Contribution
My Lords, I thank the Minister for his introduction and his undertaking to respond to all noble Lords’ comments. I very much look forward to the maiden speeches of the noble Lord, Lord Neri, and the noble Baronesses, Lady Aglionby, Lady Kitching of Penistone and Lady Ussher. I also very much look forward to the contributions from such a large and distinguished gathering.
This was Labour’s third Budget in office and the first delivered by the new Chancellor of the Exchequer. He was dealt a poor hand by his predecessor but, in summary, he has done little in this Budget to improve matters. We are in a bad way. Today’s figures were encouraging, but growth has been weak for a long time. Inflation is high, real wages are stagnating, unemployment is rising, taxation is approaching historic highs and, above all, the national debt approaches 100% of GDP and debt interest is increasing, thereby consuming an ever greater share of public spending.
These are serious problems demanding serious decisions, yet what we received was a Budget of short-term fixes and promises of action tomorrow. This week, the NIESR warned that the Budget failed the credibility test. Its director, David Aikman, said:
“A plan that is not believed adds to the premium the Government pays to borrow”.
The OBR forecast growth of just 1.2% this year, falling to 1% in 2027. Inflation will remain above target until 2028, while the economy’s underlying productive capacity is expected to grow by only around 1.5% annually. The Minister cited the IMF’s endorsement of the Government’s deficit reduction plans, but the IMF did not give them a blank cheque; it told them explicitly to “stay the course” and warned against slippage. Since then, the OBR has revised borrowing upwards and reduced fiscal headroom to £15 billion, and the Government’s plans have not yet led to any reduction in the deficit, as we discussed in Grand Committee only last week.
Further, the OBR forecasts no real earnings growth in 2027, followed by only very modest increases in subsequent years. Real household disposable income per person is expected to fall in the near term and, even by the end of the decade, to stand only around 2% above its pre-pandemic level. Yet the Government plan to meet their financial targets by “planning”—the word must be in quotation marks—to reduce public expenditure significantly in the last two years of their term. They should pull the other one.
Taxation under this Government has increased enormously, mainly by freezing income tax thresholds and increasing national insurance in the Government’s unfortunate first Budget. Both eventually have the same effect as a tax rise on working people, whatever the Chancellor says. The Government have also imposed extra burdens on higher-rate taxpayers, but, in the end, part of that burden is also borne by those lower down the income scale.
Even the OBR warns that taxation at these levels risks damaging incentives to work, save and invest. On this side of the House, we have not forgotten the debilitating effect of the application of IHT on family businesses, farms and pensions; or VAT on school fees; or the new mansion tax that will be in the Finance Bill.
This Budget’s measures continue in the same vein, with a rise in savings and property taxes, so that a widow renting out a flat pays a higher rate than a footballer, and a tax surcharge on the banks, on which SMEs rely for investment. Britain cannot tax its way to prosperity. The way to the growth and prosperity that we all seek is to spend and tax less.
What of those people who are not in work? Unemployment is forecast to exceed 5% in 2027, vacancies are falling and young people in particular are struggling to find work. Yet the Government have made employing people more expensive through higher employer national insurance, rising costs and increasing regulation. Their answer is a jobs guarantee, but another government scheme is not a substitute for a thriving private sector.
We cannot afford a system in which fewer people work, those who do work pay ever more in tax, and the welfare bill continues to rise. Can the Minister point to where in this Budget the Government have seriously confronted this challenge? We on these Benches have struggled to find it.
However, despite record taxation and enormous borrowing, the Chancellor has left himself just £15 billion of fiscal headroom. The OBR puts his chances of meeting his fiscal rule at barely 56%. Indeed, a one percentage point change in interest rates could increase debt interest costs by £16 billion, wiping out the headroom. Meeting a fiscal rule by the narrowest of margins is not the same as restoring the fiscal responsibility we need.
In short, the great failure of this Budget was the absence of serious decisions on the greatest challenges facing our country. Where was the plan for welfare reform? Health and disability benefit spending alone is forecast to rise from £86 billion to £120 billion by 2031-32. This is plainly unsustainable, yet the Government continue to postpone the difficult reforms that are needed.
Where is the plan for defence? The Chancellor himself, when resigning as Defence Secretary, warned that failing to commit to spending 3% of GDP by 2030 makes Britain less safe. He has failed the very test he set himself and failed to explain how the 3% will be funded. The Chancellor has chosen to defer difficult decisions. Postponing these decisions does not make the problems disappear; it simply makes them more difficult for the Chancellor’s successors.
What would we have done? What should a serious Budget have delivered? First, a credible plan for growth. There are signs today that AI and services are helping, which is welcome, but today’s figures for construction are grim—down 0.7%. Job losses in the sector have also been reported today, and, as I have heard from the Institution of Civil Engineers, we see a disappointing government record on maintenance spending and delivery of infrastructure projects.
Secondly, cheaper energy has been the key to growth historically. The Government’s temporary measures, set out clearly by the Minister, do nothing to address the underlying costs facing households and businesses. We need to go further. Our cheap power plan would remove carbon taxes and levies and abolish VAT on household energy bills for three years, reducing average household electricity bills by an estimated £200 a year. We also need to see the Rosebank field approved and the Fingleton report implemented.
Thirdly, the Budget should have delivered action on housing. The OBR now forecasts substantially fewer homes being built than it expected in the spring. Unlike this Government, we would reduce unnecessary regulatory burdens, remove barriers to development and abolish stamp duty on primary residences.
Fourthly, we would make work pay. We would halve employer national insurance for workers aged 21 to 24 and introduce our get to work programme, helping young people into employment.
Above all, we would confront the question this Government refuse to answer: how do we control public spending without continually asking taxpayers to pay more? We have set out a programme of £71 billion in annual savings, including £36 billion from welfare reform. At least half would go towards reducing the deficit, with the remainder supporting lower taxes, enterprise and our national priorities. We would establish a funded path to spending 3% of GDP on defence by 2030, because economic security and national security must go hand in hand.
The British people need a Budget that would confront the underlying problems facing our economy; instead, they received a Budget which left the major decisions for another day. It again relied on rising tax receipts to reduce borrowing, while leaving the largest structural pressures on public spending unresolved. Overall, it was a missed opportunity. Our ambition should be to build an economy that grows faster, rewards work, encourages enterprise and offers every generation the opportunity to enjoy a better standard of living than the ones before. Unfortunately, the Budget did none of that.