Contribution
My Lords, I speak in the space reserved for the noble Lord, Lord Davies, who, sadly, cannot be with us. I do not think anyone will be surprised by what I have to say. I was a member of a trade union before I was ever a member of any political party, and that union was in the Civil Service. First, I have not had a single representation asking me to oppose this proposal—not one. Secondly, I have been involved in a trade union consistently since the age of 16. I think I am probably the only person in this House who has actually been the president of two TUC-affiliated trade unions, and I am probably also the only person in this House who has addressed the party conferences of both Labour and the Conservatives and the Trades Union Congress. I have certainly been around the block, as they say.
My experience of trade union work was founded in the welfare area. When I first became a trade union official I was 16 years old, believe it or not. This is not because I demonstrated a great ability; it was because no one could agree who should have the job. The Communist Party, the Socialist Party of Great Britain and various bits of the Labour Party decided that it should be me because they thought I would be the easiest one to push around. They were wrong, but in those very early days I learned that much of the work we did was around welfare. It was not industrial work at all. I have not had a day on strike in my life, and I have not had a day out of a trade union either. What I learned first about TUs is that we look after members. The first chairman I had was a Red Clydesider. “All that matters, Richard,” he used to say, “is whether they are in compliance”. That meant whether they had paid their subs, and if they had, they were looked after. We had many cases where we looked after members because they had problems. It was simple as that.
It is also worth remembering, and it comes up in this debate, that the employer often asked us to intervene. The call went out: “Do you think you could have a word with him or her, because you know what we’re up against here?” People who went sailing in thinking they had a cast-iron case to pursue discovered, when they spoke to their union rep, that they did not have much of a case at all. The union rep would say, “Look, Jim, we had this a couple of years ago, and this is how it ended up. What you want is not going to work”. We were as much a part of management as of any great plot to overthrow the state.
There is no legal requirement in this for employers to give paid time off. It all boils down to good will, and many things in the trade union movement do exactly that. People want a pleasant and happy workplace, and the job of a trade union is often to help build it. But if they cannot agree, they can resort to an employment tribunal, which is provided here. I would hope it does not have to be used very often, but if it does, complaints can be resolved by conciliation or by ACAS. It is not as though this is trying to build up disputes: it is actually a way of trying to solve them.
Finally, years ago we had a Prime Minister called Mrs Thatcher—she was never my favourite. When she was leader of the Conservative Party, central office had three people devoted to trade unions. They used to look at the agendas and go to the conferences, and they knew what they were talking about. My good friend John Bowers was there as the leader of that little band. I would ask that the present Conservative leadership look again at deepening its relations with the TUs, because I am afraid it gives the impression that it does not know what on earth is going on there, or how to influence it. It is quite easy to influence it: indeed, doing so is much the same as with my dog. Pat them on the head, give them a bit of love and you will be surprised by how far you can get.