L

Lord Balfe (Con)

Speaking in the House of Lords on 14 October 2026

Debate

Trade Unions (Right to Access Workplaces) Regulations 2026

Contribution

My Lords, it is a great pleasure to speak in this debate and to note that, on the other Benches, my predecessor as president of BALPA, the noble Lord, Lord Monks, and my successor, the noble Lord, Lord Barber, are here. Sitting behind them is the noble Baroness, Lady O’Grady, who probably still has that fate to befall her, but let us see. I noticed that the Federation of Small Businesses got a mention. I seem to remember we recently introduced someone into this House on the Labour Benches who claimed to be from the Federation of Small Businesses—so maybe the Labour group will benefit from the wisdom of that particular person. The next point I would like to make is quite a simple one. As far as the unions I have been involved with have been concerned, this is not a payback from the Labour Party. BALPA has never given a penny to the Labour Party and the British Dietetic Association has never given a penny to the Labour Party. They are hardly getting a reward for doing nothing at all. They are good, strong trade unions in their sectors, doing a job to make the health service work for the dietitians and to make the aircraft industry work for those in BALPA. We talk about access to companies. I point out that there are difficulties in rostering pilots—it is very difficult to get them in the same country at the same time, let alone in the same room. This is one of the problems that has to be faced and dealt with. But whenever we bring up anything regarding better rights for trade unions, we come up with a barrage of objections —objections which, frankly, are spurious and need to be overcome. We in the European Union have dozens of airlines, and they all have structures similar to this. There is nothing exceptional about giving access to businesses to trade unions. I do not think that there is an aircraft company with under 21 employees, but this has never been a great difficulty. The prospect of bringing this in fulfils the demand which has been around for at least the last 20 years, and it is about time it was done. Access to workplaces is fundamental to trade unions. People are not going to be going down there every week, saying, “Oh, it’s Thursday, we’ve got to go down to Bristow’s aircraft and insist on getting through the door”. That is not the way it works. The way things work is that, if you get an employer who is determined to cause problems, they can cause them. I always go back to Eddy Shah—remember him?—who put all the objections he could find in the way of recognising the TU movement. I was delighted to be on the picket line at Grunwick with Shirley Williams, of blessed memory, and not necessarily with any party that I belonged to. Let us get real about this. If you want to mess things up, you can, but there is no reason why, if a responsible trade union—which at least 100% of them are, and maybe a few more than that—wants access, they should not have a right to put their claim before the workers. After all, it is the workers who sign up and it is their money that gets deducted from their pay package—it is their money that gets paid over. One of the big problems in all the unions I have served on has always been keeping up the membership and persuading people not to resign and that you are providing something for them. Most of the time what you are providing for them are welfare services; people join unions to be looked after, not to be campaigned against. I end where I did my last speech and ask the Conservative Party to have a fundamental rethink of the way it deals with the 2 million Conservative voters who hold trade union cards. These are not outsiders; these are our people, and they deserve a bit better than they sometimes hear.

More from Lord Balfe (Con)

Other recent Hansard contributions by the same speaker.

About Hansard

Hansard is the official verbatim record of proceedings in the UK Parliament. Every word spoken in the Commons and Lords is recorded and published — this page is a single contribution from that record.