before your Lordships’ Committee on European Affairs rather than the International Agreements Committee, which normally reports on international agreements. The European Affairs Committee had to decide whether to report the agreement for the House’s attention or for its special attention and debate. It chose the latter option, given the matter’s political importance in settling one of the major issues outstanding from Brexit. I note that the agreement does not require the approval of your Lordships’ House. Under the CRaG process, should the other place resolve against ratification of an agreement, a second period of 21 sitting days is triggered to allow for further consideration. That has not happened in this case. Should your Lordships resolve against ratification, the Government may still proceed after laying a statement before Parliament giving their reasons for doing so. The agreement has been operating provisionally since mid-July, and the expectation is that the UK Government will ratify it once the CRaG period expires. The EU ratification process is already under way. The committee’s report does not constitute an inquiry into the agreement: the CRaG process does not allow sufficient time for such an investigation; the report is more in the nature of a guide to the agreement, setting out its background and key features, with the aim of helping the reader to navigate a lengthy and complex document. The committee was, however, able to take evidence from the noble Lord, Lord Wood of Anfield, who is the responsible Minister in the FCDO, and from the Chief Minister of Gibraltar, the honourable Fabian Picardo, setting out the perspectives of the UK and Gibraltar Governments. We also received a written submission from the All-Party Parliamentary Group on Gibraltar. We are grateful to them all for their assistance, and their evidence is attached as annexes to the report. I am also grateful to the staff of the committee for all the support they provide. Gibraltar was not included in the trade and co-operation agreement that formalised the UK’s post-Brexit relationship with the EU. This left open the question of the broader arrangements between Gibraltar and Spain, arrangements that are of fundamental importance to the economies of Gibraltar and the adjacent region of Spain. Resolving the issue was not, however, a matter for them but for the UK and the EU. Nevertheless, in 2021, the UK Government agreed with Gibraltar a joint approach to the subsequent negotiations that sought to secure the future prosperity of Gibraltar and its surrounding region, to bring confidence, legal certainty and stability to the lives and livelihoods of the people of Gibraltar and its neighbouring communities, and to ensure fluid and open movement of people and goods between Gibraltar and the EU. In March 2021, the then Foreign Secretary, the right honourable Dominic Raab, gave an assurance that the UK would not agree to arrangements under which sovereignty over Gibraltar would pass to another state or reach an agreement with which Gibraltar was not content. This undertaking was repeated by the new Government in September 2024, following the general election earlier that year. A draft UK-EU agreement was published on 26 February 2026 and was debated in March by the Gibraltar Parliament. Ahead of that debate, the Chief Minister published three separate legal opinions stating that the agreement did not undermine UK sovereignty or jurisdiction over Gibraltar. At the conclusion of the debate, the Gibraltar Parliament agreed unanimously to call upon the UK Government to ratify the agreement subject to two conditions: that Gibraltar reach a concordat with the UK that the agreement cannot be terminated without Gibraltar’s consent and that any decision by the Gibraltar Government to terminate the agreement will be subject to a referendum. The concordat was signed on 14 July 2026. The final agreement has now been laid before Parliament. It is in seven parts and contains 43 annexes. The main sections cover: common and institutional provisions; circulation of persons; economy and trade; frontier workers; financial provisions; dispute settlement; and final provisions. I will not try your Lordships’ patience by going into the specifics of each section, which I am anyway sure noble Lords have all read in detail already. Rather, I will highlight a few issues on which noble Lords may wish to reflect. Part 1 includes a section on dispute resolution. It provides for the role of the European Court of Justice in adjudicating on the interpretation of EU law. This reflects existing arrangements in the withdrawal agreement. It also specifically excludes disputes regarding Gibraltar’s sovereignty and/or jurisdiction. Part 1 also makes it clear that in areas covered by the agreement, Gibraltar is required to align its domestic law with that of the EU, so-called dynamic alignment. The wider issue of dynamic alignment is the subject of a current inquiry by your Lordships’ Committee on European Affairs. Part 2 contains detailed rules on border procedures for entry into and exit from Gibraltar. It is worth noting that decisions on these are a matter for the Government of Gibraltar, not for the UK. Importantly, non-resident members of the UK Armed Forces and their family members are exempt from passport and visa regulations and from Schengen checks. More generally, the FCDO Minister then responsible, Stephen Doughty, told the other place on 8 July that the operational autonomy of the UK’s military facilities in Gibraltar was unchanged by the agreement. The noble Lord, Lord Wood, confirmed this when he gave evidence to us, adding that there is no Spanish role in approving, authorising or controlling UK military operations, UK personnel, deployments or military movements. That is absolutely clear. Part 3 of the agreement establishes a customs union between the EU and Gibraltar. This will have an impact on trading goods, but Gibraltar’s economy is based largely on services which are not covered by the agreement. Part 4 contains provisions for frontier workers, an issue of fundamental importance to Gibraltar’s economy. In his evidence to the committee, the Chief Minister confirmed that some 15,500 people come through the frontier every day to work in Gibraltar. Only half of them are Spanish, and one-quarter of them are British. Article 5 commits to a financial mechanism aimed at promoting cohesion in the region. The cost of this is unclear, but the Chief Minister confirmed to the committee that Gibraltar would be responsible for funding it. Final provisions in Part 7 include a clause under which the parties agree to review the implementation of the agreement after no more than four years, and at regular intervals thereafter. Either party may terminate the agreement at any time, with 12 months’ notification. It may also be terminated if the UK, in respect of Gibraltar, does not accept and implement a new EU Act falling within the scope of the agreement. This is subject to a failure of the co-operation council to agree on an alternative arrangement within 90 days. In addition, either side may terminate if it is dissatisfied with the operations agreement after the review conducted at or before the four-year point. Spain, if it so wishes, may at that time request the EU to begin the process of termination. The UK is, of course, bound by the concordat it has signed on that matter. There is naturally an enormous amount of detail in the agreement. But considering it in the round, noble Lords may wish to reassure themselves that the objectives set out by the Government in 2021, and reiterated by their successor Administration in 2024, have been met. Noble Lords may wish to note the Chief Minister’s view that, since early logistical teething issues at the border, the new system has been working effectively since its provisional introduction on 14 July. Finally, your Lordships will no doubt wish to take into account the view of the Gibraltarians themselves, as expressed through the outcome of their own parliamentary process. For them, this agreement resolves some fundamental issues which they faced in the wake of Brexit, which, unaddressed, threatened to derail the functioning of the territory. With those points in mind, I beg to move.

More from Lord Barrow (CB)

Other recent Hansard contributions by the same speaker.

About Hansard

Hansard is the official verbatim record of proceedings in the UK Parliament. Every word spoken in the Commons and Lords is recorded and published — this page is a single contribution from that record.