Support for Family Businesses
Thursday, 15 October 2026
Contributions
Question for Short Debate
Asked by
Lord Cameron of Dillington
To ask His Majesty’s Government what plans they have to support family businesses in the UK.
Baroness in Waiting/Government Whip (Baroness Dacres of Lewisham) (Lab)
My Lords, this debate should take one hour. I remind your Lordships to keep to time, as that is very precious today.
Lord Cameron of Dillington (CB)
My Lords, I must first declare that I am a member of a Somerset farming family, albeit now retired and living in Cornwall. I have also in my time started various small businesses, some of which failed but some did not. There are those who view entrepreneurial capitalism in a very bad light. They associate it with large, faceless corporations who pay the minimum of wages, treat their staff badly and ensure that the directors and shareholders take as much money out of the company as possible in as quick a time as possible, but, of course, there are almost no companies like this, and if there were they would not last long. Nevertheless, it is true that both the stock market and the Treasury are most interested in those businesses that give the largest possible financial returns. The Treasury even gives the impression that small businesses are expendable and that their long-term survival through the generations is not relevant to the nation’s economic growth. But these family businesses are the seed corn of our future economic growth. They are our best hope and produce a range of wider benefits that are not recognised by the markets or policymakers. I remember Gordon Brown saying to me that new Labour was all about encouraging greater economic growth but getting the businesses involved to give back more to society. That is almost exactly what family businesses do. They are likely to treat their staff as family and even their customers as such. The business’s reputation is their reputation and often they will go beyond the call of duty to protect it. Think of the voluntary work that these families put into their community, through local Round Tables, Rotary clubs, or serving on local charities or councils. They are the pillars that make their community a community. They are immensely hard-working. In my rural world, if you add up all the hours put into the farming or family business by the family, including the children, it is possible that they are working for less than the minimum wage, as a whole. These family businesses make up 93% of all UK businesses. They generate trillions of pounds of turnover and provide 57% of private sector employment—some 15.8 million employees. They contribute £425 billion per annum to the UK Exchequer. They drive innovation, employment and, as I have said, community stability. We really are a nation of shopkeepers, in its widest sense, which now includes highly technical businesses at the cutting edge of their fields, harnessing the science and research that the nation also excels at. Family enterprises are the lifeblood of our nation, more so than most of our competitors; some employ fewer than five people and some employ thousands. On how we enable more of the former to become the latter, our financial success as a country depends. So, what do we have to do? First, we have to stop looking at these hard-working families as a go-to place to find money whenever the Chancellor needs more funds for triple-lock pensions or ever more generous social services. Many of these family businesses have minimal spare revenue available even if, over the years and generations—by dint of borrowing and sheer hard work—they have built up considerable capital assets in their business, most of which have been paid for out of income already taxed. The Government must also stop imposing extra costs on these businesses. They almost all say that they would employ more non-family staff if they did not cost so much. In 2020, employing a 21 year-old cost £17,000 per annum, but now, in 2026, owing to minimum wage changes, it costs £29,600 per annum. No small business can afford to employ an untrained 21 year-old at that price, so who loses? The 21 year-old NEETs lose, of course. Their lives become hopeless, just when they should be setting out on their careers. The other loser is the Treasury, because it now has to pay benefits to these unemployed 21 year-olds, as opposed to receiving their lifelong payments of tax. What else can we do? Training and access to capital are two areas for improvement that are best served locally. The self-employed, particularly the young—my knowledge comes from the rural young—are happy to pay for training in simple stuff, such as drawing up budgets, cash flows and marketing campaigns, which are really important if you want to earn your own money by mending bikes, motorbikes or computers, or fitting routers into houses and businesses, or just cleaning windows. I know that it sounds like small fry from the Treasury’s point of view, but helping the next generation to pay taxes rather than draw the dole must make a difference. Who knows? Some may one day turn into one of the 300 or so UK family businesses with turnovers in excess of £500 million; but they would all have started small. The other great stumbling block for these businesses is when they need capital to expand, employ more staff, buy new equipment and so on. Unless they have the right contacts, it is difficult for those hard-working heroes to know where to turn. Local bank managers no longer exist. They need help, guidance and access to funding, preferably local funding, which could buy equity in these would-be expanding businesses. Such local investment funds, allied to training, would be immensely helpful to our nation’s growth, and these local growth funds may even end up being self-funding if the share values go up. I realise that the Government recently produced their SME strategy, which picks up on some of these issues, but I hope that this debate strengthens their resolve to pursue this agenda with a real sense of purpose, knowing that our whole economy and its future growth depend on how successful they are. Above all, we need politicians from all parties to start worrying less about how we spend government money and more about how we can earn it. For some reason this seems a hard ask among politicians, but they should all bear in mind that apart from government borrowing, which must be nearing its limits, every penny spent by government has first to be earned by a business. Every Chancellor before a Budget should have to write that out 100 times: “Every penny spent by government has first to be earned by a business”. We should treat these families running their own businesses as national heroes and value them accordingly. If we are going to kick-start our nation and its economy out of its current doldrums, then these are the people we need. Their efforts should make us proud, but they need all the support we can give them. I look forward to the maiden speech of the noble Lord, Lord McTague, and meanwhile I beg to move.
Lord McTague (Lab) (Maiden Speech)
My Lords, I start with my thanks to the Clerk of the Parliaments, Black Rod, the doorkeepers and the officials for their invaluable support and guidance over the last few weeks. I also thank Members on all sides of the House for their warm welcome. This welcome is especially true of my noble friends Lord Wilson of Sedgefield and Lady Armstrong of Hill Top, and I thank them again. But most of all I thank my wife Sue and my entire family for all their love and support that makes this possible. I think this surreal experience was best summed up by the noble Lord, Lord Cromwell, when he said to me on my entrance to the House: “Welcome to Hogwarts”. Growing up in Birmingham, I never thought this moment was even remotely possible. I did not start life with the proverbial silver spoon. Both my mother and father spent their childhoods in orphanages, but together they created a loving, secure home. Like many baby boomers, I was the first member of my family to go to university. But by the time I was 30 and fed up with the corporate world, I hungered for more purpose and freedom, so in 1987 I started my first business and moved to a village in County Durham. It was there that I met my new MP for the constituency, one Tony Blair. This was the start of the revolution in the Labour Party, and as a small-business owner and a member of that party, I fitted right in. A few years later, I was introduced to a quirky business organisation called the Federation of Small Businesses. Although it had more than 200,000 members, it was struggling to influence government policy. I wanted to change this, so 30 years later I became its national chair, and it is now a brilliant advocate for the nearly 6 million people running small businesses in the UK. It has decided to follow an evidence-led, solution-focused approach which I think a lot of Members of this House will appreciate. All of this means that I feel well-placed to contribute to the substance of today’s debate. It is a debate I feel privileged to be part of and I thank the noble Lord, Lord Cameron of Dillington, for moving it because I share almost all his views on this subject. I passionately believe that small businesses are the key to generating growth in the UK. There is a vast range of businesses that could be defined as family businesses, but they have widely different needs. The biggest issue for large, wealthy family businesses, as has been mentioned on several occasions, is the limit of £2.5 million per estate on the value of assets eligible for 100% property relief. But this is a very small group. Most small businesses will feel no impact from this change. Although I sympathise with the families that run asset-rich but cash-poor businesses, this is not the most important issue affecting small businesses. There are many more issues, several of which were touched on by the noble Lord, Lord Cameron, including business rates, access to finance and, in particular, the regulation of labour. We need to focus on those much bigger issues. But just coming back to the fact that some businesses feel that, in effect, the changes to inheritance tax rule out generation succession, I think we should look at what happens in Germany. They offer special relief for family business succession if the heirs continue to run the business for a continuous period of seven years and maintain payroll levels. Given the healthy state of the German Mittelstand, I think the Minister should look at this as an option for the UK.
The Lord Bishop of Newcastle
My Lords, it is a great pleasure to follow the noble Lord, Lord McTague, and to offer him the warm congratulations of the House and of these Benches on his excellent maiden speech. Although Birmingham has the honour of being his birthplace, the north-east has benefited from his commitment for nearly 40 years. As a fellow northerner, I am delighted to welcome another passionate champion of our region. He remains a long-suffering supporter of Birmingham City. As a follower of Newcastle United, I certainly share some of the footballing challenge in the current landscape. We share a mutual friend in John McCabe, chief executive of the North East Chamber of Commerce, and a conviction that our region has much to contribute to the nation’s future. An engineering graduate of Aston University, the noble Lord brings practical understanding and extensive business experience. Through a decade in senior leadership at the Federation of Small Businesses, including his service as national chair, a role from which he stood down on joining this House, he has championed entrepreneurs across the country. His OBE for services to small businesses recognised that considerable contribution. At a time when growth is firmly on the agenda, he brings wisdom about the people whose enterprise, determination and occasional sleepless nights help to make that possible. His commitment to the north-east extends through his work with the FSB, the CBI and the Legacy Learning Trust in Middlesbrough. He brings valuable experience of the connections between education, opportunity and economic flourishing. I particularly welcome his recognition of the contribution that SMEs can make to tackling the climate crisis. Amid competing demands, that recognition offers a prophetic witness. Caring for our planet belongs at the heart of our economic future. With his wife Sue, four children and nine grandchildren, the noble Lord also has plenty of experience of listening to different views—excellent preparation for your Lordships’ House. We warmly welcome him and look forward to the practical wisdom, insight and concern for the common good that he will bring to our deliberations. I turn now to the debate, and I am grateful to the noble Lord, Lord Cameron, for bringing it to your Lordships’ House. The north-east has always had an entrepreneurial spirit. Greggs began as a family business just around the corner from where I live. Ringtons, Barbour and Fenwick are enduring examples of family ownership—two rooted in Newcastle upon Tyne, the third in South Shields; all founded over a century ago. In Newcastle city centre’s Grainger Market, Robinson’s has served customers since 1929. Britain’s longest established family pet store, it is now run by the third generation of the family and has combined continuity with innovation in pet nutrition and care, including the first commercially available cat-scratching posts in Britain. These businesses remind us that enterprise is woven into the life of a place. Alongside familiar names are the farms, builders, cafés, shops and manufacturers whose work sustains our communities and helps build resilience. In that vein, I am particularly interested in the contribution that family businesses make to the common good. The business provides livelihoods but can also offer belonging and opportunity—a first job, an apprenticeship or an employer willing to recognise someone’s potential. Family businesses are resilient and creative but face considerable pressures, as the noble Lord, Lord Cameron, said. Higher employment costs, including employer national insurance contributions, energy bills and uncertainty over succession, all affect their capacity to invest and recruit. Public services need to be funded fairly. A business’s value may lie in premises, machinery or land, with limited cash available. Changes affecting succession should be assessed against their consequences for employment, investment and continuity. I welcome His Majesty's Government’s trade and industrial strategies. Their implementation should explicitly recognise the distinctive contribution of family businesses, including those outside the sectors usually associated with high growth. As devolution develops, we have an opportunity to encourage new family enterprises and strengthen existing ones, opening opportunities closer to home. In rural Northumberland, that requires reliable connectivity, affordable housing and transport. An apprenticeship offers little opportunity if a young person cannot reach the workplace. That brings me to young people outside education, employment or training. Behind each statistic is someone whose gifts we risk overlooking. Fenwick and the Centre for Social Justice brought together more than 120 front-line organisations, charities and employers through a Newcastle Big Listen to consider this challenge. The resulting report calls for dedicated youth and employment support within the region’s devolution arrangements. Here is a family business using its convening power to address a social concern. On 17 November, a national apprenticeship and education event, “Skills Northeast”, takes place at Newcastle Civic Centre. It will connect young people with employers, colleges and training providers. Such connections can make an unfamiliar career feel possible. Could the Minister explain how Skills England is working with family businesses to expand apprenticeship opportunities, particularly for smaller employers that lack dedicated recruitment teams? Practical support must also be accessible. I welcome the Business Growth Service and Neil Davy’s membership of the Small Business Regulatory Taskforce, bringing the experience of Family Business UK into that work. Can the Minister update us on progress in reducing administrative burdens while maintaining essential protections? Will the growth service offer tailored support for family firms, including succession planning? A clear working definition of family businesses would also help His Majesty’s Government to understand who is using its services and whether support reaches those who need it. Family businesses are part of our economic lifeblood and an enduring source of civic pride. As the Budget approaches, I hope Ministers will recognise their potential to drive innovation, create opportunities and sustain communities. Promoting family businesses means investing in the people and places they serve and giving the next generation the confidence to build upon what it receives.
Lord Elliott of Mickle Fell (Con)
My Lords, I congratulate the noble Lord, Lord McTague, on his excellent maiden speech. I was particularly interested to hear about his time as chairman of the Federation of Small Businesses. As president of a much newer business organisation, the Jobs Foundation, as in the register, I look forward to discussing these and other matters over many years to come. I also congratulate the noble Lord, Lord Cameron of Dillington, on opening this debate with an excellent speech. As we have heard articulated powerfully, family businesses occupy a special place at the heart of our economy. Some of the most trusted brands on our high streets, such as Marks and Spencer, began as family businesses, as did our largest private sector employer, Tesco, which my noble friend Lady Neville-Rolfe is well-acquainted with. In my role at the Jobs Foundation, I visit businesses across the country on a weekly basis. As a charity focused on helping people into meaningful work, we see how family businesses care particularly deeply about how they look after their employees and their families and how they support their local communities. At the beginning of the year, the Jobs Foundation released a poll of family business owners conducted by Whitestone Insight. The findings show that they share many similar concerns to other businesses: these include, to name just three, high energy costs, high employment costs and high levels of taxation. I have spoken on these issues many times in your Lordships’ House, and they remain key issues, but they are not my focus this afternoon. The same polling also identified how family businesses are finding it increasingly challenging to pass on their business to future generations, a point made by the noble Lord, Lord McTague, in his maiden speech. This concern is borne out in conversations I have had across the country. The business property relief changes in the 2024 Budget have impacted family businesses in three main ways: first, they make them look to the short term rather than the long term; secondly, they risk breaking up asset-rich family businesses; and, thirdly, they force many heirs to sell up, impacting the very soul of the company. On the first point, and the change of focus from long term to short term, of all the companies in the UK, family businesses undoubtedly have the longest time horizon. They are literally the most patient capital we have. They are not fixated on the next quarter’s results; they have a decades-long time horizon that reinforces their sustainability as organisations and ensures they are not transient parts of their local community. With the BPR changes, family businesses are forced to divert their focus to short-term profit over long-term investment. In the words of Christopher Nieper, CEO of the fashion company David Nieper: “The incentive to build for the long term has gone”. Forcing family businesses to focus on short-term profit undermines the very long-term patient capital they represent, a quality so rightly extolled in your Lordships’ House. Secondly, the BPR changes risk forcing family businesses to sell assets, lowering investment. There are many asset-rich but cash-poor family businesses. Take the example of a port: there are many family-owned ports in the UK. Most of their business is asset-based and therefore, as with farms, they will probably not have the cash to pay a large inheritance tax bill. If the owner of a port dies, how are their children meant to pay the tax bill? Are they supposed to sell the land, cranes, warehouses and other assets, or the whole business? This conundrum will face family businesses of all shapes and sizes over the coming years now that the BPR changes have come into effect. This brings me to my third and final point. Many heirs will be forced to sell their family’s business, with all the consequences that brings. In the words of one owner I spoke to recently: “Speaking frankly, it won’t affect me and my family when I die. My family will be able to pay the inheritance tax bill from the sale and still live a very good life. But what I worry about is my team and how the new owners will treat them. They are the ones who will lose out from the BPR changes”. Many family businesses will be sold under new ownership. They risk becoming a profit line, which can be axed if it is not performing, rather than a labour of love to be nurtured and cared for through good times and bad. To quote Andrew Lynas, the group manager director of Lynas Foodservice in Northern Ireland, family businesses “care more deeply about their staff. People aren’t just a number on a payroll—they’re known by name”. Surely we have a duty to protect family businesses so that they can continue to support their employees and their local communities. In the words of the Chancellor just a few weeks ago in Liverpool: “It is businesses that will create the country’s jobs and wealth and growth”. That is very true, and it is doubly true for family businesses.
Lord Fuller (Con)
My Lords, if this country is to get the long-term growth it craves, it needs to recognise that allocating that patient capital, combined with the special long-term alignment of interest which comes from the application of generational talent and entrepreneurial zip, is the place to start. Of course, we are lucky to have the FTSE 100, but increasingly it flatters us, as global companies just lodge in London but generate their revenue elsewhere. Yes, they employ lawyers and accountants, and we are grateful for that particular tax gusher, but the stock market is no longer a barometer of the British economy. That is why family businesses, out there in the real economy, are so important. There are nearly 5 million of them and they employ over 15 million workers, about half the total number of people in employment. These companies are not focused on EBITDA, next quarter’s profits or mollifying investors; no, family businesses are actually interested in their customers and their staff. They are able to innovate and test ideas precisely because they do not need to speak to the lawyers or accountants first. These businesses are sticky and that is good. They pay their taxes. Their management participates in local civic society. They should be cherished, not demonised. They have grown by being handed down in trust over the generations, improving society with every turn of that handle. The Prime Minister wants growth in every postcode. I have got news for him: family businesses exist in every postcode, each driving prosperity, creating opportunities and empowering communities in their own special way. They are in regional cities, market towns, coastal communities and the countryside. They do not just contribute to the economy; they are the local economy. The corner shop and the convenience store are at one end, while others have grown to be household names, such as JCB, Rix from Hull—which will have featured in the previous debate—the Rigby Group, Laing O’Rourke, Boodles and Swire. It would be nice if we could encourage a few more family businesses to grow and do likewise, but instead of encouraging small firms to become big ones, Labour is taxing them to death: new employment taxes on family restaurants, new steel and cement taxes on family builders, new tourism taxes on family-run hotels, crippling increases in rates for family-run pubs, and inheritance taxes that consume cash and divert to less productive assets such as life insurance. But there are more insults, such as the double taxation of dividends, which can be paid only on profits, to pay for things such as life insurance, which I mentioned. New pension taxes are damaging the long-term stability of mid-range businesses where the proprietors own the buildings in their fund. Jeremy Clarkson hit the nail on the head when he said that you would need to be mad to set up a business in this country now, with all the risk and none of the reward. Worse, our family businesses are being taxed to death in a discriminatory way that no other sector has to suffer, making them vulnerable for acquisition by debt-fuelled private equity—a point that was made powerfully in the Financial Times only this morning. APR and BPR are not visited on hedge funds, pension funds, sovereign wealth, private equity or private companies. Why are the Government so prejudiced against this particular type of business in our nation of shopkeepers? We need the entrepreneurs among the cohort of 90% of all private businesses in our nation. Entrepreneurship is a good thing, but it does not happen by itself; it must be nurtured, cherished and encouraged, and, as in my own case, it must be learned from a young age. I sat round the kitchen table and learned and I printed fertilizer bags in the holidays—a job that nobody else in the family wanted to do. We all need to start at the bottom. I am a member of several businesses owned by a remarkable group of unrelated families in Great Yarmouth. Our team works hard; we play an important part in feeding our nation, in a rags-to-riches story hewn from three generations of effort. Our business traces its roots back over 200 years, to 1815. My grandfather joined as the office boy, my father succeeded him as chairman, and now I hold the reins. As an Olympic sprinter, grandpa told me that I needed to run 110 yards to everybody else’s 100 because I was in the family, so that is what I have done. Like so many family-owned businesses, it is what we do: hard work, dedication, commitment and leadership. We are the ones who risk it all to make our birthright a success or go bankrupt. That is the reality of what we all do in our ways. Do the Government encourage these qualities? Of course not. We just have the entitled politics of envy and grievance. Youngsters who might want to get on and become entrepreneurs are not even starting. Worse, our brightest and best are going to Dubai, Milan or Sydney. That is why we are seeing the fire sale of businesses and properties, with overseas firms engaged in an industrial hoovering up of some of our best firms, damaging future tax revenues. It sets the wrong tone. It is inexplicable. It is irrational. It is an act of self-harm. As chairman of our business, last month I was proud to award two long service medals to Stephen Patterson and Simon Beales for 45 and 40 years’ respective service to our family business. Where is the ministerial thanks to people like them—people out in the provinces, for the most part, who are nimble, industrious and innovative? In this debate, I want to speak for the 15 million people who are employed by family graft, including that butcher’s in Devon that is Britain’s oldest established family business, which has been going for 400 years. We need such businesses to grow. The Government should incentivise them to grow and make them feel loved. Our family businesses are the solution, not the problem, to our growth; if only the Government could see that for themselves, we would all be richer for it.
Baroness Neville-Rolfe (Con)
My Lords, I congratulate the noble Lord, Lord Cameron of Dillington, on securing this debate and on his rousing speech. Like him, I come from a farming background. Following a difficult period in the 1960s, our farm was sold and my father retrained and set up a new business as an agricultural economist, mainly in Brussels, working there until he was well past 70, so noble Lords can see that small business and enterprise are in my DNA. Indeed, during my 15 years at Tesco, I worked hard to encourage the small supply base with special procurement arrangements to assist dairy farmers and small suppliers in Cornwall, Scotland, Northern Ireland and Wales, so that they could get their products listed. Noble Lords will be familiar with the importance I have consistently placed on supporting small and medium-sized enterprises, sometimes with the help of the Federation of Small Businesses, through our debates, scrutiny of government policy and consideration of legislation. My recent amendments to the Financial Services and Markets Bill are one example. I was delighted that the Government accepted the importance of supporting smaller operators by agreeing to add proportionality as a principle to that Bill. Many businesses start as family businesses, and there is a good reason for this. Starting out in business requires trust, and it is often easier to trust family. Family members are more likely to provide a loan or even take a stake in the business, and there is less risk of the business being torn apart if it runs into trouble, reflecting the benefit of familial links. My belief is that this is true of all ethnicities. An even more important driver of trust is the involvement of one’s children in one’s business. It is natural to train one’s children, teach them one’s trade and want them to take over one’s business on retirement or death. The parent can be more secure in the knowledge that his or her heir knows the business: every good or boggy field on a farm, different customers in a retail or restaurant business, good beer, service and ambience in a pub, and processes and design in an engineering or architecture business. It is against this background that this Government’s assault on families through IHT and the farm and family business taxes are so troubling. These have generated a dangerous gloom. Concessions made earlier this year do not solve the problem, and the sums raised will be small. The Reeves policy on this was profoundly mistaken, for reasons that my noble friend Lord Elliott of Mickle Fell set out so well. It is not as though this is in isolation. These businesses are being hit by the triple whammy of the Reeves increases in national insurance—the jobs tax; the hike in the minimum wage, especially for the young, which the noble Lord, Lord Cameron, highlighted in his example; and the Employment Rights Act, the full horror of which is beginning to emerge, as we heard yesterday in the debate on SIs implementing trade union involvement. Business rates are also rising for all but the smallest, with a double hit arising from a rates rise on top of a revaluation. Wider cost pressures and regulation are also affecting family firms. The worst of these is high energy prices in the UK—four times those in the US and, according to some estimates, up to six times those in China—with trouble in the Middle East and eastern Europe increasing the pressure every day. This is closely followed by our planning and building regulation system. The Government’s attempted reforms seem to be failing, at least for small housebuilders—often family firms whose share of the construction market has plummeted in recent years and resulted in insolvencies, such as that of Devonshire Homes in the south-west. I do not want to end on a depressing note. We have an extraordinary capacity for enterprise, innovation and ambition in this country. As an example, consider the stories behind some of our most well-known businesses, involving Michael Marks and Tom Spencer, John and Mary Ann Sainsbury, and, more recently, William Morrison of Morrisons and Jack Cohen of Tesco. By chance, the mention of the nation of shopkeepers by the noble Lord, Lord Cameron, and indeed by my noble friend Lord Fuller, chimed with this. These people all had the confidence from modest beginnings to take risks, invest their own resources and build some of the most successful businesses in the world, providing good jobs for literally hundreds of thousands of people. As the budget approaches, the Government need to consider how they can kick-start the enterprise lurking in family firms. They need to cancel the IHT death taxes, re-examine plans for business rates, which are hitting hospitality particularly hard, halve NICs for under-25s, and ease the ever-growing burden of regulation, especially on housing and the countryside. Above all, given the limits imposed by the troubling fiscal situation, they must try to do no harm, avoiding new taxes on family businesses and the inevitable impact on growth.
Lord Razzall (LD)
My Lords, first, I congratulate the noble Lord, Lord McTague, and welcome his contributions to the House, which we look forward to very much. Like others, I thank the noble Lord, Lord Cameron, for introducing this topic, because there is no doubt about the significance of family businesses to the economy of the UK. As I think the noble Lord, Lord Fuller, indicated, there are probably over 5 million family businesses currently and, according to the Library, 93% of all private sector firms in the UK are family businesses. The estimate in 2023, which may have been updated since then, was that total gross value added by family businesses was £985 billion and, as the noble Lord, Lord Cameron, indicated, the total taxes paid then were over £400 billion, so there is no doubt of the significance of these businesses. Family businesses have many characteristics similar to all SMEs in the challenges that are posed by the Government, except for one, which a number of your Lordships have mentioned. Because of the structure of family businesses, where assets are often passed from generation to generation, they are particularly vulnerable to changes in inheritance tax. As the noble Lords, Lord McTague and Lord Elliott, have indicated, the introduction of the £2.5 million per estate limit on the value of assets eligible for 100% agricultural business property relief has hit large family farming businesses particularly hard. But recent activity by the Government has materially affected all SMEs, particularly in the service and hospitality sectors. The noble Baroness, Lady Neville-Rolfe, mentioned three key decisions by this Government that have had an obvious impact. First, there is the increase in the minimum wage, which from these Benches we support, but which has had a significant impact when combined with the other two. The second decision was the increase in employer NICs from 13.8% to 15%, and the third decision was the proposed restrictions on zero-hours contracts, which are so vital for young people, particularly in the hospitality sector. To take the example of my local pub in Wiltshire, owned by two locals and often frequented by me—and, dare I disclose, the noble Baroness, Lady Neville-Rolfe—this is the sort of small pub that the countryside really requires. When these three measures were brought in by the Government, I asked the management what they thought the costs were—the effect of those three increases—and it came to £75,000 per annum. If we multiply those costs across the country, we can see what an own goal Rachel Reeves scored. I do not go as far as the hyperbole of the noble Lord, Lord Fuller, over the tax increases made by this Government, but avoiding the increase in PAYE payments by Rachel Reeves ignored the damaging effect of these increases. Finally, noble Lords would not expect me not to bring up Europe—I like that the noble Baroness, Lady Neville-Rolfe, is laughing. Many small family businesses have stopped trying to sell into Europe due to the problems of negotiating the required paperwork. Any progress by this Government in breaking down our trade barriers to Europe would disproportionately affect small businesses.
Lord Sharpe of Epsom (Con)
My Lords, I am also very grateful to the noble Lord, Lord Cameron of Dillington, for securing this debate and I congratulate the noble Lord, Lord McTague, on his excellent maiden speech, much of which deserves further consideration, if I may say so. I am extremely grateful for the opportunity to speak in this important debate on family businesses. At the outset, I should declare my small business interests as set out in the register. Family businesses are not simply another category on a Treasury spreadsheet, as my noble friend Lord Fuller eloquently explained. They are farms passed from one generation to another; the pub that has served the same village for decades; and the family-run hotel, shop, manufacturer or engineering company. They are businesses in which people have invested not simply their money but their lives. Yet one of the first major economic decisions that this Government took was to go after precisely those businesses through the family business tax. For farmers in particular, as we have heard from around the House, that was an extraordinary decision. At a time when we should have been strengthening domestic food production and improving our food security, the Government instead created enormous uncertainty for the people producing our food. Eventually, after months of protests and pressure, Ministers were forced into a partial U-turn. The original £1 million allowance for 100% APR and BPR was increased to £2.5 million per individual. However, as my noble friend Lord Elliott of Mickle Fell eloquently explained, farmers had already changed investment decisions. Families had already paid accountants, tax advisers and lawyers significant sums to reorganise their affairs. Some had considered selling land or other assets. Others had accelerated lifetime gifts and succession planning that they might otherwise never have undertaken. Last week, polling by the Country Land and Business Association showed that 89% of 700 rural family businesses had paused investment, with more than one-third holding back investment of more than £150,000. That has an enormous trickle-through effect on the wider economy. The attack has not stopped with inheritance tax. Family businesses have also had to absorb the Government’s enormous increase in employer national insurance. Raising the employer rate and dramatically lowering the threshold amounts to a tax increase on employers running to around £25 billion a year. Who do the Government imagine ultimately pays that? It is paid through fewer vacancies, lower wages, reduced investment and higher prices. It falls particularly heavily on labour-intensive family businesses, such as the pubs that the noble Lord, Lord Razzall, just mentioned, restaurants, hotels, shops and farms, which cannot simply automate every job or relocate their operations overseas. As the noble Lord, Lord Cameron, eloquently pointed out during his introduction, it disproportionately falls on those not in education, employment or training. Then we come to the Employment Rights Act. The Government’s own latest assessment suggests that its measures will impose around £1 billion of additional costs on businesses every year. Considerable uncertainty remains surrounding guaranteed hours, zero-hours arrangements and flexible working. The Government have to recognise that businesses do not all operate in the same way. Farming is seasonal, hospitality demands changes from week to week and tourism is seasonal. Many small family businesses depend on flexibility simply to remain viable. There is another approach: we on these Benches have made it clear that the next Conservative Government will repeal the family farm tax and family business tax, and restore the protections that allow viable businesses to pass between generations. We have committed to removing business rates from thousands of high street businesses, and our cheap power plan is designed to tackle one of the greatest structural disadvantages facing British businesses, which is the extraordinarily high cost of energy, as my noble friend Lady Neville-Rolfe pointed out. That is the difference between seeing business as something to tax and regulate and seeing business as the source of the investment, employment and prosperity on which everything else ultimately depends. The new Prime Minister himself acknowledged the problem. Before entering Downing Street, he promised to look again at the Government’s APR and BPR reforms. Farming organisations are now quite reasonably asking him to honour that commitment. However, the Prime Minister also championed a substantial VAT reduction for hospitality before entering No. 10. More than 800 hospitality businesses have since asked him to deliver on that position but, when he has had the opportunity, he has refused to commit to it. The forthcoming Budget presents an opportunity. After two years of higher employment taxes, new employment regulation, inheritance tax changes and continuing pressure on business costs, Britain needs to take a chainsaw to the taxes and regulatory burdens that are holding family businesses back. The Labour Party conspired to remove Keir Starmer. Surely the purpose of removing him was to change direction, as well as personnel. Will the forthcoming Budget mark a genuine change of course by reversing the damaging taxes imposed on family farms and family businesses, and by reducing the burden on employers, allowing these businesses once again to invest, employ and grow, or will this simply be the same policies under a different Prime Minister?
The Parliamentary Under-Secretary of State, Department for Business and Trade (Lord Leong) (Lab)
My Lords, I thank the noble Lord, Lord Cameron of Dillington, for securing this debate and all noble Lords for their contributions. I congratulate my noble friend Lord McTague on his maiden speech. With 30 years’ experience of running his own businesses and as a former chair of the Federation of Small Businesses, he will bring an enormous contribution to our debates in this House. We look forward to hearing much more from him. This is a timed debate, so I will endeavour to answer as many questions as I can. If I do not have time, I will write to all noble Lords and place a copy of the letter in the Library. Family businesses touch our lives every single day: the milk in our tea, the bread on our table, the shop on the high street. Consider how many family business might touch our lives before we have even stepped outside our front door: the Harrison Spinks mattress we wake up on; the Baylis & Harding handwash in the bathroom; the Yorkshire Tea in our cup; the Mornflake porridge in our bowl; and the Warburtons bread in our toaster. Then, perhaps, we put on a pair of Crockett & Jones shoes and a Barbour jacket before we leave the house. Behind each family product is families who have invested, taken risks, created jobs and built reputations over generations. Their businesses are woven into our daily lives. Their futures matter in every community where they employ, supply and serve. Behind each is a family that has taken a risk, built a reputation and accepted responsibility for other people’s livelihoods. When a family manufacturer invests in a market town or a village business takes on an apprentice, the benefits remain in that community for many years to come. These businesses often measure success in generations. Having spent more than 45 years building and running businesses, I understand something of that outlook. I know the satisfaction of winning a customer and seeing an employee develop. I also know the pressure of meeting payroll when an invoice remains unpaid. When your family’s savings, livelihood and reputation are invested in the business, those pressures follow you home, so I recognise why owners worry about energy bills, borrowing costs, business rates and employment costs, including national insurance. They experience those pressures together, alongside the time required to understand changing rules. For a small firm without a finance department or an HR team, the owner bears the burden directly. Government must understand that reality: our support must be accessible, our requirements proportionate and our implementation workable. That is the purpose behind our small business plan: helping firms manage today’s pressures while building the confidence and capacity to grow. Let me set out what that means in practice. First, on getting paid, a business can have a healthy order book and still face a cash flow crisis. An overdue invoice can mean postponing equipment, turning down work or abandoning plans to recruit. Through our Commercial Payments Bill and the support of the noble Lord opposite, we are pursuing a maximum payment period of six days for contracts within scope, stronger powers for the Small Business Commissioner and a ban on construction retentions. A small family supplier should be able to challenge poor payment practices with confidence. Work delivered should mean payment received. Secondly, on access to finance and advice, family owners may want to expand while retaining control of the enterprise they have built. Finance must respond to that ambition. The British Business Bank’s five-year strategy includes 85,000 new start-up loans. For established smaller firms, the growth guarantee scheme supports access to lending for investment and growth. Through the business growth service and the growth hubs throughout the country, we are also making advice easier to find. Mid-market businesses face their own challenges around investment, management and exporting. The Northern 500 initiative will bring ambitious mid-sized northern businesses together with mayors, government and private sector partners to support their growth. Thirdly, on investing in people and productivity, succession requires preparation, developing future leaders, bringing in expertise and giving the next generation room to contribute. The Government’s Help to Grow: Management programme provides eligible leaders with training and mentoring backed by a 90% government subsidy. Our digital adoption work helps business to assess how technology and AI can improve productivity. Family firms also give many young people their first chance. Many noble Lords have asked about skills. In England, apprenticeship training is fully funded for eligible under-25s at non-levy paying employers, with a £2,000 hiring payment for eligible new apprentices from this month. These measures help small employers to develop the skills they need. Fourthly, on opportunities to win business, departmental procurement targets are intended to deliver more than £7.4 billion in annual direct spending with small and medium-sized businesses by 2028. The Procurement Act and the central digital platform are designed to reduce barriers to participation. The test is whether a capable family business can compete fairly without the bidding process consuming resources it cannot spare. Place matters too. A successful high street brings customers to the family café, retailer and service business. Our £210 million high street package will help bring neglected buildings back into use and support community assets and businesses alongside the forthcoming high street strategy. Let me now turn to inheritance and succession. I understand why this matters so much. A business value may be tied up in premises, machinery or land. That is not the same as having cash available, although an estate can, where appropriate, pay its tax liability from other assets. Some families are asking what a potential future liability means for today’s investment and how it affects succession planning, recognising that business owners have a range of options, including making lifetime gifts. The Government must balance support for enterprises with fair taxation and sustainable public services. We have also listened and changed the arrangements. The allowance for assets eligible for 100% agricultural and business property relief is £2.5 million, and any unused allowance can be transferred between spouses and civil partners. This means a couple can pass on up to £5 million in qualifying assets tax-free, alongside existing allowances and exemptions. Qualifying assets above the allowance receive 50% relief, and tax attributed to property eligible for this relief can be paid over 10 years in interest-free instalments. However, I will ensure that the concerns raised today are conveyed to my Treasury colleagues. Family Business UK also contributes to our work on small business growth and mid-market regulation, and I, my team and my ministerial colleagues meet with them regularly. That dialogue matters, and I look forward to taking part in Family Business Week, which is coming up very soon. Families who build businesses invest far more than money: they invest their time, hopes and often a lifetime of work. They deserve a Government who understand that commitment and who take their concerns seriously. Our task is to help turn ambition into investment, investment into good jobs, and years of hard work into a business the next generation can carry forward. When family businesses succeed, employees, suppliers and whole communities share in that success. That is why their future matters to us all.
← Previous
Local Government: Democratic Accountability, Participation and Electoral Reform
Next →
Food Security
Source: UK Parliament Hansard API. Debate ID: 5417790.