L

Lord Jackson of Peterborough (Con)

Speaking in the House of Lords on 14 October 2026

Debate

Trade Unions (Right to Access Workplaces) Regulations 2026

Contribution

My Lords, I am pleased to support my noble friend on the Front Bench. If the previous instrument was gilding the lily, this is overegging the pudding, I have to say. The burden placed on employers to demonstrate that access arrangements do not reasonably interfere with their business, and referring the matter to the CAC, are both onerous and time-consuming. I have to ask the fundamental question: what right do trade unionists have to come into a business every week, demanding to involve themselves in the technical, granular activities of that business? Even His Majesty’s Revenue & Customs does not avail itself of those opportunities. Why should this be part of secondary legislation? Why are the trade unions treated differently from anyone else? Weekly access as a model is a burdensome expectation of the CAC, which would significantly disrupt businesses and employers. There are also potential privacy concerns around digital access inclusion as part of the union’s right to access the workplace. It is barely believable: this is not about going in and having regular access, which is completely laudable to people who are already trade union members; this applies to people who are not trade union members. If you have one person who is a trade union member and nine who are not, on what basis should that trade union official have a right to go into that business, disrupt it and stop it supporting the bottom line, jobs, prosperity and opportunity? We are told that the regulations do not impose legal obligations but that the provisions are “admissible in evidence and are to be taken into account in proceedings before any court, tribunal or the CAC where they consider them relevant”. This arguably gives the code a quasi-legal status, which perhaps it should not have outside of statutory or secondary legislation. Let us be honest and not be naive—trade unions are going to push the envelope on this. They are going to be as difficult as possible, using this code in order to have as much access as they possibly can. We are looking at the development of quite a draconian enforcement scheme via the Central Arbitration Committee contained in the code. It is going to be time-consuming and bureaucratic. I would like to ask some specific questions of the Minister. An impact assessment has not been prepared for the instrument because apparently the department has concluded that “annual costs to business are expected to remain below the De Minimis threshold”. Is it saying that there will not be very significant costs of these regulations and this code of practice? Again, there is no evidence to support that. In respect of the costs and the benefits, the Government say: “We expect the equivalent annual direct cost to business, charities and voluntary bodies … to remain below the £10 million de minimis threshold. I do not believe that. They then say: “The benefits of the policy have not been monetised”. This is the Government who say that they are absolutely laser-like in their focus on growth, but they do not even bother to avail themselves of the opportunity to look at data to decide whether this will have a real benefit to the economy. I come back to the point that my noble friend Lord Sharpe raised about the statutorily supported national bargaining frameworks for adult social care and school support staff. Do we really believe that hard-pressed school support staff and people in the social care sector—which under all Governments are under enormous strain in recruitment and retention, and in getting to the next client or closing down another client to make sure they are fed properly, cleaned or washed—have time to be negotiating with trade unionists, when some of them are micro-businesses in restricted geographical areas with a small workforce? It is bonkers, and it is a completely fantastical approach to the real world. The Government do not care about that. They were warned about this by His Majesty’s Opposition. The chickens will come home to roost. In the particular areas of school support and social care, jobs will be lost and that will be a very regrettable thing. I ask the Government to think again.

More from Lord Jackson of Peterborough (Con)

Other recent Hansard contributions by the same speaker.

About Hansard

Hansard is the official verbatim record of proceedings in the UK Parliament. Every word spoken in the Commons and Lords is recorded and published — this page is a single contribution from that record.