Contribution
My Lords, I thank all noble Lords for their contributions. I am grateful for the support from across the House for these regulations.
I will address the several questions that the noble Lord, Lord Hunt, asked in respect of the strike days, and I will share some statistics with him. Across 2024-25, there was an annual average of 773,000 days lost to industrial action. This is a decrease from the highs of 2022 and 2023 under the previous Government, when 2.5 million and 2.6 million days respectively were lost to strike action, the most for over three decades, and a significant increase from the previous decade, which saw an average loss of 345,000 days per year between 2012 and 2019. Let me remind the noble Lord again that in 2019-20 and 2020-21, there were, respectively, 24 and 15 tribunal hearings related to detriments for trade union membership, the closest parallel to this legislation. We expect the number to be similarly low for detriments imposed for industrial action.
The noble Lord also asked about protecting public services. Protecting patients, service users and the public remains essential. Employers can take genuine measures to maintain critical operations, and address health and safety risks. These regulations do not require managers to ignore safeguarding concerns. The fair treatment of workers and responsible management of essential services must operate together.
The noble Lord also asked whether there was a full impact assessment. I agree with the noble Lord that employers’ concerns deserve a substantive answer. We conducted a consultation, recorded concerns about litigation, administration, and operational flexibility, and we considered them. The department judged that the expected impact fell below the threshold for requiring a full impact assessment, reflecting the limited use of these detriments. However, we will monitor implementation through stakeholder feedback, and the published memorandum commits to a review in 2031. The memorandum also identifies the £10 million equivalent annual net direct cost to business threshold, and the planned non-statutory review.
The noble Lord also asked about the burden on businesses. Responses to our consultation showed that employers rarely, if ever, impose detriments for taking industrial action, as I said earlier. These changes will have a very limited impact on the vast majority of employers. It is general good practice for employers to keep records of business and disciplinary decisions relating to workers. These records will help deter any speculative claims. On the burden of recording employer decisions, there is no evidence to suggest that workers will bring additional speculative claims as a result of this legislation. Workers are already protected from detriments for their trade union membership and general activities. Our understanding is that few speculative claims are brought under those provisions, so we would not expect this to lead to any increase in such cases.
The noble Lord, Lord Goddard, asked about pay deduction. The precise amount of pay that can be deducted is subject to complex case law, and depends on the particular facts and circumstances, including a worker’s contractual terms and ways of working. It would therefore not be practical to codify the case law in these regulations. The position is not made any more complex by these regulations. In the majority of cases, the matter of pay deduction is simple, and often corresponds to one day’s pay withheld for one day’s strike. On the question about guidance, I will write to the noble Lord after speaking to officials, but, obviously, this is going to take effect from 30 October.
This statutory instrument addresses a simple issue—namely, protecting workers from unfair treatment if they take industrial action—which I am sure all Members support. Many will have thought that this basic protection already exists in legislation. However, the 2024 Supreme Court judgment showed that this statutory instrument is necessary to ensure that workers are properly protected. This legislation will close this gap and ensure that workers are properly protected. I beg to move.