Contribution
My Lords, I congratulate the noble Lord, Lord Cameron of Dillington, on securing this debate and on his rousing speech. Like him, I come from a farming background. Following a difficult period in the 1960s, our farm was sold and my father retrained and set up a new business as an agricultural economist, mainly in Brussels, working there until he was well past 70, so noble Lords can see that small business and enterprise are in my DNA. Indeed, during my 15 years at Tesco, I worked hard to encourage the small supply base with special procurement arrangements to assist dairy farmers and small suppliers in Cornwall, Scotland, Northern Ireland and Wales, so that they could get their products listed.
Noble Lords will be familiar with the importance I have consistently placed on supporting small and medium-sized enterprises, sometimes with the help of the Federation of Small Businesses, through our debates, scrutiny of government policy and consideration of legislation. My recent amendments to the Financial Services and Markets Bill are one example. I was delighted that the Government accepted the importance of supporting smaller operators by agreeing to add proportionality as a principle to that Bill.
Many businesses start as family businesses, and there is a good reason for this. Starting out in business requires trust, and it is often easier to trust family. Family members are more likely to provide a loan or even take a stake in the business, and there is less risk of the business being torn apart if it runs into trouble, reflecting the benefit of familial links. My belief is that this is true of all ethnicities. An even more important driver of trust is the involvement of one’s children in one’s business. It is natural to train one’s children, teach them one’s trade and want them to take over one’s business on retirement or death. The parent can be more secure in the knowledge that his or her heir knows the business: every good or boggy field on a farm, different customers in a retail or restaurant business, good beer, service and ambience in a pub, and processes and design in an engineering or architecture business.
It is against this background that this Government’s assault on families through IHT and the farm and family business taxes are so troubling. These have generated a dangerous gloom. Concessions made earlier this year do not solve the problem, and the sums raised will be small. The Reeves policy on this was profoundly mistaken, for reasons that my noble friend Lord Elliott of Mickle Fell set out so well. It is not as though this is in isolation. These businesses are being hit by the triple whammy of the Reeves increases in national insurance—the jobs tax; the hike in the minimum wage, especially for the young, which the noble Lord, Lord Cameron, highlighted in his example; and the Employment Rights Act, the full horror of which is beginning to emerge, as we heard yesterday in the debate on SIs implementing trade union involvement. Business rates are also rising for all but the smallest, with a double hit arising from a rates rise on top of a revaluation.
Wider cost pressures and regulation are also affecting family firms. The worst of these is high energy prices in the UK—four times those in the US and, according to some estimates, up to six times those in China—with trouble in the Middle East and eastern Europe increasing the pressure every day. This is closely followed by our planning and building regulation system. The Government’s attempted reforms seem to be failing, at least for small housebuilders—often family firms whose share of the construction market has plummeted in recent years and resulted in insolvencies, such as that of Devonshire Homes in the south-west.
I do not want to end on a depressing note. We have an extraordinary capacity for enterprise, innovation and ambition in this country. As an example, consider the stories behind some of our most well-known businesses, involving Michael Marks and Tom Spencer, John and Mary Ann Sainsbury, and, more recently, William Morrison of Morrisons and Jack Cohen of Tesco. By chance, the mention of the nation of shopkeepers by the noble Lord, Lord Cameron, and indeed by my noble friend Lord Fuller, chimed with this. These people all had the confidence from modest beginnings to take risks, invest their own resources and build some of the most successful businesses in the world, providing good jobs for literally hundreds of thousands of people.
As the budget approaches, the Government need to consider how they can kick-start the enterprise lurking in family firms. They need to cancel the IHT death taxes, re-examine plans for business rates, which are hitting hospitality particularly hard, halve NICs for under-25s, and ease the ever-growing burden of regulation, especially on housing and the countryside. Above all, given the limits imposed by the troubling fiscal situation, they must try to do no harm, avoiding new taxes on family businesses and the inevitable impact on growth.