B

Baroness Lawlor (Con)

Speaking in the House of Lords on 14 October 2026

Debate

Trade Unions (Right to Access Workplaces) Regulations 2026

Contribution

It is a pleasure to follow the noble Lord, Lord Balfe, and I have an answer for him. When I first went to Cambridge, I had come from Ireland, so I was not familiar with the British trade union movement. Two people I worked with in Cambridge who were not academics but were doing another job told me that they wanted work but could not get it because they were not in the trade union, yet when they applied to join a trade union and were admitted, they were taken out on strike, so they could not work. But they joined the union because they could not get work unless they joined it. Perhaps they are still members of that union; I have not kept in touch. Anyway, the noble Lord, Lord Balfe, is a very old and dear friend, but we disagree about this. He introduced me into your Lordships’ House, and I have great respect for him. I oppose these regulations because they detract from the efficient and productive operation of businesses and factories. I speak as a small employer, but an employer none the less. I would not be under these regulations, but heaven knows, if I had a bigger organisation, I would be. They bring unknown costs to employers—and they are unknown. From what my noble friend has said, there has been no reliable costing. They go against fairness and politicise the workplace. There will be a serious impact on efficiency because of the need to facilitate perhaps weekly meetings by vacating a room for them, providing IT backup and keeping compliance records. There will be a definite loss of productivity and profitability. Just think of small businesses which employ the threshold of 21 employees, or a much smaller business of maybe 10 employees but which is associated with other businesses owned by the same employer which have a much larger workforce. They will be included in these recognitions. There will be overhead costs for security, IT and energy, and moreover there will be disruption to working schedules, co-working, teamworking, and all the practices which make for good outcomes and successful productivity. My noble friend Lord Sharpe has drawn attention to the fact of our not having any reliable assessment provided by the Government of the costs and impact. It could be anything, judging by the code of practice stipulations for access in working hours, providing the rooms, digital liaison, and so on. The model for reasonableness laid down here is a weekly meeting. No wonder, as my noble friend Lord Sharpe has said, so few employers support these arrangements. Let us say each meeting takes an hour or more of working time. How much working time is lost for an employer over the whole year with a payroll of 21 or 30 or 40 employees, at a time when the total productivity and growth in this country is abysmal? Finally, the trade unions are, in essence, an arm of the Labour Party. I oppose the politicisation of the workplace and the labour movement. There are many affiliated unions. I take the point made by the noble Baroness, Lady O’Grady, that not every union is affiliated to the Labour Party, but many of them support it.

More from Baroness Lawlor (Con)

Other recent Hansard contributions by the same speaker.

About Hansard

Hansard is the official verbatim record of proceedings in the UK Parliament. Every word spoken in the Commons and Lords is recorded and published — this page is a single contribution from that record.