B

Baroness Carberry of Muswell Hill (Lab)

Speaking in the House of Lords on 14 October 2026

Debate

ACAS Code of Practice on Time Off for Trade Union Duties and Activities

Contribution

My Lords, the noble Lord, Lord Sharpe, might not be surprised to hear that I do not agree with him that the code is disproportionate and represents an unjustifiable burden on employers and taxpayers. I will start with a technical point. The regret amendment suggests that the draft ACAS code will expand the statutory entitlement to paid facility time for equality reps, but, as the noble Lord knows, the Employment Rights Act did that, and the arguments were played out during that Bill’s passage. ACAS is now explaining how the statutory right is to operate in practice. The key question is whether ACAS has produced a sensible set of guidance for implementing the law that Parliament has enacted. I believe that it has. To recall, the Employment Rights Act provides a right to reasonable time off for equality reps of a recognised trade union for a specified purpose. The noble Lord, Lord Sharpe, described the purposes as broad, but I emphasise that they are specified, which is helpful. The purposes are: “promoting … equality in the workplace … arranging learning or training … providing information, advice or support to qualifying members … consulting with the employer … obtaining and analysing information”, and “preparing” for those activities. Again, the Act provides a right to reasonable time off for relevant training. The amount of time off, and its purposes, occasions and conditions, have to be reasonable in “all the circumstances”, including the employer’s circumstances and the practical requirements of the workplace. The code does not turn that into an unlimited entitlement, so this is not some new, open-ended commitment for employers. The regret amendment suggests that there is insufficient evidence that equality representatives will improve workplace outcomes. Of course, we should always ask what evidence supports a new employment right, but no one can provide proof that every single instance of paid time off will produce a measurable improvement in a particular workplace. However, there is long-standing evidence and experience that properly trained workplace representatives can contribute to better employment relations, and they do. The existing ACAS codes point to the positive benefits of effective workplace representation to employers, employees and union members, including helping to resolve problems and conflicts at work. The updated code adds that effective representation can help to build trust, improve communication and support early resolution of workplace disputes. These are not abstract benefits. A workplace dispute that is resolved at an early stage is less likely to become a formal grievance, a disciplinary dispute, an employment tribunal claim or a breakdown in the employment relationships. I have spoken to many employers who recognise that union reps can be a valuable source of intelligence for management, helping the employer to deal with a problem before it becomes expensive, entrenched or legally contentious. That matters very directly in equality matters. Issues involving discrimination, harassment, victimisation or unequal treatment are precisely the sorts of matters where trained representatives can help employees and employers and stop grievances getting out of hand. I fully share the regret amendment’s concern about value for money. Every pound of taxpayers’ money should be spent responsibly, but I do not accept that the costs related to time off for equality reps will be disproportionate. As always, costs need to be measured against benefits. It is wrong to assume that the time spent by a trained representative is simply a cost with no corresponding benefit. The potential benefits of these measures are workplaces where disputes are dealt with efficiently, managers receive early warnings and accurate information about problems affecting their workforce, employees understand their rights and responsibilities, and problems are contained. Sometimes, an hour spent identifying and resolving a problem is an hour that saves many more hours later. The amendment speaks of taxpayers funding “additional staff time”. Again, the legislation talks about reasonable time off, and there are conditions. To get paid time off, the employee must be “a member of an independent trade union recognised by the employer”, and must have been “appointed or elected” as an equality representative in accordance with the union’s rules. The amendment is not keen on taxpayers’ money being spent on equality, diversity and inclusion activity. Bashing EDI has become a fashionable transatlantic sport, but leaving that aside, what does the code actually say? The statutory definition of equality in this context is not an invitation to pursue every conceivable form of EDI activity; it is tied to established concepts in the Equality Act 2010: eliminating discrimination, harassment and victimisation; advancing equality of opportunity between people who share protected characteristics and those who do not; and fostering good relations.

More from Baroness Carberry of Muswell Hill (Lab)

Other recent Hansard contributions by the same speaker.

About Hansard

Hansard is the official verbatim record of proceedings in the UK Parliament. Every word spoken in the Commons and Lords is recorded and published — this page is a single contribution from that record.