L

Lord Sharpe of Epsom (Con)

Speaking in the House of Lords on 15 October 2026

Debate

Support for Family Businesses

Contribution

My Lords, I am also very grateful to the noble Lord, Lord Cameron of Dillington, for securing this debate and I congratulate the noble Lord, Lord McTague, on his excellent maiden speech, much of which deserves further consideration, if I may say so. I am extremely grateful for the opportunity to speak in this important debate on family businesses. At the outset, I should declare my small business interests as set out in the register. Family businesses are not simply another category on a Treasury spreadsheet, as my noble friend Lord Fuller eloquently explained. They are farms passed from one generation to another; the pub that has served the same village for decades; and the family-run hotel, shop, manufacturer or engineering company. They are businesses in which people have invested not simply their money but their lives. Yet one of the first major economic decisions that this Government took was to go after precisely those businesses through the family business tax. For farmers in particular, as we have heard from around the House, that was an extraordinary decision. At a time when we should have been strengthening domestic food production and improving our food security, the Government instead created enormous uncertainty for the people producing our food. Eventually, after months of protests and pressure, Ministers were forced into a partial U-turn. The original £1 million allowance for 100% APR and BPR was increased to £2.5 million per individual. However, as my noble friend Lord Elliott of Mickle Fell eloquently explained, farmers had already changed investment decisions. Families had already paid accountants, tax advisers and lawyers significant sums to reorganise their affairs. Some had considered selling land or other assets. Others had accelerated lifetime gifts and succession planning that they might otherwise never have undertaken. Last week, polling by the Country Land and Business Association showed that 89% of 700 rural family businesses had paused investment, with more than one-third holding back investment of more than £150,000. That has an enormous trickle-through effect on the wider economy. The attack has not stopped with inheritance tax. Family businesses have also had to absorb the Government’s enormous increase in employer national insurance. Raising the employer rate and dramatically lowering the threshold amounts to a tax increase on employers running to around £25 billion a year. Who do the Government imagine ultimately pays that? It is paid through fewer vacancies, lower wages, reduced investment and higher prices. It falls particularly heavily on labour-intensive family businesses, such as the pubs that the noble Lord, Lord Razzall, just mentioned, restaurants, hotels, shops and farms, which cannot simply automate every job or relocate their operations overseas. As the noble Lord, Lord Cameron, eloquently pointed out during his introduction, it disproportionately falls on those not in education, employment or training. Then we come to the Employment Rights Act. The Government’s own latest assessment suggests that its measures will impose around £1 billion of additional costs on businesses every year. Considerable uncertainty remains surrounding guaranteed hours, zero-hours arrangements and flexible working. The Government have to recognise that businesses do not all operate in the same way. Farming is seasonal, hospitality demands changes from week to week and tourism is seasonal. Many small family businesses depend on flexibility simply to remain viable. There is another approach: we on these Benches have made it clear that the next Conservative Government will repeal the family farm tax and family business tax, and restore the protections that allow viable businesses to pass between generations. We have committed to removing business rates from thousands of high street businesses, and our cheap power plan is designed to tackle one of the greatest structural disadvantages facing British businesses, which is the extraordinarily high cost of energy, as my noble friend Lady Neville-Rolfe pointed out. That is the difference between seeing business as something to tax and regulate and seeing business as the source of the investment, employment and prosperity on which everything else ultimately depends. The new Prime Minister himself acknowledged the problem. Before entering Downing Street, he promised to look again at the Government’s APR and BPR reforms. Farming organisations are now quite reasonably asking him to honour that commitment. However, the Prime Minister also championed a substantial VAT reduction for hospitality before entering No. 10. More than 800 hospitality businesses have since asked him to deliver on that position but, when he has had the opportunity, he has refused to commit to it. The forthcoming Budget presents an opportunity. After two years of higher employment taxes, new employment regulation, inheritance tax changes and continuing pressure on business costs, Britain needs to take a chainsaw to the taxes and regulatory burdens that are holding family businesses back. The Labour Party conspired to remove Keir Starmer. Surely the purpose of removing him was to change direction, as well as personnel. Will the forthcoming Budget mark a genuine change of course by reversing the damaging taxes imposed on family farms and family businesses, and by reducing the burden on employers, allowing these businesses once again to invest, employ and grow, or will this simply be the same policies under a different Prime Minister?

More from Lord Sharpe of Epsom (Con)

Other recent Hansard contributions by the same speaker.

About Hansard

Hansard is the official verbatim record of proceedings in the UK Parliament. Every word spoken in the Commons and Lords is recorded and published — this page is a single contribution from that record.