E

Earl Howe (Con)

Speaking in the House of Lords on 9 November 2026

Debate

Health Bill

Contribution

My Lords, in moving Amendment 32 in my name and that of my noble friend Lord Kamall, I will also speak to Amendments 37, 38 and 86. These amendments, like those in the preceding group, concern the relationship between the Secretary of State and integrated care boards and, in particular, the powers of direction that the Government propose to introduce through the Bill. I hope the Committee will forgive me for having separated these four amendments out from those of the noble Lord, Lord Scriven, but I have done so because I felt it would be useful to debate these provisions from a slightly different angle from the one that he adopted, albeit persuasively, in some of his earlier amendments. I have already set out my concerns about the mixed messages that the Bill sends out regarding where accountability for decision-making in the health service should lie, and the inherent contradiction of legislating for open-ended ministerial powers of direction over ICBs against the background of an explicit government policy that recognises the benefits of devolving decision-making to a local level. I will not repeat the points that I have already made on that theme. I was reassured by the Minister’s statement in response to the last group that there is no intention to micromanage the NHS. Nevertheless, I underline the point that the powers as drafted would not protect decisions that ICBs may choose to make in some very important areas: which services to provide, how to allocate budgets across a population, and whether and how services should be reconfigured. I took the point made by the noble Lord, Lord Hunt, about service reconfiguration, and I will say more about that in a second. But, armed with the powers in the Bill, the Secretary of State would be able to interfere with all those things. That is the backdrop. Let me instead focus on the specific provisions of these amendments, which have one guiding purpose: to propose a set of basic, overarching principles that should govern the exercise of the powers of direction in any given set of circumstances. Amendment 37 is perhaps the most substantive. It would require the Secretary of State to be satisfied that a direction is necessary and proportionate, and that its objectives would not reasonably be achieved through guidance, agreement with the integrated care board, existing oversight arrangements or some other less restrictive means. In other words, I am suggesting that the power of ministerial direction should essentially be a power of last resort, and not, as it could be read as being, a ready option available to Ministers whenever they happen to disagree with a local decision or the direction of travel taken by local decision-makers. The amendment would also require the Secretary of State to consult the relevant integrated care board and consider the potential consequences of a direction for the ICB’s finances, its operations and its ability to take decisions in the best interests of patients. There are two important principles at play here. First, if we believe that local healthcare leaders are best placed to understand the needs of their communities and to commission in their best interests, their views ought to carry considerable weight before Ministers decide to override their judgment by insisting on something else. The other principle is that of local autonomy and the value we should attach to it. The moment that local leaders in the health service believe there is no point trying to do things in an innovative way to improve the delivery of services, for fear that they will be told by the powers that be to direct their energies elsewhere, we will breed a set of leaders who are leaders only in name. The best leaders are those who are motivated to take new ideas forward and to excel. I am proposing this amendment as a basic constraint on the unfettered use of the ministerial power. As the Minister said in response to the previous group, there may be urgent and unexpected circumstances in which consultation cannot reasonably take place beforehand, and the amendment makes provision for that. Outside those circumstances, it is entirely reasonable to expect Ministers to explain why intervention is necessary and why other options would not be sufficient. Amendments 32 and 38 are about another principle, that of transparency. They each seek to ensure that, where directions are issued, there is a clear and publicly available record of what has been decided and why. They would require the Secretary of State to publish a statement within seven working days of a direction, setting out the reasons for the direction, its intended duration, its expected financial and operational consequences and the resources available to the integrated care board to comply with it. Crucially, they would also require an explanation of how the direction might affect the board’s ability to meet the needs and priorities of its local population. That is particularly important. A ministerial direction is no small step to take. Take service reconfiguration as an example. If a Minister directs an integrated care board to pursue a particular course, and doing so requires the board to divert resources away from another area of activity previously deemed a local priority, then everybody—Parliament, patients and the public—should be able to understand that. They should know who made the decision, why it was made, what alternatives were considered and what the consequences are expected to be. If the direction results in poorer performance elsewhere, there should be a clear record of whether that was the consequence of a local decision or of a requirement imposed by the Secretary of State.

More from Earl Howe (Con)

Other recent Hansard contributions by the same speaker.

About Hansard

Hansard is the official verbatim record of proceedings in the UK Parliament. Every word spoken in the Commons and Lords is recorded and published — this page is a single contribution from that record.