L

Lord Johnson of Lainston (Con)

Speaking in the House of Lords on 14 October 2026

Debate

UK and Poland: Security and Defence Partnership

Contribution

I thank the Minister for a very comprehensive set of replies and thank my fellow committee members and other Members who have taken part in this debate, including my noble kinsman Lord Hamilton. It is always a good thing to have your father-in-law with you when you come to give a speech. I want to cover just a few points. I was delighted that the recognition of the extended time period we had to scrutinise the treaty has been fed back in. These things are very important because having scrutiny of our treaties and agreements raises their profile, which in itself is extremely helpful. So this is not just a simple question of us making a critique of something but an important point, because it allows these principles to be aired, which gives greater power to the document in its own sense. I felt that in my introductory comments my job was to focus specifically on the report that we had written collectively, but the reality is far deeper than that. The relationship with Poland has been well pointed out by the noble Lord, Lord Hannay, and the noble Baronesses, Lady Anelay and Lady Lawlor. The noble Lord, Lord Bruce, mentioned the enormous population of Poles who live in this country. This is not simply a piece of paper or a technical and structural agreement; it is a very important reaffirmation of incredibly strong historic and people-to-people links. There is no question at all that Poland is one of our closest and most important allies, and so this treaty is absolutely at the centre of that. That is why I think a number of colleagues, such as my noble kinsman, the noble Earl, Lord Courtown, the noble Baroness, Lady Lawlor, and other Members of the Committee, mentioned the operational specificity around delivery. We are extremely pleased to hear that the Kensington agreement is starting to yield fruit, because we reviewed that and I believe we said exactly the same: “Great idea. We all agree with everything here, but we need to see these things become reality”. We will watch that carefully and review those points. Of course, the principle of funding is very relevant as well. It will be difficult for us to suggest that we can be a proper ally to any of the countries with which we have specific treaties if we cannot afford to put our money where our mouth is. Obviously, we press the Government to ensure truly that Poland looks to us for our commitment in the same way as we look to it for the commitment it is making—this point was illustrated so well by the noble Lord, Lord Bruce—in terms of defence spending and the size and growth of its economy. The noble Lord, Lord Hannay, the noble Baroness, Lady Anelay, and several of my other colleagues mentioned the relationship to Article 5 and NATO. The Minister said that this treaty is a reaffirmation of Article 5. My question, and this puzzled the noble Lord, Lord Hannay, the team and the rest of the committee, is: why do we need to reaffirm something that we felt was pretty inviolable? I say this not as a foreign policy expert, but of all the principles of treaties anywhere in the world, Article 5 strikes me as the one that is carved in rock; many other treaties have elements that probably need reaffirming. I am just a bit concerned about that. Clearly, it is a small point in the sense of the reaffirmation of the relationship, but why do we need to reaffirm Article 5? I would be grateful if the Government could comment on that point. It is in our report; I am sure that, when they write their report, it would be helpful to see why that is relevant. If we have not reaffirmed Article 5 with other countries, does it mean that we do not take that principle seriously? I would have thought not. In which case, if this is just good language to reconfirm our relationship, perhaps it should be expressed slightly differently. All in all, we are very pleased that our relationship with this important ally of ours is being strengthened. I am grateful to the Minister for his comments, to all the people who have spoken so eloquently and constructively this afternoon, and to the committee for producing this report.

More from Lord Johnson of Lainston (Con)

Other recent Hansard contributions by the same speaker.

About Hansard

Hansard is the official verbatim record of proceedings in the UK Parliament. Every word spoken in the Commons and Lords is recorded and published — this page is a single contribution from that record.