Contribution
My Lords, I am grateful to the Minister for explaining and introducing this statutory instrument, to which, as he noted, I have tabled a regret amendment. As he pointed out, under this code of practice, if a dispute reaches an employment tribunal over the amount of time that a union representative proposes to take off, it is for the employer to show that the amount requested was not reasonable. That applies not only to existing trade union representatives but to the new statutory equality representatives created by the Act.
How is that a fair starting point for an employer who is trying to run an organisation? The employer is responsible for delivering the service, meeting the order, keeping the production line moving, ensuring adequate staffing, serving customers and, in the public sector, ensuring that taxpayers receive the services for which they have paid. Yet when an employee asks to spend paid working time away from their ordinary duties undertaking trade union activity, the presumption now operates against the employer. If there is a challenge, it is the employer who must prove that the amount requested was unreasonable.
The Government’s own impact assessment acknowledges a possible consequence. It states explicitly that employment tribunal claims may increase because the Bill places the burden of proof on the employer. The code states explicitly that what is reasonable will depend on the circumstances in each case. That is an invitation to test every case, and we can have little doubt that it will be exploited aggressively by the trade unions to cow employers into submission.
The second issue is the creation of statutory rights for trade union equality representatives. Let us be precise about what this means. The Government are not creating a separate, new job title in every workplace. They are giving existing employees, who are appointed or elected as union equality representatives, a statutory entitlement to spend reasonable paid working time carrying out equality-related union functions. But those functions are extraordinarily broad. They include promoting equality in the workplace, arranging equality-related training, consulting the employer on equality issues, obtaining and analysing workplace equality information, and preparing to carry out all those activities. These regulations could encompass requiring businesses to carry out document reviews, data analysis and meeting preparation. There could also be a serious data protection issue: equality and pay information may identify individuals, and much of it may constitute special-category personal data. The draft code was silent on whether employers might be expected to create new material rather than simply provide information which already exists. I suppose we should be grateful that the code specifies that employer and union activities at least complement one another to avoid duplication.
The Government’s own impact assessment said that there is likely to be a cost to employers from representatives spending more paid working time on facility time. It also accepts that statutory equality representatives are likely to impose some additional paid facility time cost. The cost, particularly in the public sector, is already unsustainable. The TaxPayers’ Alliance, analysing reported public sector facility time data for 2023-24, calculated that at least 21,639 trade union representatives were costing £98.2 million in facility time across the public sector. It found 993 employees spending 100% of their working hours on facility time. At the same time, a report by the Institute of Economic Affairs found direct public sector equality, diversity and inclusion staffing and training costs of approximately £557 million annually. The latest Civil Service facility time guidance removes the previous departmental mandatory cap, which was set at 0.1% of the pay bill, and replaces it with a suggested guideline at the same number. Meanwhile the unemployment Act repeals trade union facility time publications requirements. I wonder why.
The Government cannot even get unemployment down, yet when people are in work, they are legislating to give them more paid time away from their actual jobs. The taxpayer is asked to fund additional facility time without a quantified estimate of the recurring public sector cost. The private employer faces additional paid absence facilities administration, data protection questions and potential litigation. Public service managers face further pressure on staff time at a point when productivity remains below its pre-pandemic level. The Government’s paymasters really have bought some nice perks; I say to them: enjoy them while they last.
For those reasons, I regret this code and ask the Minister to explain why the Government believe that this is a good use of business resources, public sector staff time and taxpayers’ money.