Hansard·Lords Chamber·Vol. 860

Protection Against Detriment (Industrial Action) Regulations 2026

Wednesday, 14 October 2026

15 contributions5 members

Contributions

  1. Motion to Approve

    View contribution permalink →

  2. Moved by

    View contribution permalink →

  3. Lord Leong

    That the draft Regulations laid before the House on 24 June be approved. Relevant document: 8th Report from the Secondary Legislation Scrutiny Committee

    View contribution permalink →

  4. The Parliamentary Under-Secretary of State, Department for Business and Trade (Lord Leong) (Lab)

    My Lords, the three debates today cover measures that play an important part in the Government’s plan to make work pay, delivering on our commitments to modernise and improve employment rights for the 21st century. These measures will help us reset and modernise our industrial relations framework. I am grateful for the opportunity to debate these important reforms and trust that the House will fully support this package of measures. Our first debate is on the Protection Against Detriment (Industrial Action) Regulations 2026. I also note the regret amendment tabled by the noble Lord, Lord Hunt of Wirral. I am glad of the opportunity to debate these important reforms, and I will address the concerns raised by him in my remarks. This instrument was laid before the House on 24 June 2026. It relates to protection from detriments for workers taking protected industrial action under the Trade Union and Labour Relations (Consolidation) Act 1992 and is being introduced to provide essential protections for workers, ensuring that they can take industrial action without being treated unfairly by the employer as a result. In 2019, Fiona Mercer was suspended by her employer for participating in and helping to organise lawful strike action. She brought a claim against her employer under Section 146 of the Trade Union and Labour Relations (Consolidation) Act, or TULRCA. The 2024 Supreme Court Mercer judgment ruled that the current protections against detriment for trade union activity under this section of TULRCA do not extend to protected industrial action. As a result, the Supreme Court issued a declaration of incompatibility between UK legislation and Article 11 of the European Convention on Human Rights, which protects the right to freedom of association. This means there is a gap in the law that could enable bad-faith employers unfairly to penalise workers taking industrial action. While it should always be treated as a last resort, this Government believe that industrial action is an integral and vital part of workers’ rights to express their collective voice. If a worker chooses to take industrial action, it is essential that employers treat them fairly and with respect, as the vast majority of employers have always done. This statutory instrument fills a legal gap, allowing workers to strike without risking detriment and aligning our law with the European Convention on Human Rights. These regulations are made under Section 236A of the Trade Union and Labour Relations (Consolidation) Act 1992, introduced by the Employment Rights Act 2025. These regulations and Section 236A prohibit employer detriments aimed at penalising, preventing or deterring protected industrial action. This Government are committed to protecting workers who take industrial action while ensuring that employers are not unduly affected or restricted. The vast majority of employers already act responsibly and do not penalise workers for taking industrial action. This legislation therefore targets the rare cases in which such treatment may occur without disrupting the day-to-day running of responsible businesses. That is why this legislation prohibits detriments only for the sole or main purpose of penalising, preventing or deterring industrial action. This means that during the period of industrial action, ordinary business practices will not be banned, provided they are not used for the sole or main purpose of penalising, preventing or deterring a worker from taking industrial action. For example, a disciplinary action may still be taken against a worker who has committed misconduct unrelated to strike action during an ongoing strike. Employers will still be able to manage industrial action in ways that do not involve imposing unlawful detriment. Examples of this include proactive negotiation before industrial action commences and contingency planning to mitigate the impact of the action. I will now address the matter of wage deductions in the context of industrial actions. An employer should not be obliged to pay a worker for work not done because that worker was on strike. Therefore, in common law, the principle of “no work, no pay” applies. This means that, if a worker does not attend work for a day because of industrial action, the employer is under no obligation to pay them for the day. These regulations state that they do not affect this common-law position. The rules enabling the deduction of pay on account of a worker’s participation in protected industrial action will remain as they are. This statutory instrument also adds Section 236A to the list of claims in Schedule A2 to the Trade Union and Labour Relations (Consolidation) Act. Detriment claims will be added to Schedule A2, and an employment tribunal may adjust compensation by 25% based on compliance with the ACAS code of practice on disciplinary and grievance procedures. This promotes fairness, co-operation and prompt dispute resolution, helping employers resume normal business quickly. The regret amendment tabled by the noble Lord, Lord Hunt, raises concerns about the timing of the regulations in the context of the Government’s reforms to industrial action notices and mandates. The noble Lord also expresses concern that there is a risk of increased litigation and administrative burdens resulting from the regulations, which he believes will lead to employers delaying legitimate operational decisions and possibly affect the delivery of critical public services. Let me address the noble Lord’s concern that these regulations and reforms to industrial action notices and mandates will lead to more strikes. This will not be the case. At present, employers very rarely impose detriments on workers for taking industrial action. Very few significant cases have been brought. Therefore, we do not believe that banning all detriments will have a significant impact on the level of industrial action. In 2019-20 and 2020-21, there were 24 and 15 tribunal hearings, respectively, related to detriments for trade union membership—the closest parallel to this legislation. We expect the number to be similarly low for detriments imposed for industrial action. The Employment Rights Act simplified industrial action notice requirements and extended the mandate length, reducing ballot frequency while ensuring that employers get enough notice to prepare. Providing notice before balloting an action is still required for protection. In addition, employers can still withhold pay from workers taking industrial action; this has always been shown to be the effective detriment to workers. In response to the noble Lord’s second concern, I do not agree that these reforms will increase litigation and administrative burdens on businesses or cause employers to delay the action. In conclusion, this statutory instrument is crucial for protecting workers’ rights to industrial action and aligning our law with the European Convention on Human Rights. It will prevent bad-faith employers exploiting the legislative gap highlighted by the Supreme Court while allowing good-faith employers to handle industrial action non-punitively and to continue normal practices. I hope all noble Lords will support this instrument.

    View contribution permalink →

  5. Amendment to the Motion

    View contribution permalink →

  6. Moved by

    View contribution permalink →

  7. Lord Hunt of Wirral

    At end to insert “but that this House regrets that the draft Regulations prohibit all detriments for taking protected industrial action at a time when the Government has already reduced protections surrounding industrial action notices and mandates; and risk increasing litigation and administrative burdens, causing employers to delay or avoid legitimate operational, disciplinary and performance decisions, with particular consequences for the delivery of critical public services.”

    View contribution permalink →

  8. Lord Hunt of Wirral (Con)

    My Lords, I am grateful to the Minister for explaining and introducing this statutory instrument, to which I have tabled a regret amendment. I look forward to hearing the speeches of the noble Baroness, Lady Carberry of Muswell Hill, and the noble Lord, Lord Davies of Brixton, who bring considerable knowledge based on their long service in the trade union movement and the field of employment relations. They will probably understand my approach. I believe these regulations risk taking this country back to an industrial relations culture which most people thought had been left behind decades ago, when I served in the House of Commons. I go back 50 years, but I look in particular to 1979—the winter of discontent, when 29.5 million working days were lost to industrial disputes. Public services were disrupted right across the country and the consequences were severe for ordinary people, in particular my constituents in Merseyside. It remains one of only three years since 1926 in which more than 20 million working days were lost to industrial action. That history ought to make any Government extremely cautious about legislation which further weakens the consequences of industrial action. Yet these regulations choose the broadest possible approach. The Government’s own consultation shows where the concerns lie. Of the 27 employer respondents, 22 were large employers with more than 250 staff. Employer respondents overall opposed prohibiting every detriment by 16 to nine. Among business representative organisations, nine out of 11 oppose this blanket approach. These are the organisations responsible for managing workforces, maintaining operations and delivering services during industrial disputes. The majority of them warned Ministers that this approach goes too far and will likely harm industrial relations further. The cost to the economy will be real and could be very substantial indeed. An employer may still discipline genuine misconduct or take decisions for legitimate operational reasons, but if a worker alleges that the real purpose was to penalise industrial action, the employer may find itself having to defend that decision before a tribunal. The risk is that managers become more reluctant to take perfectly legitimate decisions on performance, discipline, staffing or business continuity for fear that these decisions will later be challenged as a detriment. The Government’s own consultation confirms: “Any increase in strike activity could indirectly affect households through service disruptions (transport, education), creating externalities that raise household costs”. That is perhaps stating the obvious, but where is the obvious conclusion that strike activity should continue to be the last resort? The impact of these regulations will hit the public sector—and therefore taxpayers—the hardest. Since 2022, around 70% of workers involved in labour disputes have been public sector workers and around 80% of stoppages have occurred in the public sector. Around half of all working days lost over that period were in the public sector. The increased costs that this legislation adumbrates will fall on passengers waiting for trains, parents whose children cannot get to school and patients waiting for treatment. We do not have to speculate about what rogue industrial disruption looks like. Earlier this year, RMT industrial action on the London Underground caused significant disruption, with Tube journeys falling sharply during strike days and some lines unable to operate normally. In the NHS, the consequences are even more serious. During the BMA resident doctors’ strikes, in July 2025 alone over 54,000 appointments and procedures were postponed. Taking the measures in the Employment Rights Act cumulatively, we see that the direction of travel is always towards more power for the trade unions, more legal risks for employers and fewer protections for the public, who depend on uninterrupted services. The Government cannot even tell us how much all this will cost. Their own options assessment states that they have not been able to put a figure on the costs, benefits or potential impact on businesses and the public sector, yet Ministers have chosen the widest possible option regardless. There is of course a broader question of public interest here. Industrial relations law must strike a balance. These regulations tilt that balance too far. The lessons of the 1970s must not be forgotten. Britain paid a heavy price when industrial relations became dominated by confrontation and disruption. We should not be taking steps that risk returning us towards that model. I beg to move.

    View contribution permalink →

  9. Baroness Carberry of Muswell Hill (Lab)

    My Lords, I am very sorry and disappointed that the noble Lord, Lord Hunt, is seeking to reopen an important principle behind these regulations, a principle that has been endorsed in both Houses in the Employment Rights Act and a principle that was well debated, where the arguments were well aired, as that Bill was going through the House before it became an Act. As my noble friend the Minister has recalled, the principle that we are talking about is that a worker should not suffer a detriment simply for exercising the lawful right to take protected industrial action. I emphasise “lawful”. The amendment before us regrets that the regulations prohibit all detriments for taking protected industrial action. I was expecting the noble Lord, Lord Hunt, to argue that he preferred a closed list, in which case I might have been able to express some sympathy with his arguments—although I would take him to task. However, I interpret his speech as preferring there to be no list at all and therefore no limit on any punitive action that could be taken against a worker who was simply exercising a lawful right. Perhaps the noble Lord could clarify that. As the noble Lord, Lord Hunt, reminded us, the Government consulted businesses and other stakeholders on only two options—a prescribed list or a complete ban. The Government set out their conclusions earlier this year and the Minister in the other place further elaborated on this at a meeting of the Delegated Powers Committee last month. In essence, the Government concluded that a closed list might initially appear more certain, but they opted for a complete ban, which is what the noble Lord very much regrets. In the consultation there were credible arguments in favour of a prescribed list, but the arguments against were much stronger and, in essence, it is not possible to reduce industrial relations to a list of foreseeable forms of retaliation. A prescribed list of detriments would not give workers the protections that they need when they are acting on their lawful right to take industrial action. It is not possible to anticipate all employer potential actions in secondary legislation. An employer who wanted to get around the protection could simply do something that was not on the list because Parliament had not anticipated it. Also, a list could become out of date, but again I anticipate that the noble Lord does not want any list at all. I recognise the concerns expressed during consultation by some employers and business organisations, as the noble Lord has set out. They are entitled to be assured that these regulations will not stop legitimate management decisions or expose employers to random claims. I contend that the Government have provided that reassurance. The regulations do not provide workers with a general immunity from adverse treatment. They apply a statutory purpose test. The employer’s act, or deliberate failure to act, must have the sole or main purpose of preventing, deterring or penalising the worker. That is a significant threshold. As my noble friend the Minister said, these regulations do not make every management decision that might affect a person who is on strike unlawful. The purpose test provides a safeguard. The noble Lord’s amendment points to the risk of increasing litigation and burdens, with adverse effects on employers’ day-to-day business activities. No one wants more tribunal cases. Nobody wants to see more burdens on businesses. However, there is no evidence that this is what will follow. An employer will still be able to manage its business. It can make contingency arrangements, reorganise work, deal with genuine misconduct and take decisions for legitimate operational reasons. To underline the point made by my noble friend the Minister, the regulations do not prevent the ordinary deduction of pay for time not worked because of a strike. The regulations do not give workers immunity from management action. They address something much narrower: the use of management power to punish or deter the exercise of a statutory right. Nor does it seem likely that we will see more tribunal cases for reasons my noble friend the Minister has set out. These regulations are preventive. They provide clarity. There is no reason to believe that they will lead to more litigation. I will underline the point: the right to take protected industrial action is a statutory right. A right that can be deliberately frustrated through an employer’s choice of sanction is not a particularly meaningful right. These regulations do not seek to tilt the balance of industrial relations in favour of one side. They establish a boundary around the exercise of managerial power. Legitimate management remains legitimate; retaliation for exercising a lawful statutory right does not.

    View contribution permalink →

  10. Lord Davies of Brixton (Lab)

    The noble Lord, Lord Hunt of Wirral, has tabled a regret amendment, but I am going to explain why the House should not share his regrets. I thank my noble friends Lady Carberry of Muswell Hill and Lord Leong. First, I have to give my apologies, because I am now not able to stay for the other two debates, which I have my name down for this evening, although I think those in the House can probably understand my views on those by reading across from my views on this one. I probably should not be here for this one, but I feel so strongly on this and the other issues before the House this evening that I feel compelled to speak out. The truth is that I know which side I am on—I am on the side of the worker—and how we all gain, workers and employers alike, from good and effective industrial relations. Essentially, this is what these regulations will right. Getting rid of oppressive anti-trade union legislation is a means to that end. These regulations deal with a gap in the law that the Supreme Court has already identified. In the Mercer case, Fiona Mercer, a care worker, was suspended as a result of taking part in lawful industrial action. The court found that the existing framework gave workers no protection against detriment short of dismissal for taking part in industrial action. It held that this was incompatible with the right to freedom of association under Article 11 of the European convention. That was inserted by the Employment Rights Act last year, and under that Act there is the power to close this gap. This gap has real consequences, as Ms Mercer’s case is not an isolated one. In the Communication Workers Union’s dispute with Royal Mail in 2022 and 2023, the employer imposed disproportionate disciplinary sanctions, restricted sick pay and reallocated overtime to agency workers. In the RMT’s dispute with Southern Rail between 2016 and 2018, members lost their free travel passes and so did their families and dependants. Their car parking permits were withdrawn, and all their pay was withheld until the passes and permits were returned. Their applications for rest day working were refused. None of these measures was dismissal, and none was unlawful under the law as it stood and stands, but each caused real and material harm. The effect goes beyond the individuals involved. When workers know they can be penalised in these ways, some of them will decide not to take part in action they are legally entitled to take. The rights exist in law, but in practice they are restricted. This matters for the way disputes are resolved. Industrial action, we all agree, should be the last resort, and most disputes are settled by negotiation and most are settled before any strike takes place. Negotiation—the essential process of achieving agreement—works because both sides know the workers can, in the end, withdraw their labour. If using that right carries penalties, even those short of dismissal, the balance in negotiations moves towards the employer. Perhaps those on the other side of the debate could say whether they think employers should be able to dismiss employees for going on strike, because what is the difference? It is the pressure on the workers that makes the point. The TUC emphasises that trade unions are essential to rebalance power in the labour market, and these regulations are consistent with that aim. The noble Lord, Lord Hunt of Wirral, waves the spectre of a return to the 1970s. I think we have moved on a long time from there and much of the legislation post that time is already in force. My noble friend Lady Carberry of Muswell Hill has explained the extensive consultation and the decision not to use a closed list has been explained. The test here, just to emphasise the point, is whether the sole and main purpose of the employer’s action was to penalise workers for taking part in protected industrial action and for exercising their democratic rights, or to prevent or deter them from doing so. Tribunals have much practice in applying that test; it is not new. These regulations are essential to close, in a measured way, the gap that the Supreme Court has already identified.

    View contribution permalink →

  11. Lord Goddard of Stockport (LD)

    My Lords, I will be reasonably brief, as we carry the scars from the original employment Bill as it wended its way through many an hour past midnight towards delivery. Throughout the passage of that Bill, we on these Benches argued for a proportionate and reasonable approach: one that gives employees adequate rights without placing undue burdens on the business. These regulations should be judged by that test. At present, the law protects workers from being dismissed for taking part in lawful industrial action, but not from lesser penalties such as cut shifts, a withheld bonus or a missed promotion. Whatever view one takes of the gap, employers and workers are entitled to know where the line falls. The law should provide clarity on this issue, not obscurity. The test is narrow, and that matters. The detriment must have the sole or main purpose of penalising, preventing or deterring protected action. I would be grateful if the Minister could confirm a couple of points to me on the record, since employers will read the decisions of this debate tonight. Can the Minister confirm that ordinary management decisions taken during a dispute remain lawful, that discipline for misconduct unrelated to the dispute is still unaffected and that employers still can deduct pay for days not worked? I have three practical questions for the Minister. First, on guidance, the Explanatory Memorandum says guidance will be updated this month. The regulations take effect from 30 October, so what exactly will be published, and will ACAS be ready to answer questions from smaller employers? Secondly, on pay, the Explanatory Memorandum accepts that the rules on how much pay may be deducted for strike days are complex. An employer who gets that figure wrong could face a claim. Will the guidance set out, with worked examples, how proportional deductions should be calculated? Finally, I come to tribunals. The tribunal system is already under strain, as we know, so what assessment have the Government made of the likely numbers of claims under these regulations, and will they monitor and report back to the House? The noble Lord, Lord Hunt, raised fair questions about litigation and public services, and I hope that the Minister answers them tonight. Clear answers on guidance, pay and monitoring will give employees and workers the clarity that they need, perhaps more than a regret amendment does.

    View contribution permalink →

  12. Lord Leong (Lab)

    My Lords, I thank all noble Lords for their contributions. I am grateful for the support from across the House for these regulations. I will address the several questions that the noble Lord, Lord Hunt, asked in respect of the strike days, and I will share some statistics with him. Across 2024-25, there was an annual average of 773,000 days lost to industrial action. This is a decrease from the highs of 2022 and 2023 under the previous Government, when 2.5 million and 2.6 million days respectively were lost to strike action, the most for over three decades, and a significant increase from the previous decade, which saw an average loss of 345,000 days per year between 2012 and 2019. Let me remind the noble Lord again that in 2019-20 and 2020-21, there were, respectively, 24 and 15 tribunal hearings related to detriments for trade union membership, the closest parallel to this legislation. We expect the number to be similarly low for detriments imposed for industrial action. The noble Lord also asked about protecting public services. Protecting patients, service users and the public remains essential. Employers can take genuine measures to maintain critical operations, and address health and safety risks. These regulations do not require managers to ignore safeguarding concerns. The fair treatment of workers and responsible management of essential services must operate together. The noble Lord also asked whether there was a full impact assessment. I agree with the noble Lord that employers’ concerns deserve a substantive answer. We conducted a consultation, recorded concerns about litigation, administration, and operational flexibility, and we considered them. The department judged that the expected impact fell below the threshold for requiring a full impact assessment, reflecting the limited use of these detriments. However, we will monitor implementation through stakeholder feedback, and the published memorandum commits to a review in 2031. The memorandum also identifies the £10 million equivalent annual net direct cost to business threshold, and the planned non-statutory review. The noble Lord also asked about the burden on businesses. Responses to our consultation showed that employers rarely, if ever, impose detriments for taking industrial action, as I said earlier. These changes will have a very limited impact on the vast majority of employers. It is general good practice for employers to keep records of business and disciplinary decisions relating to workers. These records will help deter any speculative claims. On the burden of recording employer decisions, there is no evidence to suggest that workers will bring additional speculative claims as a result of this legislation. Workers are already protected from detriments for their trade union membership and general activities. Our understanding is that few speculative claims are brought under those provisions, so we would not expect this to lead to any increase in such cases. The noble Lord, Lord Goddard, asked about pay deduction. The precise amount of pay that can be deducted is subject to complex case law, and depends on the particular facts and circumstances, including a worker’s contractual terms and ways of working. It would therefore not be practical to codify the case law in these regulations. The position is not made any more complex by these regulations. In the majority of cases, the matter of pay deduction is simple, and often corresponds to one day’s pay withheld for one day’s strike. On the question about guidance, I will write to the noble Lord after speaking to officials, but, obviously, this is going to take effect from 30 October. This statutory instrument addresses a simple issue—namely, protecting workers from unfair treatment if they take industrial action—which I am sure all Members support. Many will have thought that this basic protection already exists in legislation. However, the 2024 Supreme Court judgment showed that this statutory instrument is necessary to ensure that workers are properly protected. This legislation will close this gap and ensure that workers are properly protected. I beg to move.

    View contribution permalink →

  13. Lord Hunt of Wirral (Con)

    My Lords, I am grateful to all those who have participated in what has been an important debate. I say to the noble Baroness, Lady Carberry of Muswell Hill, that I admire her great record. She rightly received recognition for her services to industrial and employment relations, but I think several of the points that she raised were answering a speech I had not made, but which I could have made. I say to the noble Lord, Lord Davies of Brixton, that I always admire him, because he is a fellow of the Institute and Faculty of Actuaries, so his words are always to be taken carefully, particularly on pensions. The noble Lord, Lord Goddard of Stockport, posed three key questions, I thought, and I do not think that they have been properly answered. No doubt we will await further responses, but I will just say that these regulations are moving in the wrong direction. I remember fighting the election towards the end of the 1990s, when Tony Blair, who did win the election in 1997, promised faithfully that he would not reverse the legislation enacted after the winter of discontent. He was put on the spot, but he promised that, and it was fulfilled. During that period of Labour government, there was no attempt to do what the Minister is now asking the House to approve. I just say, do not forget history; it teaches us a great deal. Industrial relations have to strike a balance between the rights of workers to take lawful industrial action, the rights of employers to manage their organisations, and—in particular—the rights of the public who rely on essential services. These regulations tilt that balance too far. For these reasons, I regret these regulations, and I urge the Government to reconsider them, preferably before it is too late. In the meantime, I beg leave to withdraw my amendment.

    View contribution permalink →

  14. Amendment to the Motion withdrawn.

    View contribution permalink →

  15. Motion agreed.

    View contribution permalink →

Source: UK Parliament Hansard API. Debate ID: 5416619.