Hansard·Lords Chamber·Vol. 860

International Update

Wednesday, 14 October 2026

44 contributions13 members

Contributions

  1. Statement

    View contribution permalink →

  2. The following Statement was made in the House of Commons on Monday 12 October.

    View contribution permalink →

  3. “With permission, I wish to make a Statement on the United Nations General Assembly and related international events that have occurred since the House last met.

    View contribution permalink →

  4. Before I do so, let me first welcome my honourable friend the new Member for Holborn and St Pancras, Sagal Abdi-Wali, to her place. What a journey, from child refugee to Parliament, and what a country—that this story of hope could happen here. I know my honourable friend will enhance this House in so many ways, and I look forward to working with her.

    View contribution permalink →

  5. I took a clear message to the United Nations: after a decade of turbulence, Britain is back and can be relied upon as a consistent and stable partner in an uncertain world, always upholding the shared values set out in the UN charter, rejecting aggression wherever we see it, and always steadfast in our support for Ukraine, as I assured President Zelensky at our meeting in New York.

    View contribution permalink →

  6. In the three weeks since that meeting, Russian strikes have intensified even further, with more attacks on civilians: on apartment blocks housing innocent families and on buses carrying innocent children. When I spoke to President Zelensky on Saturday, he described the step change from Russia, including daylight attacks intended to break the will of Ukraine—and ours. I can tell you that that will never happen. In recent days, we have announced new funding to help Ukraine get through its fifth winter under Russian bombardment and a new sanctions package so that over 90% of Russia’s oil-producing capacity is now covered by UK sanctions.

    View contribution permalink →

  7. The quickest way to get diesel back on to world markets without rewarding the aggressor is an energy ceasefire, with both sides stopping their attacks. I raised this with President Trump in New York. It is what Ukraine wants to see, so I welcome President Trump’s announcement yesterday of a reciprocal energy ceasefire. President Zelensky has assured me that Ukraine would immediately implement it when a start date is confirmed, and I will be discussing this further with him in the coming days.

    View contribution permalink →

  8. NATO is a defensive alliance. We do not seek confrontation, but our resolve to defend our allies and ourselves is absolute, and I was clear in all of my meetings, including with the NATO Secretary-General in Oxfordshire, that we will meet our NATO commitments in full.

    View contribution permalink →

  9. We know that Russia is conducting a campaign of hybrid attacks and sabotage across Europe. In Berlin last week, Chancellor Merz and I agreed a new partnership to tackle these hybrid threats. We must be clear-eyed about attempts to destabilise our democracies. It is why, in my speech to the UN General Assembly, I confirmed our commitment to establish a new centre for information defence, as recommended by the Foreign Affairs Select Committee. More broadly, this is a moment to deepen collaboration with our partners, which is why in Berlin I indicated Britain’s openness to Germany joining the Global Combat Air Programme alongside Italy and Japan.

    View contribution permalink →

  10. In my meeting with President Trump, we discussed the situation in the Middle East. I confirmed Britain’s decision to send air defence and a Voyager aircraft to Saudi Arabia to provide air-to-air refuelling support. I can confirm today that it has already completed 14 operational missions. This support is needed to protect civilians. I condemn the appalling attacks on the King Khalid International Airport. We will continue to stand with Saudi Arabia against the Houthis.

    View contribution permalink →

  11. Since UNGA, we have been in close contact with the US about protective security at our shared bases. I thank our police and military personnel for their swift response to the incidents at RAF Fairford and RAF Molesworth. My right honourable friend the Home Secretary will update the House on the incident at RAF Fairford, but I can confirm our assessment that it is highly likely to have been co-ordinated in Iran, almost certainly directed by Iran’s Islamic Revolutionary Guard Corps. We will not tolerate these threats on our soil. We will crack down on Iran’s use of criminal networks, using our full range of powers to target them and their funding streams, and we will bring further sanctions to restrict the capacity of Iran and the IRGC to do us harm.

    View contribution permalink →

  12. In my meeting with the President, I also raised the Falkland Islands and the clear and declared will of the islanders to remain British. I emphasised that point in my speech to the UN General Assembly and that we will also always do whatever it takes to uphold their will.

    View contribution permalink →

  13. In New York, I also had a positive meeting with the President of the European Commission, Ursula von der Leyen, about the forthcoming UK-EU summit. I can confirm to the House today that it will take place in Brussels on 20 November. This summit presents an opportunity to make progress on two crucial issues: boosting UK growth and controlling illegal immigration. On the table is a trade deal on food and drink products, a deal on emissions trading, progress towards linking our energy systems, a new youth experience scheme, and deeper co-operation on immigration.

    View contribution permalink →

  14. The summit will also be an opportunity to raise our concerns about ‘Made in Europe’, and it is clear to me that there is an opportunity to make progress in all these areas. Together, these deals will add the equivalent of over £10 billion per year to the UK economy by 2040, with the potential to add significantly more. We should not turn our backs on this opportunity, and I hope Members from all sides of this House will get behind the Government’s efforts to land a positive outcome. It is a chance to cut costs and bureaucracy for sectors such as farming.

    View contribution permalink →

  15. At present, entire truckloads of plants or fresh produce can be destroyed because of a single missing stamp or a minor paperwork delay. Fresh meat and fish spoil while waiting in trucks, and tonnes of exports have to be written off. Our largest food export, Scottish salmon, faces a 100% rate of document checks at the border, costing us around £100 million in lost exports. British burgers and other fresh meat products cannot be sold in the EU. Seed potatoes from Scotland and shellfish from Wales are banned. This is having a real impact on businesses, and the agreement on the table could reverse some of that damage. For farmers and food producers, it would lift a burden that can reach £1,400 on a single shipment. For our small businesses, it would mean no more export health certificates, which can cost up to £200 each time. For households, it would ease the pressure on prices in the supermarket. It could help lower energy costs for households and businesses alike.

    View contribution permalink →

  16. In Northern Ireland, the proposed energy deal could cut wholesale energy costs by 20%. On immigration, we could link up our law enforcement efforts once again, sharing more data and criminal records of foreign nationals, as well as ensuring faster electronic evidence from the phones of those behind the gangs. It is in Britain’s interests to secure a deal along these lines, and I will work hard over the next five weeks to achieve that. I believe that our chances of doing so will be enhanced by being open to a discussion about our relationship with the EU in the longer term. If we are serious about promoting growth, controlling immigration, and upholding our values and security, it is a conversation that we must have. Sticking with the status quo is not good enough for Britain. Worse, it would be a major dereliction of duty to turn away. We need to take a calm, clear-eyed, rational look at the world as it is today, to consider what is best for our country.

    View contribution permalink →

  17. Our immediate priority is securing a successful outcome at the summit, and I believe we should then set up a serious dialogue about the different options for our relationship in the long term. At every stage, the British public will be the boss, and I am clear that public opinion currently supports a pragmatic approach, like the one I am suggesting, but if we go into this further phase, we will proceed with care and complete transparency. This is the leadership we need to draw a line under a decade of drift and division, and to take the country forward.

    View contribution permalink →

  18. Beyond Europe, a confident Britain is ready to play our part on the global stage as we take up the presidency of the G20 in 2027. I confirmed in New York that we will place artificial intelligence centre stage in our presidency, to capture the incredible opportunities it presents while guarding against the risks. Leading voices such as the president of Microsoft are saying that Britain is the world leader on AI safety, so we are well placed to take on this role, and to work towards agreeing a single set of global principles and standards on AI, in our G20 presidency year.

    View contribution permalink →

  19. The message to the world is clear: Britain is back. On so many fronts, we are playing our part and looking confidently to the future. We are leading again, so our country can hope again. I commend this Statement to the House”.

    View contribution permalink →

  20. Earl Howe (Con)

    My Lords, I am grateful to the Leader of the House for allowing time for questions on this Statement. In the other place, my right honourable friend the leader of the Opposition set out some of the serious challenges that we are facing as a country, many of which cannot be solved through international engagement without serious hard work at home. As the Official Opposition, we are willing to work with the Government on defence, welfare spending, and support for our allies across the world, particularly Ukraine. The Prime Minister’s Statement was upbeat in its tone, but it was perhaps a pity that he could not have said more about the specific challenges that we are facing as a country. The Prime Minister spoke at some length about the opportunities of a new trade deal with the European Union that might cut through barriers faced by UK exporters. It was encouraging to hear him express confidence that such a deal was attainable. Can the Minister say what has led the Prime Minister to express that degree of confidence that a better deal with the EU is within reach? He said that there is a deal “on the table”, but what we did not hear was what the EU could expect us to concede in return. Will there be any red lines in our position, and if so, what will they be? On this side of the House we of course want to see stronger economic growth, but if we look at what is happening in the EU on growth, it is not encouraging. This week, Chancellor Merz of Germany, the Italian Prime Minister, Meloni, and the Belgian Prime Minister, De Wever, all called for an emergency brake mechanism to help boost the EU’s flagging economic competitiveness. That shows that EU leaders themselves recognise the economic risks of overregulation. Can the Minister explain why the Prime Minister feels that new agreements with the EU would unlock growth when EU leaders themselves are battling against overregulation within the bloc? On a specific point included in the prospective trade deal, the Prime Minister referred to energy prices in Northern Ireland. He said: “In Northern Ireland, the proposed energy deal could cut wholesale energy costs by 20%”. I emphasise the word “wholesale”. I was puzzled by that and would be glad if the Minister could explain what precisely he meant. I was heartened to see the Prime Minister’s unequivocal and steadfast support for Ukraine. That is a position on which we have had cross-party consensus since Putin’s illegal invasion, and I welcome President Zelensky’s visit today. On a specific point relating to sanctions, the Energy Minister, the noble Baroness, Lady Curran, said yesterday in the House that the United Kingdom’s ban on Russian oil “applies to all oil and oil products that originate in Russia, irrespective of the way that they enter the UK ”.—[ Official Report , 13/10/26; col. 115.] Was that statement strictly accurate? Can the Minister confirm that, under the general trade licence for sanctioned processed oil products, some Russian-derived oil products are in fact being imported into this country? Can she say when Ministers intend to discontinue that licence? The Prime Minister made a point of committing the UK to meeting our NATO commitments in full. Yesterday, the Defence Secretary warned of the risk that our allies, if attacked, would prioritise the supply of defence equipment for their own defence over agreed supplies to the United Kingdom. He went on to emphasise the strategic importance of building our sovereign defence supply capabilities. However, we understand from the Prime Minister that we will have to wait until the spending review—possibly as late as next autumn—for confirmation of when the United Kingdom will hit the interim 3% spending target. If we want to build our sovereign defence capabilities, that is a long delay that leaves our own defence manufacturing sector in limbo. Does the Minister agree with the Defence Secretary on the importance of homegrown defence? If she does agree, can she confirm that we will have to wait until next autumn before we know the date by which the Government plan to hit the 3% interim target? The recent Houthi attacks on Saudi Arabia have demonstrated how important our defence capability is. I know that we have committed an RAF Voyager refuelling aircraft to support Saudi Arabia, but in the light of the most recent attacks, what further support will we provide? If the Leader of the House cannot answer that today, will she write to me on the point? We know that the Houthis have been emboldened by Iran, and it is very likely that the Islamic Revolutionary Guard Corps is behind the threat to RAF Fairford. What reassessment of the threat have Ministers made following the incident at RAF Fairford? Can the Minister say what, if any, practical steps to boost security at our air bases are planned? I turn briefly to the threats posed to our overseas territories. The Prime Minister is right to have announced a review of the £35 billion Chagos treaty with Mauritius, which has been overwhelmingly unpopular. Can the Minister say when this review of the policy is set to be completed? Finally, we have heard increasingly aggressive rhetoric from Javier Milei, the President of Argentina, on the sovereignty of the Falkland Islands. The Falklands are British; the Falkland Islanders are clear on that. It was reassuring to read in today’s press of the amphibious assault exercise conducted in the Falklands by soldiers of the Parachute Regiment. On the other hand, we hear that HMS “Protector”, which we rely on to patrol the southern Atlantic, is out of action following engine failure. I would be grateful if the Minister could reassure us that His Majesty’s Government will continue not only to defend our sovereignty over the Falkland Islands but to ensure that we are prepared for any eventuality.

    View contribution permalink →

  21. Lord Purvis of Tweed (LD)

    My Lords, these Benches agree with the Prime Minister that the UK needs to be a consistent and stable partner on the international stage. We want to build and maintain relations, and that is especially the case for our relations with emerging economies where our interests are developing, such as in Africa. It is therefore a disappointment that this job is made harder for the UK by a constant shift of ministerial positions—for example, three Ministers for Africa in just two years. What is definitely not a consistent or stable partnership is our relationship with the Trump Administration. The US decision to assist the Russian war effort is reprehensible. The UK must do what we can to ensure that the US cannot circumvent our sanctions. The Prime Minister’s Statement references the refined oil sanctions, and the noble Earl, Lord Howe, referred to the sanctions introduced in the spring. I might be able to help him with the question that he asked the Leader. The open-ended exemption of the refined oil products in third countries now has a sunset clause attached to it, as a result of my discussions with Minister Stephen Doughty, who wrote to me on 11 June to say that this exemption will be sunsetted on 1 January. The Government issued a statement on GOV.UK—I hope the Official Opposition have access to the internet. Can the Leader confirm that this remains the case under the Burnham premiership? I very much hope so. I raised this with the noble Lord, Lord Wood, at Questions and I hope the Leader can confirm that that loophole will be coming to an end and that we will be able to withstand any pressure from the Trump Administration. We agree that the Government need to be resolute in our defence against any Iranian intervention in the UK. We need a further assessment as to how the IRGC manages to communicate, co-ordinate and potentially conduct activity here at home. I hope that the Leader will update us on how we are closing all of those opportunities and also ensuring that there are no means by which transnational repression by proscribed Iranian terrorist organisations can target individuals here in the United Kingdom, including journalists. On external influence, we welcome the Prime Minister’s statement on Russian interference in British politics, especially that associated with the Brexit referendum. The leader of the Opposition denied that there was any Russian interference in that. So I went back to the Russia report. It is interesting that paragraph 46 of that report is less definitive than the leader of the Opposition suggests that it is. However, the difficulty that we in Parliament have, and indeed the public, is in the very last sentence of the report, where the ISC drew what it considered to be its conclusions. After outlining all the information that it presented, the last sentence of the last conclusion states: “However, we have found *** which suggests that ***. ***.”. That does not help us to have full disclosure as to the extent of Russian interference. Given the Prime Minister’s Statement on Monday, and today, it is now time to publish much more material when it comes to Russian interferences—without three asterisks deleting critical information. We hope that the Government’s efforts to obtain agreements with the European Union on food safety, energy and law enforcement will be successful. The leader of the Opposition said in reference to the Prime Minister seeking improvements in our relationship with the EU compared with the Brexit deal: “He is not going to get a better deal”. These Benches think that the previous Government would have found it hard to get a worse deal, which is proven by the fact that it took them years to mitigate problems with Northern Ireland, and it has taken the current Government to have an agreement with Gibraltar. The noble Earl, Lord Howe, referred to the Falkland Islands and to our commitment to that territory, which I have been to. The previous Government forgot to include the Falklands in the negotiating mandate on Brexit. When I was there, the islanders were furious that they had struggles with Brexit, so we welcome the Government’s efforts to have a better agreement. I was confused by the position that we have just heard because in the Commons the leader of the Opposition criticised the Prime Minister for outlining the objectives of these talks. She said: “I will tell him now, as a former Trade Secretary, that that is not how you conduct negotiations ”.—[ Official Report , Commons, 12/10/26; col. 26.] Now we are being asked what the Government’s red lines are, so there is a lack of consistency in the position of the Opposition. While we want the Government to be successful in their negotiations, these are far too modest ambitions. The Prime Minister said that if the Government are successful in achieving everything they want, it will be the equivalent of a £10 billion a year benefit after the 14th year. We are losing close to £90 billion a year now, and therefore the Government need to remove the red lines. I draw to a close. I am afraid that the Statement is silent on the world’s worst humanitarian crisis—Sudan. The UK is the penholder at the UN Security Council, and we have now had credible information about the use of chemical weapons on civilians in this conflict. The Government need to be clear about what their intentions are. Are they seeking a full investigation by the Organisation for the Prohibition of Chemical Weapons, which is desperately needed to ensure that there is no further scar on humanity and that we are not turning a blind eye to the use of chemical weapons in this conflict? Finally, I hope the Leader can reassert the position on Sudan that we remain determined to see a civilian-led Government, we will not open an embassy in Khartoum until we have a civilian-led Government and we will make sure that there are efforts to protect civilians in this ongoing humanitarian crisis.

    View contribution permalink →

  22. The Lord Privy Seal (Baroness Smith of Basildon) (Lab)

    I thank the noble Earl and the noble Lord for their comments and questions—I will do my best to answer as many as possible—and for the tone in which they expressed them. There is a lot in this Statement. It shows the extent of the Prime Minister’s work since he took office just before the Summer Recess. It is like a tour around the world in some places, with different issues as well as the issues at home. The noble Earl and the noble Lord both raised the annual threat update that we have seen, and the issue of Russian interference. This is serious. I do not know whether noble Lords have had the opportunity to read Sir Ken McCallum’s speech, the questions he took and the answers he gave. I thought the way he expressed himself was highly significant. He stressed that there is an important difference between those attempts and the impact they can have. It is also a matter of record that although there was a lot of activity by the Russians during elections and the Brexit campaign, there is no evidence that it had much impact. Inevitably, they will try, for a reason. They continue to try, and that is escalating. I found Sir Ken’s speech both alarming and encouraging. The work that our agencies do to protect us, much of which we will never know the details of, is seriously impressive. The noble Earl asked about Ukraine, and he is right. There is cross-party support in both Houses for Ukraine. We saw that when President Zelensky visited here, and he has been back in the UK today to see the King and the Prime Minister. That support cannot just be moral support and words; it has to be practical support. That was committed. The Prime Minister said before the meeting that President Zelensky will not go away empty-handed today. Support is ongoing. It is important that both Houses remain totally united, steadfast and robust in our support for Ukraine. It is about our own defence as well, and there is self-interest in that. It is important that we carry on with that support. On sanctions, the noble Earl asked about the dates on the current situation on oil and gas. Currently, about 90% of all Russian oil is sanctioned. That includes products that are refined outside Russia, even though they have originated from Russia. The noble Earl also asked about the spending review and the commitment to NATO spending. He sort of implied that because we have committed to reaching the NATO commitment and spending 3.5% by 2035 nothing is happening in the meantime. It is a process to get to that. The spending review will outline that process. When the previous Labour Government left office, we were spending more than 2.5%. That went down under the Conservative Government. I do not think the Conservative Government ever got to 2.5% spending on defence. That has now increased, and we are over 2.5%. The amount of investment being made in our defence industry is hugely significant. We will invest nearly £300 billion over the next four years. The Ministry of Defence’s budget will reach £74 billion in 2027-28 and by 2029-30 will be 27% higher in real terms than in 2023-24. It is not okay to sit back and wait, have the spending review and make an announcement. This is ongoing expenditure investment that is going on now and will continue to do so. It is right to say that we do not sit back and wait. We cannot afford to do that. The security of the nation is a Government’s first responsibility. There was also a question about Iran and the IRGC. Noble Lords will recall the state threats legislation that this House passed, and the IRGC is now designated. That is critical. That was referenced in the speech from MI5 and the comments of the Prime Minister. Tying this in with Russia, the unwillingness of the previous Government to ask questions about Russia is important. As the Prime Minister said today, the leader of the Opposition said in a previous role that she had not even read the report. We need to ensure that we are open with people. Unless the public understand the nature of the threats and why the Government want to spend more money on defence, it is hard to make the case. Keeping people informed about the nature of the threats and the reality of what this means is going to be crucial. However, sometimes asterisks are going to be important because there is information that cannot be provided in the public domain for national security reasons. I trust the ISC to know when that is the case and when it is not. The noble Earl, Lord Howe, asked why the Prime Minister is confident that he can get a better deal from the EU. I say that it is hard to get a worse one if we look at what has been happening. I looked at some figures about the amount of produce that is being wasted at the moment because of red tape. I always believed that the Conservative Party wanted to reduce red tape and bureaucracy for businesses, yet it seems that when it is Brexit that has caused it, it is not the same problem. Yet many producers are seeing their products rotting at ports or being destroyed. The amount of paperwork to export Scottish salmon, which is a major contributor to our economy, is shocking. It is costing the economy millions of pounds every year. I would not say that we can be guaranteed there is a deal, but the work is going on to make sure we get a deal. The agrifood and drinks deal, the SPS, will add up to £5 billion a year, which will help supermarkets and give better prices, but also it is respect to those producing our food that it does not go rotting on the quayside. If the noble Lord wants to say to farmers, “We think the deal we’ve got is a good one”, he is on his own as far as I am concerned. It is a poor deal, and we will do everything we can to engage with Europe to get a better deal for the people of this country. The Prime Minister has been very clear on this. I am being told I have run out of time. Those questions I have not answered, I will come back to during the course of other questions.

    View contribution permalink →

  23. Captain of the Honourable Corps of Gentlemen-at-Arms and Chief Whip (Lord Kennedy of Southwark) (Lab Co-op)

    My Lords, we now come to up to 20 minutes of Back-Bench questions, and the first question should come from the Conservative Benches.

    View contribution permalink →

  24. Baroness Monckton of Dallington Forest (Con)

    My Lords, the noble Baroness the Leader said that we have a moral and practical obligation still to support Ukraine, and I am sure we all agree on that. So why have the Government reduced the money given to hosts of Ukrainian families from £350 to £100 a month? I declare an interest as someone who has hosted a Ukrainian family, and we have another one coming soon.

    View contribution permalink →

  25. Baroness Smith of Basildon (Lab)

    I have to say to the noble Baroness that I am not aware of that at all. Friends of mine are hosting a Ukrainian family and they have not raised it with me at any point. I will have to write to her—I will go back and check on that. I have asked my colleagues here, and they are not aware of that either. I will look into it for her and will write to her.

    View contribution permalink →

  26. Baroness Ludford (LD)

    I thank the noble Baroness the Leader of the House for repeating the Statement. I have a brief word on Ukraine. It is extremely important that we remain very solid. I am glad that the new Prime Minister is, and that there is such cross-party support. It is not only crucial for Ukraine but is attracting international respect for this country, through the degree of consistency and strength that we are showing to Ukraine. My questions are about Europe, inevitably. I very much welcome the Prime Minister breaking the omerta that has prevailed for many years. He talks—and I welcome this—about a “serious dialogue about the different options for our relationship in the long term”. It is important that that dialogue encompasses issues not only of the economy but of people’s sense of identity, which was completely neglected in the Brexit referendum. I hope that will happen. But you cannot have a dialogue about different options unless the Prime Minister is willing to set out what those options are. I hope that we will hear sooner rather than later about that. Obviously, my side has put forward the single market and the customs union, and there is going to have to be some kind of stepped approach. I hope we get some flesh on the bones about that. Lastly, the noble Baroness talked about the red tape of the Brexit deal that the red-tape-hating Conservatives managed to deliver. I am on the Northern Ireland Scrutiny Committee and I feel so much for businesses in Northern Ireland, which are suffering from the current situation. Solving that would help a great deal.

    View contribution permalink →

  27. Baroness Smith of Basildon (Lab)

    I am grateful to the noble Baroness. It is always the case that, when we discuss matters European, the Official Opposition say we are going too far and the Liberal Democrats say we are not going far enough. For clarity, the Prime Minister made it very clear that we respect the result of the referendum. We are not removing our red lines; they are clearly in place. As he put it, and I think he is right to put it in these terms, he is concerned about the damage Brexit has done to the economy and about economic growth, but he is also concerned about trust in politics. In our last manifesto, we were clear about the red lines. In fact, the Brexit referendum informed the manifesto when we talked about the red lines. But he has also said that he wants to have all options on the table. There is no predetermined outcome and he will come forward with more discussions on that, and they should involve all parties and everyone should be able to contribute to those discussions. The noble Baroness is right on Northern Ireland. Somebody mentioned that the Falkland Islands were not considered during Brexit. I do not remember Northern Ireland being discussed during the Brexit debate. I do remember a former Prime Minister telling businesses in Northern Island, “Don’t worry, there’ll be no checks and no forms for you to fill in. If you get any, send them to me”. I do not know whether Boris Johnson has had all the forms that Northern Ireland businesses have to complete sent to him, but people did not understand the full implications. If we can remove some of those—the export health certificates and the product sampling costs—and some of the red tape and bureaucracy in the discussions that are ongoing at the summit, that would be a good thing for businesses and for growth in this country. Yes, there will have to be a proper assessment. It would be wrong for any Government not to look at decisions that have been taken and make assessments of where they have been beneficial and where they have been damaging—a proper assessment of any benefits and disbenefits and the impact on this country. The Prime Minister has made his views clear on it, and that kind of assessment is needed to look at what action could be taken further in future. He has been clear that that would have to be agreed by the public, because, as he says, the public are the boss.

    View contribution permalink →

  28. Lord Craig of Radley (CB)

    My Lords, would the noble Baroness agree that, in the light of the increasing threat to Middle East bases used by American aircraft and the losses of aircraft on those bases, their interest in the continuing availability of Diego Garcia as UK sovereign territory is now ever more important and explains why, in President Trump’s exchanges with the Prime Minister, the President emphasised once again the importance of Diego Garcia and its sovereignty to the UK?

    View contribution permalink →

  29. Baroness Smith of Basildon (Lab)

    The noble and gallant Lord makes a key point. We regard Diego Garcia as a key strategic military asset for both the UK and the US, and discussions are ongoing. It is our shared security that is important, and we work together on this. Maintaining the long-term operation of the base is really important and the Prime Minister will continue to discuss that. That has been driving the negotiations since they started, in 2022, I think. As the noble and gallant Lord will be aware, it has sometimes been three steps forward and one step back—or two steps back, even. As the Prime Minister has said, we will continue to work on this. He will be discussing these issues with the American Administration and the President, to see whether we can reach a conclusion and an agreement.

    View contribution permalink →

  30. Lord Forbes of Newcastle (Lab)

    My Lords, I have been struck during my relatively short time in your Lordships’ House by the increasing frequency with which AI contributes to discussions and questions in this Chamber. I therefore ask my noble friend the Leader of the House if she can confirm that it is the Government’s view and position that decisions about the regulation of AI should be taken by democratically elected Governments expressing sovereign intent on behalf of their citizens, rather than by industry leaders alone. If that is the case, this will require significant international collaboration, through a variety of mechanisms. Is this therefore a position that the Government are prepared to advocate in their international discussions, especially in the forthcoming G20 summit?

    View contribution permalink →

  31. Baroness Smith of Basildon (Lab)

    The short answer is yes. The slightly longer answer is that the Government have already said that this will be a key focus when we are holding the chair of the G20 that is coming up. It will be discussed in the summit, no doubt, at the G20 meetings. The issues we have to look at are security, the benefits that can accrue, where the dangers are and how we work together internationally. This is not something that any one country can deal with on its own; it has to be a global effort. It has to be Governments looking at how they can benefit their citizens through AI and how they can protect their citizens from AI when essential. The work is going on. I think this is the first time the Government have a dedicated AI Minister who sits around the Cabinet table. We also have across every department—indeed, we have discussed it at Cabinet on more than one occasion already—responsibilities around AI. It is not, as I think my noble friend Lady Twycross said earlier today, something that you can put in a box and say it is in just one area. It has to be across government and across nations. It will be a key focus for our Prime Minister at the G20.

    View contribution permalink →

  32. Lord Leigh of Hurley (Con)

    My Lords, I thank the Leader of the House for allowing us to have this debate. The Prime Minister mentioned Fairford. He said that it was “almost certainly directed” by the IRGC, and quite properly and correctly, he has sanctioned two Iranian individuals whom the Government believe were responsible, for which I congratulate him. However, does she understand the revulsion—and I choose the word with care—that many of us felt at the photograph of our Foreign Secretary shaking hands with the Foreign Minister of Iran? I honestly felt gut-wrenched to see that my Foreign Secretary should shake hands with a person who is a member of the Government of Iran. Does she not accept that that sort of photograph and earlier messages that have been sent will lead to a result in the Israeli elections which he may not be happy with? Care should be taken at this very sensitive time to avoid making those sorts of handshakes or comments that will lead to people taking a view in the Israeli elections that we might not be happy with. Finally—and I accept that she may not have a briefing on this point—what is the Government’s response to the announcement yesterday by President Abbas, who is in the 21st year of his four-year period, that the elections in November will be postponed again? When the Government recognised the State of Palestine, we were told that this would lead to a democratic state. We were told that there would be a player in the region who could be respected, and yet they have cancelled their elections. I have received messages from Palestinians, particularly in east Jerusalem, who are really upset with this. I would be interested to know the Government’s perspective and views on this announcement.

    View contribution permalink →

  33. Baroness Smith of Basildon (Lab)

    I am grateful to the noble Lord. He will be aware that the Foreign Secretary would certainly pull no punches in his discussions with Ministers from Iran and he has been very clear on that. Governments over many years have been having meetings and we need to keep that engagement open. We do have British citizens who are in prison in Iran, and we want to do everything we can to support them. It is a meeting, but I understand the point he makes. On the Palestinian elections, I do not think the noble Lord has seen the joint statement that has been issued by the Foreign Secretary and the Foreign Ministers of Australia, Canada and France as well. A joint statement has been issued that says that they “deeply regret the Palestinian President’s decision to postpone the … elections as well as the Presidential elections to September 2027”. It has been two decades now since there have been elections, which is deeply disappointing. The statement goes on: “We acknowledge that significant challenges and impediments have affected the ability to conduct elections in a manner fully consistent with international standards ... We commend the important work of the Central Elections Commission in advancing practical preparations to address these challenges and facilitate voter participation”. We want to see free and fair elections. I can give the noble Lord a copy of the statement from the Foreign Secretaries if that would help him. Moreover, at the bottom of the statement, they “reiterate our longstanding position that Hamas can have no role in the future governance of Palestine”.

    View contribution permalink →

  34. Lord Kerr of Kinlochard (CB)

    My Lords, I recall that the noble Lord, Lord Cameron of Chipping Norton, shook hands with the Iranian Foreign Minister at the United Nations. Diplomacy is about talking to foes as well as friends. My question is about being a stable, consistent and reliable partner and about the absence in the Statement on Monday of any reference to development aid. I would like the Leader to ask people in her party—the party of Judith Hart and Clare Short—whether it is right that aid to Malawi, for example, which is £50 million this year, will be £5 million in 2028-29. There are massive cuts for all of Africa, but with no softening for the poorest or for Commonwealth countries, and Malawi is one of the poorest 10 countries in the world. Do the cuts for Africa really have to be that big, and do they have to be so heavily skewed against our friends? How does that fit with consistency and stable partnerships?

    View contribution permalink →

  35. Baroness Smith of Basildon (Lab)

    I understand the point the noble Lord makes, and we remain committed to being able to increase ODA as and when circumstances allow. But he will be aware of the amount of money the Government are spending around the world, and direct aid through ODA is not the only way to support these countries. There is more we can do in partnerships and development, creating and supporting economies, providing humanitarian aid, and an additional £100 million is going to Yemen at the moment to support humanitarian aid there as well. The needs around the world are greater than ever. The noble Lord, Lord Purvis, mentioned Sudan as well, and there is support there. I will take back the points that the noble Lord makes, but we should not think that the only way we can support our friends and those in need is through direct ODA.

    View contribution permalink →

  36. Lord Wallace of Saltaire (LD)

    My Lords, the noble Baroness in her Statement today remarked that, unless the public understand the nature of the threat, they will not be able to help in making sure we resist it. I would like to pursue that question. It is quite clear that the previous Government did underplay the nature of the threat. It is equally clear—I have just checked back on some of the notes on this—that Boris Johnson, for example, prevented the Intelligence and Security Committee from publishing a fuller version of the Russia report, partly because it was deeply embarrassing to the Conservative Party. We had, under the Conservatives, a Defending Democracy Taskforce, but we all know very little about it. It does not report to Parliament, unlike its French, Canadian, or Australian equivalents. The Prime Minister’s Statement on Monday talked about a new national centre for information defence, about which we so far have almost no detailed information. Can the Minister take back to the Government the argument that, unless our public are educated about the nature of foreign interference in British politics from a range of hostile states, we will not be successful in combating them because the public will not understand when these hybrid threats arise?

    View contribution permalink →

  37. Baroness Smith of Basildon (Lab)

    That was not what I said, but it was sort of in that area, and the noble Lord is absolutely right that the public need to understand and we need honesty and transparency as far as possible. I should also say it is not always possible to be completely transparent if information would put British citizens at risk or our operations at risk. However, you do not have to read very far into the speech yesterday from MI5 on state threats, and the comments made by the Prime Minister, to know that the threats are many and varied. They are threats against individuals and threats against infrastructure, and the nature of those—whether we are talking about undersea cables or whether we are talking about cyber attacks—is varied. Even this week, we have seen threats to commercial companies and cyber attacks. We do not know where they have come from or how they have been done, but it is a threat nevertheless. He is right that the public do have to be made aware. I think we have a Prime Minister who is very keen to be as open as he possibly can—we have seen that from many of the things he said—and to look at things in a different way. I am confident that we can have a more grown-up conversation about this. You do not want to alarm people unnecessarily, but you do want to let them know the nature of the threats and what is being done. As I mentioned before, much work has been done by the security services, the counterterrorism police and our police forces in negating those threats and tackling them, and much of that we will never hear of because of the fantastic and excellent professional work that they do. But, yes, we have to ensure the public are aware that, when the Government take action, there is a very strong reason for doing so.

    View contribution permalink →

  38. Baroness Griffin of Princethorpe (Lab)

    My Lords, despite my continuous requests, Brexit was undertaken with no—I repeat no—economic or social impact study of its effects on the north-west region, a region of over 6 million people. Can my noble friend the Leader of the House undertake that new and improved relationships with the EU will be considered for their economic, social and cultural impacts for all of the regions of the UK?

    View contribution permalink →

  39. Baroness Smith of Basildon (Lab)

    I think there were two points there. One is on the breadth of issues to be dealt with—economic, social and cultural. We have had many debates in this House about the cultural impact on our creative industries, but my noble friend makes a wider point about all areas of the country being affected and how those issues can be addressed. Particularly when we have No. 10 North looking at economic growth, there is a real determination within this Government that these impacts on growth and these kinds of issues are looked at across the whole country, not just in a few areas.

    View contribution permalink →

  40. Lord Maude of Horsham (Con)

    My Lords, does the Leader of the House agree with the argument made by Sir Tony Blair in his very long essay published in May this year, about the European Union reversing its approach to technology regulation, which, in his broad words, weighs the dangers of technology much too heavily versus “seizing the opportunities” of new technology? He argues that until that changes, it would be a very big mistake for the United Kingdom to contemplate rejoining it. Indeed, he argued that rejoining the European Union is not the answer to Britain’s situation in 2026.

    View contribution permalink →

  41. Baroness Smith of Basildon (Lab)

    That is precisely why there has to be a full assessment of what all the options could be, so that an assessment can be made of what the country wants to do. To suggest that everything is right in Europe would be a fallacy; that would not do justice to the debate. At the moment, we have real concerns about the “Made in Europe” laws. That is a part of the negotiations we will be having at the summit. It is premature to get into that argument, because we have not decided on a way forward yet. There are issues of what the benefits and the detriments would be. But I put it to the noble Lord that when we exited—when we Brexited—we lost the opportunity to influence regulations and laws within Europe, so we have this awful situation where things are happening and we are just not part of it or able to influence them in any way. The whole discussion of what the route forward is will look at all these issues, because obviously they have to be taken into account.

    View contribution permalink →

Source: UK Parliament Hansard API. Debate ID: 5416620.