L

Lord Balfe (Con)

Speaking in the House of Lords on 12 November 2026

Debate

Autumn Budget 2026

Contribution

My Lords, I congratulate the three maiden speakers we have heard and look forward to the fourth. It is always good to start with a bit of good news. I am the halfway point. After my speech, noble Lords will be heading towards the end of the debate. I am sure that will please a few people. This is a very odd debate because we know the Chancellor has ruled out cutting benefits in this Parliament. Two reports are being produced, one by Stephen Timms and another by Alan Milburn, on the future of various benefits. I have been to meetings with both and have had a private meeting with Stephen Timms. They are not postponing the decisions; they will produce reports that will start another large series of rows, as our House will say that we should implement the reports and a bit more, while the House of Commons, I suspect, will say that it does not want any cuts at all because their grannies will starve. We have hit a major problem, because, although we have put off the decisions, the fact is that the review does not foresee any reduction at all. My noble friend Lord Hammond, whom we do not see here very often these days, once said to me that his time in the Treasury was spent interviewing MPs from the Conservative Party, who said that they believed in savings but that they had to be made from Labour’s benefits, and people from the Labour Party, who said that they wanted him to invest to save. Investing involved spending government money, and he told me he had never seen any savings coming into the Treasury from doing so. I have a certain amount of sympathy with the Chancellor in trying to get his way round this conundrum. What has happened is that the Governments of both parties have failed to control public spending. It has been edged up for many years by a very compliant Civil Service. I was amazed when I learned that the Department for Work and Pensions was incentivising civil servants to clear people off the applications for certain benefits. They were being decided over the phone, and the key was that you were a good civil servant if you approved a lot of benefits, because if you did not approve them then you got letters from MPs and Ministers and life was made very difficult. So the first thing I say to the Government is let us look for cross-party agreement to get the benefits bill down, because it has to come down. My final point—we do not have that long—is that the freeze on middle-class aspiration has to stop. As some noble Lords know, I have been president of two TUC trade unions: those of the dietitians and the pilots. Both of them, especially the pilots, are high-earning, but they are also hard-working. Pilots are often on the other side of the world when their child has a birthday or is in the school play. Their wives—the pilots are mainly men—are, in effect, one-parent families. They have had this £100,000 threshold for several years now, and it appears that it will never be lifted. It is a new way of raising money, but it is also a new way of disincentivising people. It says to people: leave the country and move abroad, and do less work. We need a Government who put more incentive back into the achievers and strivers in society, to encourage them to work harder, to increase the wealth of the country, and, in doing so, to make the country and their families more prosperous, not to feel that the Government are the eternal enemy, as many of them feel at the moment.

More from Lord Balfe (Con)

Other recent Hansard contributions by the same speaker.

About Hansard

Hansard is the official verbatim record of proceedings in the UK Parliament. Every word spoken in the Commons and Lords is recorded and published — this page is a single contribution from that record.