Contribution
My Lords, the noble Lord, Lord Fox, said that this was a Budget playing around the margins. I scanned the papers this morning and, perhaps unsurprisingly, there was little mention of the Budget, apart from a telling comment piece in the Financial Times from Janan Ganesh. He talked about the literary device of bathos, a
“sudden drop from a grand and elevated tone to a mundane one”.
It seems that our English graduate Prime Minister has been studying literary forms, because what else could you describe it as, when we have gone from talking about ending 40 years of neoliberalism to this Budget. I can only hope, for the sake of the nation, that the Prime Minister and the Chancellor do not plan to follow the same model for the much-hyped 10-year plan, which we are promised before Christmas. I echo the call by noble Lord, Lord Fox, for us to have a proper debate on that.
We have seen how much change is being demanded around the world, from the Serbian elections to the American mid-terms, and there is no doubt that this nation is similarly hungry for change. Sir Kier Starmer promised it and failed to deliver. Andy Burnham has little time to demonstrate that he is on a significantly different path, despite the presence of so many neoliberal Blairite figures in his team. This is a Budget that, understandably, made the public wonder whether they were not trapped in a history in which “no change” is a recurring literary motif.
I turn to our debate. The noble Lord, Lord Pitt-Watson, said that this was an unpredictable world, but it is entirely predictable that we are on a fast-warming, unstable planet in the middle of an utterly unprecedented El Niño. My noble friend Lady Jones focused on the gaping hole on climate in the Budget, so I will not go over the same ground, but we are also in a world where biodiversity—the health of the more than human world—is in a terrible decline and, with it, our health as human animals. Last night, on the Health Bill, I talked about antimicrobial resistance. Just this morning, the latest national surveillance data came out, showing that the rate of reported, serious such infections has risen again in the past year: 406 cases per week. That is one case study of the general direction of travel of the health of our society.
Human bodies are the foundations of the economy. It is not finance or technology, but the living, breathing but far from flourishing bodies of our communities that are the foundations of our economy, as is the more than human world in which they operate. But I do not expect the Treasury to understand that, despite the fact that it has been given the overriding power by successive Governments to decide the direction of our society.
The noble Lord, Lord Pitt-Watson, said that we have resilient people and resilient businesses. I am afraid that is not a description that I or very many people in this country will recognise. We have a fragile society, fragile individuals and fragile businesses. That is not the fault or failure of individuals, but rather a failure of those 40 years of neoliberalism that the Prime Minister says he understands. Most businesses in the UK are small and medium-sized enterprises. They are, as many will say, the foundations of our economy. Yet we have an economy that is, in most sectors, overwhelmingly dominated by a handful of large multinational companies that have an oligarchic hold not just on our society but on our governing classes. Just this morning, a study came out about how awful ultra-processed food is—“big food” is providing terrible food and dominating our societies and our communities. That has economic implications, but I am afraid I do not expect the Treasury to understand that.
I have one final comment on the speech by the noble Lord, Lord Pitt-Watson. He said that we are
“one of the most geographically unequal large economies in the world”.
I have to declare an interest, as I have just this afternoon been elected president of the National Association of Local Councils. I hope the Treasury recognises—but I expect it will not—that it does not understand what is happening in communities up and down our land. It has to be local decision-making for local people, and they need the resources—parish and town councils are an important part of that—to start healing our society and economy.