L

Lord Wood of Anfield (Lab)

Speaking in the House of Lords on 14 October 2026

Debate

UK and Poland: Security and Defence Partnership

Contribution

That indeed is one of the issues about avoiding duplication and trying to get the best out of existing organisations rather than replacing them with a new framework. That is the challenge inside the UK as well, when we think about the new NCID and how it fits with the National Cyber Security Centre, for example. The noble Lord is completely right to raise that as a design issue going forward. I agree with the committee that we must keep energy behind progress happening across departments and keep progress under review. We will do so through the governance arrangements that I have just described. I turn to a particular point that the noble Baroness, Lady Anelay, and others raised on the effect of Article 2(5) of the treaty and how it relates to Article 5 of the North Atlantic Treaty. In doing so, I will directly answer the noble Lord, Lord Johnson, as well. The Northolt treaty reaffirms our legally binding commitment to each other’s defence in a new age of threat. As two leading European NATO allies bound by NATO treaty commitments, it reinforces and is underpinned by our commitment to collective defence enshrined in Article 5 of the Washington treaty. The commitment in Article 2(5) is consistent with our Article 5 obligations and mirrors them. That is the most precise way of putting the matter. I hope that is helpful to the committee; our formal response will say a little more about that. I turn to the additional challenge in this area, from the noble Baroness, Lady Lawlor, on whether this treaty marks the Europeanisation of defence. It absolutely does not. I find it odd that strong co-operation between two NATO allies, in the face of changing, more complex and more integrated threats, can be interpreted as an attempt to shift the centre of defence gravity to Europe rather than through NATO. Defence is a geographical matter, and it is no surprise—I hope it is welcomed—that two NATO allies from the same part of the world are sharing understandings, methods and responses to shared geographical threats, under the cover of the ties that bind them through their NATO membership. I recognise the committee’s concern about defence funding, and I do not think it would be right to brush it aside. However, I will resist the noble Earl’s generous invitation to reveal the contents of the defence component of the upcoming Budget and spending reviews. We remain committed to spending 3.5% of GDP on core defence by 2035, and the Chancellor has been clear that the path to this will be set out at the next spending review. That is the normal process by which these commitments are delivered. I turn briefly to the point raised by the noble Lord, Lord Hamilton, who had some interesting reflections on the future of NATO. He is right, of course, to say that Poland is core not just to NATO but to the coalition of the willing and the defence of Ukraine. On Polish engagement with the JEF, I cannot speak for the Poles’ future intentions, but it is striking that they have participated in JEF manoeuvres and the so-called JEF+ mechanism. So they are co-operative—I am not using the term formally—and have an associate relationship with the JEF, but I cannot speak for Poland’s future intentions on membership of the JEF. It is not for me to discuss. What I can say about defence funding is that the treaty does not create unfunded commitments. It is a framework for co-operation, rather like other treaties, such as the Kensington treaty. It is not a single spending programme, and funding for individual projects will be considered through the normal departmental processes that ensure value for money. Detailed defence activity will continue to be taken forward through bilateral defence planning, and the Government remain fully committed to meeting our NATO defence investment commitments. The Northolt treaty and its associated defence commitments are designed to complement and strengthen our existing NATO commitments. On the question of hybrid threats, I was very glad that several noble Lords, including the noble Lord, Lord Johnson, and the noble Baroness, Lady Anelay—I almost said “my noble friend”, but she happens to be my friend—welcomed the treaty’s provisions on hybrid threats and defence industrial co-operation. I share that view. I am grateful again to the noble Lord, Lord Johnson, for passing on the positive comments from BAE Systems, and to the noble Baroness, Lady Anelay, for her very positive comments about her experience of our high-quality team in Poland, when she was there. I will definitely pass those back. As we all know, Poland and the UK face a common and growing threat from Russian sabotage, cyber attacks and disinformation. The new counter-hybrid working group and closer co-operation against foreign information manipulation and interference will, without doubt, help both countries to detect, deter and disrupt these activities much more quickly. On the detail of defence industrial delivery, again, I hope noble Lords will forgive me if I do not stray too far into territory that properly belongs to the Ministry of Defence. I will just get it wrong if I try to extemporise. Our formal response, once complete, will set out that picture more fully. I turn to two further points that the Committee raised. One is on consultation with the devolved Governments: I confirm that the Government have consulted them on the draft treaty text to ensure that there are no implications on devolved competences. We have kept them updated ahead of signature and will continue to engage with them on specific projects that fall within their respective competences. The noble Lord, Lord Johnson, raised a question on amendment and scrutiny under the CRaG Act—the Constitutional Reform and Governance Act. I am grateful to the committee for its clarity on this point, and I regret that the Explanatory Memorandum did not address this point. I also regret that some noble Lords clearly feel that this is a pattern, and I will definitely feed that back, because it is a proper challenge for your Lordships to make to the department. I will definitely take that back and look at it further. The Government take seriously the importance of Parliament’s role in scrutinising this relationship as it develops, and we will develop both these points, on devolved Administration consultation and amendment scrutiny, in our formal response. I will quickly respond to two other points that noble Lords raised. The noble Lord, Lord Bruce, raised the issue of Europol. Migration co-operation is indeed going to be part of the territory of the UK-EU summit in late November, which he mentioned. My personal view is that there is a strong need for better access to the information kept by the European Union and that that is in both the European Union’s and the UK’s interests. In Gibraltar, by the way, that information is now routinely shared as a result of the Gibraltar arrangement set up a few months ago, which both sides think is fantastic. So this is not a zero-sum game at all, and it will be good if there was more exchange and co-operation in that area. The noble Earl, Lord Courtown, also mentioned the question of the delivery of military support, which the Prime Minister commented on today. I do not want to exaggerate what has been discussed today. Today, as the noble Earl said, we are talking about accelerating deliveries of British lightweight multirole missiles—LMMs. By the way, they have proven extremely effective in dealing with jet-powered drones, which have transformed the daily experience of people who live in Kyiv and other Ukrainian cities. They have absolutely changed daily life in a way that you do not quite appreciate until you go there, as I was lucky enough to do a few weeks ago. We have already committed £1.6 billion to deliver more than 5,000 LMMs to Ukraine over the next four years, and we will accelerate a package of about £45 million of those missile allocations announced today to meet Ukraine’s most urgent winter requirements. The announcement today is therefore an acceleration of part of a pre-existing four-year commitment—that is the best way of putting it—to respond to the needs that are, sadly, pressing for Ukraine today. In conclusion, this treaty is a significant and necessary step in deepening our partnership with one of our most important allies at a moment when that partnership has rarely mattered more to the security of both countries. I am grateful to the committee for its scrutiny, which has sharpened the Government’s thinking on how this treaty will be judged, and I look forward to setting out our response to the committee’s report in full in the coming weeks. For today, I commend the treaty to the Grand Committee.

More from Lord Wood of Anfield (Lab)

Other recent Hansard contributions by the same speaker.

About Hansard

Hansard is the official verbatim record of proceedings in the UK Parliament. Every word spoken in the Commons and Lords is recorded and published — this page is a single contribution from that record.