Contribution
My Lords, I thank the Minister for introducing these two instruments. On these Benches, we welcome the steps that the Government are taking to support the development and regulation of digital assets in the United Kingdom. This is an area of considerable opportunity for our financial services sector, and it is so vital to UK growth. It is important that we establish a regulatory framework that supports innovation and competition while maintaining appropriate protections for consumers and the integrity of our markets.
I recognise the work being undertaken by Chris Woolard, the Government’s digital markets champion, to explore the potential role of stablecoins in our financial system. We also note the Government’s proposed digital gilt next year—DIGIT, as we heard it called by the Minister. The noble Baroness, Lady Kramer, was right to ask about how we can follow the path of these important changes, given that future changes would limit parliamentary accountability.
Although these are broadly welcome developments, I return to a concern that we raised repeatedly during the passage of the Financial Services and Markets Bill through your Lordship’s House: the absence of a clear co-ordinated strategy for the development and adoption of digital assets across our financial system. Indeed, it was precisely this concern that motivated our amendment to the Bill—now Clause 50—requiring the Government to develop a comprehensive digital asset strategy.
The development of digital assets is taking place at considerable pace around the world. Stablecoins, tokenised securities, digital currencies and distributed ledger technologies all have the potential to transform different aspects of our financial system. But these are not isolated developments; they are increasingly interconnected components of what could become a fundamentally different financial infrastructure. Therefore, what we need from the Government is not simply a collection of individual regulatory initiatives such as these, however welcome they might be, but rather a clear explanation of how these initiatives fit together, what the Government ultimately want to achieve and, above all, how they will ensure that the UK remains competitive as these technologies develop internationally. The proposed digital gilt is a useful illustration of this concern. Last week, the FT made the pointed observation that it was unclear what the exercise was intended to achieve beyond demonstrating that a digital gilt could be issued.
Turning specifically to the first instrument, we welcome the Government’s intentions to make UK-issued regulated stablecoins more practical to use for everyday payments, transfers and settlement. The instrument rightly introduces a number of exclusions from the regulated activities framework. I look forward to hearing the Minister’s response to the question raised by the noble Baroness, Lady Kramer, about flexibility in the event of abuse.
I have two areas of concern. First, if you are a potential stablecoin operator, you would be desperate to know exactly what the regulatory regime will be before you finally commit. The Treasury still holds the ring on how payment systems regulation will change, and its consultation has closed. When will final decisions on the regime be taken?
Secondly, the relatively narrow scope of today’s SI illustrates the wider point about the need for a whole-system approach. The principal payment-related exclusions are focused on a particular category of stablecoin: those issued by an appropriately authorised UK issuer. They do not extend generally to the wider range of crypto assets, and other activities, including certain exchanges and custody services, remain within the regulatory perimeter. Therefore, I would be grateful if the Minister could explain how these measures fit within the Government’s broader plans for the adoption of stablecoins and digital assets. Do the Government intend to set out a more comprehensive vision for their practical application across the economy?
Turning to the second instrument, we welcome the Government’s intention to provide greater flexibility for innovation through financial market infrastructure sandboxes. As I understand it, this instrument expands the range of legislation that may be modified within an FMI sandbox rather than itself making substantive changes to those enactments. That additional flexibility is welcome. It is right that firms should be able to test emerging technologies in an appropriate and controlled regulatory environment. I know that the Financial Services Regulation Committee is conducting an inquiry into sandboxes, and I look forward to its conclusions.
A fundamental question is what happens beyond the sandbox. It is one thing to demonstrate that a particular technology or process can work within a controlled environment. It is quite another to establish that it can operate successfully, at scale, within the wider financial market. There is a risk that we develop a succession of interesting pilots that demonstrate technical feasibility but never make the transition into commercially viable, widely adopted infrastructure.