Contribution
My Lords, I am grateful to the Leader of the House for allowing time for questions on this Statement. In the other place, my right honourable friend the leader of the Opposition set out some of the serious challenges that we are facing as a country, many of which cannot be solved through international engagement without serious hard work at home. As the Official Opposition, we are willing to work with the Government on defence, welfare spending, and support for our allies across the world, particularly Ukraine. The Prime Minister’s Statement was upbeat in its tone, but it was perhaps a pity that he could not have said more about the specific challenges that we are facing as a country.
The Prime Minister spoke at some length about the opportunities of a new trade deal with the European Union that might cut through barriers faced by UK exporters. It was encouraging to hear him express confidence that such a deal was attainable. Can the Minister say what has led the Prime Minister to express that degree of confidence that a better deal with the EU is within reach? He said that there is a deal “on the table”, but what we did not hear was what the EU could expect us to concede in return. Will there be any red lines in our position, and if so, what will they be?
On this side of the House we of course want to see stronger economic growth, but if we look at what is happening in the EU on growth, it is not encouraging. This week, Chancellor Merz of Germany, the Italian Prime Minister, Meloni, and the Belgian Prime Minister, De Wever, all called for an emergency brake mechanism to help boost the EU’s flagging economic competitiveness. That shows that EU leaders themselves recognise the economic risks of overregulation. Can the Minister explain why the Prime Minister feels that new agreements with the EU would unlock growth when EU leaders themselves are battling against overregulation within the bloc?
On a specific point included in the prospective trade deal, the Prime Minister referred to energy prices in Northern Ireland. He said:
“In Northern Ireland, the proposed energy deal could cut wholesale energy costs by 20%”.
I emphasise the word “wholesale”. I was puzzled by that and would be glad if the Minister could explain what precisely he meant.
I was heartened to see the Prime Minister’s unequivocal and steadfast support for Ukraine. That is a position on which we have had cross-party consensus since Putin’s illegal invasion, and I welcome President Zelensky’s visit today. On a specific point relating to sanctions, the Energy Minister, the noble Baroness, Lady Curran, said yesterday in the House that the United Kingdom’s ban on Russian oil
“applies to all oil and oil products that originate in Russia, irrespective of the way that they enter the UK”.—[Official Report, 13/10/26; col. 115.]
Was that statement strictly accurate? Can the Minister confirm that, under the general trade licence for sanctioned processed oil products, some Russian-derived oil products are in fact being imported into this country? Can she say when Ministers intend to discontinue that licence?
The Prime Minister made a point of committing the UK to meeting our NATO commitments in full. Yesterday, the Defence Secretary warned of the risk that our allies, if attacked, would prioritise the supply of defence equipment for their own defence over agreed supplies to the United Kingdom. He went on to emphasise the strategic importance of building our sovereign defence supply capabilities. However, we understand from the Prime Minister that we will have to wait until the spending review—possibly as late as next autumn—for confirmation of when the United Kingdom will hit the interim 3% spending target. If we want to build our sovereign defence capabilities, that is a long delay that leaves our own defence manufacturing sector in limbo. Does the Minister agree with the Defence Secretary on the importance of homegrown defence? If she does agree, can she confirm that we will have to wait until next autumn before we know the date by which the Government plan to hit the 3% interim target?
The recent Houthi attacks on Saudi Arabia have demonstrated how important our defence capability is. I know that we have committed an RAF Voyager refuelling aircraft to support Saudi Arabia, but in the light of the most recent attacks, what further support will we provide? If the Leader of the House cannot answer that today, will she write to me on the point? We know that the Houthis have been emboldened by Iran, and it is very likely that the Islamic Revolutionary Guard Corps is behind the threat to RAF Fairford. What reassessment of the threat have Ministers made following the incident at RAF Fairford? Can the Minister say what, if any, practical steps to boost security at our air bases are planned?
I turn briefly to the threats posed to our overseas territories. The Prime Minister is right to have announced a review of the £35 billion Chagos treaty with Mauritius, which has been overwhelmingly unpopular. Can the Minister say when this review of the policy is set to be completed?
Finally, we have heard increasingly aggressive rhetoric from Javier Milei, the President of Argentina, on the sovereignty of the Falkland Islands. The Falklands are British; the Falkland Islanders are clear on that. It was reassuring to read in today’s press of the amphibious assault exercise conducted in the Falklands by soldiers of the Parachute Regiment. On the other hand, we hear that HMS “Protector”, which we rely on to patrol the southern Atlantic, is out of action following engine failure. I would be grateful if the Minister could reassure us that His Majesty’s Government will continue not only to defend our sovereignty over the Falkland Islands but to ensure that we are prepared for any eventuality.