B

Baroness Carberry of Muswell Hill (Lab)

Speaking in the House of Lords on 14 October 2026

Debate

Protection Against Detriment (Industrial Action) Regulations 2026

Contribution

My Lords, I am very sorry and disappointed that the noble Lord, Lord Hunt, is seeking to reopen an important principle behind these regulations, a principle that has been endorsed in both Houses in the Employment Rights Act and a principle that was well debated, where the arguments were well aired, as that Bill was going through the House before it became an Act. As my noble friend the Minister has recalled, the principle that we are talking about is that a worker should not suffer a detriment simply for exercising the lawful right to take protected industrial action. I emphasise “lawful”. The amendment before us regrets that the regulations prohibit all detriments for taking protected industrial action. I was expecting the noble Lord, Lord Hunt, to argue that he preferred a closed list, in which case I might have been able to express some sympathy with his arguments—although I would take him to task. However, I interpret his speech as preferring there to be no list at all and therefore no limit on any punitive action that could be taken against a worker who was simply exercising a lawful right. Perhaps the noble Lord could clarify that. As the noble Lord, Lord Hunt, reminded us, the Government consulted businesses and other stakeholders on only two options—a prescribed list or a complete ban. The Government set out their conclusions earlier this year and the Minister in the other place further elaborated on this at a meeting of the Delegated Powers Committee last month. In essence, the Government concluded that a closed list might initially appear more certain, but they opted for a complete ban, which is what the noble Lord very much regrets. In the consultation there were credible arguments in favour of a prescribed list, but the arguments against were much stronger and, in essence, it is not possible to reduce industrial relations to a list of foreseeable forms of retaliation. A prescribed list of detriments would not give workers the protections that they need when they are acting on their lawful right to take industrial action. It is not possible to anticipate all employer potential actions in secondary legislation. An employer who wanted to get around the protection could simply do something that was not on the list because Parliament had not anticipated it. Also, a list could become out of date, but again I anticipate that the noble Lord does not want any list at all. I recognise the concerns expressed during consultation by some employers and business organisations, as the noble Lord has set out. They are entitled to be assured that these regulations will not stop legitimate management decisions or expose employers to random claims. I contend that the Government have provided that reassurance. The regulations do not provide workers with a general immunity from adverse treatment. They apply a statutory purpose test. The employer’s act, or deliberate failure to act, must have the sole or main purpose of preventing, deterring or penalising the worker. That is a significant threshold. As my noble friend the Minister said, these regulations do not make every management decision that might affect a person who is on strike unlawful. The purpose test provides a safeguard. The noble Lord’s amendment points to the risk of increasing litigation and burdens, with adverse effects on employers’ day-to-day business activities. No one wants more tribunal cases. Nobody wants to see more burdens on businesses. However, there is no evidence that this is what will follow. An employer will still be able to manage its business. It can make contingency arrangements, reorganise work, deal with genuine misconduct and take decisions for legitimate operational reasons. To underline the point made by my noble friend the Minister, the regulations do not prevent the ordinary deduction of pay for time not worked because of a strike. The regulations do not give workers immunity from management action. They address something much narrower: the use of management power to punish or deter the exercise of a statutory right. Nor does it seem likely that we will see more tribunal cases for reasons my noble friend the Minister has set out. These regulations are preventive. They provide clarity. There is no reason to believe that they will lead to more litigation. I will underline the point: the right to take protected industrial action is a statutory right. A right that can be deliberately frustrated through an employer’s choice of sanction is not a particularly meaningful right. These regulations do not seek to tilt the balance of industrial relations in favour of one side. They establish a boundary around the exercise of managerial power. Legitimate management remains legitimate; retaliation for exercising a lawful statutory right does not.

More from Baroness Carberry of Muswell Hill (Lab)

Other recent Hansard contributions by the same speaker.

About Hansard

Hansard is the official verbatim record of proceedings in the UK Parliament. Every word spoken in the Commons and Lords is recorded and published — this page is a single contribution from that record.