L

Lord Stevens of Birmingham (CB)

Speaking in the House of Lords on 9 November 2026

Debate

Health Bill

Contribution

I wonder whether this might be an opportunity for the Minister to set out how the new accountability arrangements would work in practice, because the amendment from the noble Earl, Lord Howe, would rightly require that, in the event that a power of direction is used, a rationale is set forth so that it is clear why a decision was taken and where responsibility for it sits. One illustration of this might be the situation facing maternity services in Norfolk, which the noble Baroness, Lady Coffey, mentioned. I quickly had a look at the situation there. Of the three hospitals, two had under 2,000 births a year, and the prediction is that, within a decade, two of those three hospitals will be delivering four or fewer births a day. So there is a question about the sustainability and safety of that service. If, in the interests of a political direction, these new powers are used to insist that those small maternity units with a potential safety concern remain open, even though it might be hard to staff them and to provide the level of back-up said to be required, where will accountability for the safety questions sit? Will the Care Quality Commission, when it arrives at those hospitals, do an inspection to determine whether women may be put at risk, if that is the case? Will the Care Quality Commission then issue findings against the Secretary of State—potentially with criminal proceedings in certain circumstances—or against the local provider or the ICB? To the extent that this group is about the integrated care boards, let us not forget that, as I understand it, the proposed route for direct influence from the Secretary of State to those hospitals in Norfolk would be only partly through the ICB strategic commissioning decision. The performance management function of those hospitals, including the way in which they manage their safety, will now be routed through this new offshore special health authority, which will then route back, on some sort of new vector, directly into the hospitals concerned. Can the Minister explain, in the interests of transparency and political accountability, how will it work in a situation like that? Where will the decision-making sit? When safety concerns are front and centre, will the Secretary of State override the individual provider, and will they do so via the new special health authority or just rely on the commissioning role of the ICB?

More from Lord Stevens of Birmingham (CB)

Other recent Hansard contributions by the same speaker.

About Hansard

Hansard is the official verbatim record of proceedings in the UK Parliament. Every word spoken in the Commons and Lords is recorded and published — this page is a single contribution from that record.