L

Lord Johnson of Lainston (Con)

Speaking in the House of Lords on 14 October 2026

Debate

UK and Poland: Security and Defence Partnership

Contribution

My Lords, I am particularly delighted that we are having this debate on the day that President Zelensky is in London meeting the Prime Minister, I think while we are having this discussion. That only highlights the importance of agreements such as this. We are going to scrutinise the UK-Poland Security and Defence Partnership and our International Agreements Committee’s report on that agreement. The agreement was signed in May 2026. The then Prime Minister described it—this is an important statement—as “the biggest step forward in our defence and security relationship with Poland in a generation”. It establishes a framework for co-operation between the UK and Poland across foreign policy, defence and security, and a whole range of other areas. The scrutiny period under CRaG expired on 9 September. We reported the agreement to the House for special attention and debate in the light of its political significance, but, in the light of our overall conclusions, we did not think it was necessary for this debate to take place during the CRaG period. I thank the Government for their decision to publish the treaty online ahead of its formal laying in Parliament, which gave us more time to take evidence and therefore produce this more comprehensive report. I would be very grateful if the Minister could feed back to his colleagues that that practice is extremely welcome, particularly for treaties such as this. It gives us more time and does not necessitate asking for an extension to the CRaG process. The outcome is eminently satisfactory. I thank the witnesses, who were numerous, especially and including the Minister for Europe and senior officials from the FCDO and the MoD. I thank the staff who support our committee, admirably led by Dom Walsh, in particular Priscilla Tomaz for her support in leading our inquiry and, effectively, producing the report. I think we can all agree that the UK and Poland are entering into this treaty at a time of sustained geopolitical challenge, in particular Russia’s war in Ukraine and the growth of hybrid threats. In this context, we agree with the Government that Poland is clearly a vital partner and ally on NATO’s eastern flank. As the treaty recognises, Poland plays an increasingly central role in the Euro-Atlantic security architecture and in shaping European responses to Russian aggression. Committee Members will be aware that this is not the first defence treaty that the UK and Poland have signed. It aims to build on a previous defence treaty from 2017 and a non-binding declaration signed in 2023. However, compared with its predecessors, this treaty takes a far more expansive approach to the issues that are considered relevant to defence and security, including economic resilience, energy and climate security, and tackling illegal migration. This expansive approach reflects the increasingly diverse threats that the UK and Poland face. However, the committee was concerned that it would cause challenges in co-ordinating collaboration across departments. I am not saying this as a political point, but I think that getting departments to work together is often a challenge even within His Majesty’s Government. To multiply that by the cubic number of two to add a second country’s government departments to collaborate will represent a significant challenge. I would be very grateful for the Minister’s comments on that, in the sense of the steps the Government will take to ensure that we truly have an integrated approach to implementing this treaty. In the current security context, the treaty strengthens our bilateral defence relationship with Poland and affirms the importance of co-operation at this time of great uncertainty. By expanding the scope of co-operation beyond traditional defence policy issues, it establishes a comprehensive framework to address the increasingly integrated nature of the threats that face both the UK and Poland. These hybrid threats include provisions on collaboration in cyber security, critical infrastructure, supply chain resilience, and so on. This is particularly valuable for private defence companies, which are often the first targets of hybrid attacks. I think the committee was pleased to note the element of industrial co-operation, where the treaty aims to make the UK and Poland joint European leaders in complex weapons manufacturing. As it happens, I spoke today to BAE Systems, which wanted me to express its support for this treaty because it pushed further the collaboration between BAE Systems and PGZ and enabled a far more institutional approach to combined weapons development and delivery. That is an important win for the UK defence industry and clearly a good thing for both countries. The question that comes from this—this is the theme that the committee wishes to raise in scrutinising this treaty—is: can we be sure that the Ministry of Defence will dedicate the right level of resourcing to the teams behind these projects? If it does not do that, it will not succeed. For the benefit of other Members taking part in this debate, these processes are not simply about single weapons development—this is the important point. We want to see us move from single-platform development collaboration to overall defence collaborations, as we saw with BAE Systems in Norway. I am sure there will be some well-phrased words from the Minister on that, but we would quite like to hear some concrete responses to those points. This leads on to the point that much of the treaty is very high level and general, rather than setting out detailed, substantive obligations. The Minister for Europe told us that this was deliberate and designed to allow for greater flexibility. Alongside this treaty is a list of 14 landmark projects, which we hope will turn the ambitions set out in the treaty into tangible outcomes. However, many of those also lack specific timelines and do not outline specific deliverables. We are also concerned about how the treaty’s commitments will be funded. Frankly, someone may say that this is the elephant in the room, in the light of the UK’s defence spending plans and whether the UK’s broader commitments to NATO on defence spending will be met. The uncertainty around our defence spending plans undermines the UK’s reputation as an ally at a time of geopolitical uncertainty. Clearly, Poland will respond positively to this treaty from its point of view only if it feels that we are investing enough capital, time and resources into our entire defence industry, and then the specific treaty obligations that we have with it. I am sure the Minister cannot give me anything significantly specific about our defence spending plans, but it will be very important, since I am sure the Polish military will be listening to this debate—as, no doubt, are many other people as well—to underline truly our financial commitment to defence in general and to this project specifically. I will move on to one of the other points that were raised by the committee in our inquiry. Article 2 of the treaty provides that the parties “reaffirm their commitment to NATO as the foundation of their collective defence, and to their obligations … in the North Atlantic Treaty … in particular Article 5”. It then states that in the event of an armed attack against the other party, the parties “shall assist one another, including by military means in accordance with Article 5 of the North Atlantic Treaty”. We clearly welcome this reaffirmation of both parties’ commitment to NATO but we were a bit unclear as to whether the treaty adds commitments that go beyond our NATO commitments. The wording of Article 2 of the treaty, which states that assistance by “military means” is to be in accordance with Article 5 of the North Atlantic Treaty, appears to suggest that any use of military force in response to an armed attack would take place within the NATO framework. However, can the Minister clarify whether Article 2 creates any mutual defence commitments in addition to those under Article 5 of the North Atlantic Treaty? The EM notes that the devolved Administrations were consulted, but added that “there are limited implications for the Devolved Administrations”. I know, from having been in the Minister’s position, that that is understandable, given the complication of trying to get the approval of the devolved Administrations, particularly in a reserved matter such as the creation of treaties. However, this treaty specifically goes beyond simple military matters, and by its very nature, if it is to be effective, it covers whole areas of home affairs—immigration, crime, and so on. We really would like to understand from the Minister that the devolved Administrations have been properly consulted and that they are aware of their commitments that might relate to this treaty. All of them are important and I am sure they are all shared goals, but that has not been clearly enough indicated. There was no reference to the treaty’s provisions for amendment or the scrutiny implications. We have repeatedly asked that the Government should say more in the Explanatory Memorandum on which amendments will be subject to ratification and, therefore, scrutiny. This is the third consecutive report—if the Minister could note this—in which we have had to make this point. It is very important that Parliament has the opportunity to scrutinise further amendments of these treaties. Many of them are designed to be flexible in the modern world, which we support, but we must ensure that we have effective oversight. In conclusion, I believe personally, and I believe this is the strong view of the committee, that this treaty is to be welcomed. It enhances bilateral co-operation with a very important ally at what is clearly a highly challenging time and contains some important provisions, especially the principle of an expanded mandate between the two countries, important defence sharing and support for our industrial base. However, it is high level and general in nature. It remains to be seen how co-operation will be advanced in practice and, importantly, how it is to be paid for. It therefore remains to be seen what its true long-term significance will be. I look forward to the Minister’s comments, and I beg to move.

More from Lord Johnson of Lainston (Con)

Other recent Hansard contributions by the same speaker.

About Hansard

Hansard is the official verbatim record of proceedings in the UK Parliament. Every word spoken in the Commons and Lords is recorded and published — this page is a single contribution from that record.