Contribution
My Lords, I am grateful to the Minister for explaining and introducing this statutory instrument, to which I have tabled a regret amendment. I look forward to hearing the speeches of the noble Baroness, Lady Carberry of Muswell Hill, and the noble Lord, Lord Davies of Brixton, who bring considerable knowledge based on their long service in the trade union movement and the field of employment relations. They will probably understand my approach.
I believe these regulations risk taking this country back to an industrial relations culture which most people thought had been left behind decades ago, when I served in the House of Commons. I go back 50 years, but I look in particular to 1979—the winter of discontent, when 29.5 million working days were lost to industrial disputes. Public services were disrupted right across the country and the consequences were severe for ordinary people, in particular my constituents in Merseyside. It remains one of only three years since 1926 in which more than 20 million working days were lost to industrial action. That history ought to make any Government extremely cautious about legislation which further weakens the consequences of industrial action. Yet these regulations choose the broadest possible approach.
The Government’s own consultation shows where the concerns lie. Of the 27 employer respondents, 22 were large employers with more than 250 staff. Employer respondents overall opposed prohibiting every detriment by 16 to nine. Among business representative organisations, nine out of 11 oppose this blanket approach. These are the organisations responsible for managing workforces, maintaining operations and delivering services during industrial disputes. The majority of them warned Ministers that this approach goes too far and will likely harm industrial relations further. The cost to the economy will be real and could be very substantial indeed.
An employer may still discipline genuine misconduct or take decisions for legitimate operational reasons, but if a worker alleges that the real purpose was to penalise industrial action, the employer may find itself having to defend that decision before a tribunal. The risk is that managers become more reluctant to take perfectly legitimate decisions on performance, discipline, staffing or business continuity for fear that these decisions will later be challenged as a detriment. The Government’s own consultation confirms:
“Any increase in strike activity could indirectly affect households through service disruptions (transport, education), creating externalities that raise household costs”.
That is perhaps stating the obvious, but where is the obvious conclusion that strike activity should continue to be the last resort? The impact of these regulations will hit the public sector—and therefore taxpayers—the hardest.
Since 2022, around 70% of workers involved in labour disputes have been public sector workers and around 80% of stoppages have occurred in the public sector. Around half of all working days lost over that period were in the public sector. The increased costs that this legislation adumbrates will fall on passengers waiting for trains, parents whose children cannot get to school and patients waiting for treatment. We do not have to speculate about what rogue industrial disruption looks like. Earlier this year, RMT industrial action on the London Underground caused significant disruption, with Tube journeys falling sharply during strike days and some lines unable to operate normally. In the NHS, the consequences are even more serious. During the BMA resident doctors’ strikes, in July 2025 alone over 54,000 appointments and procedures were postponed.
Taking the measures in the Employment Rights Act cumulatively, we see that the direction of travel is always towards more power for the trade unions, more legal risks for employers and fewer protections for the public, who depend on uninterrupted services. The Government cannot even tell us how much all this will cost. Their own options assessment states that they have not been able to put a figure on the costs, benefits or potential impact on businesses and the public sector, yet Ministers have chosen the widest possible option regardless.
There is of course a broader question of public interest here. Industrial relations law must strike a balance. These regulations tilt that balance too far. The lessons of the 1970s must not be forgotten. Britain paid a heavy price when industrial relations became dominated by confrontation and disruption. We should not be taking steps that risk returning us towards that model. I beg to move.