Contribution
My Lords, I am very grateful to the Minister for explaining and introducing this statutory instrument, to which I have tabled a regret amendment, but he will not be surprised to know that I take a very different view from the one that he has just explained.
Let us begin with the Government’s own consultation. When respondents were asked whether weekly access should be a model term, just 4.6% agreed and 95.3% disagreed. When they were asked whether two working days’ notice should be the model for subsequent access visits, just 7.5% agreed and 92.4% disagreed. So, rather than being carefully considered, as the Minister has contended, I am afraid that the conclusions look neither careful nor considered.
On the two most controversial aspects of this SI, weekly access and two working days’ notice, the Government have proceeded despite overwhelming opposition among the business community. So can the Minister tell the House what evidence the Government received which they considered sufficiently compelling to outweigh that response?
These regulations implement one of the most far-reaching changes to industrial relations contained in the Government’s unemployment Act. They create a statutory route by which an independent trade union can obtain physical access to a workplace, even where those workers are not union members. The union does not even have to be recognised by the employer, nor does it have to demonstrate that it already has members in that workplace, and such an intrusion is a complete violation of the property rights of business.
The exemption in the regulations applies only below 21 workers, meaning that businesses with no HR department, no in-house lawyer and no industrial relations team or experience are going to have to deal with some of these intrusions. It will guarantee that a large number of businesses will choose not to expand beyond 21 workers to avoid the hassle of all of this.
On Report on the Employment Rights Bill, the Official Opposition tried to protect SMEs from precisely this outcome. The Federation of Small Businesses explicitly supported that approach, warning that smaller employers simply do not have the HR infrastructure or the legal teams available to larger companies to navigate complex access procedures and negotiations. It is no surprise that the Government opposed us; unfortunately, the Liberal Democrats also abandoned the small business argument.
In April this year, the British Chambers of Commerce, the CBI, the Federation of Small Businesses, the Institute of Directors, Make UK, the CIPD and the Recruitment and Employment Confederation wrote jointly to the Employment Rights Minister, and yet they have been completely ignored. Their conclusion was that the absence of a structured dialogue had produced an outcome which failed to address businesses’ fundamental concerns over significant disruption from increased access rights.
These new burdens also come at a very peculiar moment. The new Prime Minister, Andy Burnham, has said:
“For too long, businesses have been carrying the burden of rising costs”,
and he has promised that his Government will “bring down costs”. Does the Prime Minister even support these regulations? If he does, how does he reconcile potentially weekly union access, new statutory response and negotiation processes, the Soviet-sounding Central Arbitration Committee proceedings and potentially very substantial penalties, as we have just heard, with his stated ambition to reduce costs on British businesses? I remind noble Lords that those penalties can go up to £500,000. That is not proportionate.
The Government’s own costing does little to reassure. The Explanatory Note says that no full impact assessment has been produced for the regulations because no significant impact on the private, voluntary or public sector is foreseen. Well, how is that possible? Are the Government being deliberately ignorant, or are they just incompetent?
The public sector raises an additional concern. The Local Government Association warned that arrangements should not interfere with operational priorities or the provision of vital public services, including schools, waste depots and other controlled environments. The Homecare Association has said that no assessment of this cost to publicly funded care was published, and that providers have received no additional funding to meet it. For England’s homecare, supported living and extra care workforce, it estimates that if 25% of workers attended weekly one-hour meetings, the additional cost could be around £266 million. Its extreme worst-case scenario of weekly attendance by the entire workforce exceeds £1 billion a year. The association also points out that around 80% of homecare is purchased by the state. So, after all the talk from the Prime Minister about reforming care, the Government’s measures are going to divert scarce resources into paid attendance at union meetings, resources that ultimately come from providers, councils and taxpayers.
I want to finish with two very specific questions. The first comes from a business organisation which asked us this this morning. If this is what the Government think a good business must do, how they will empower trade unions against employers who fail to meet this standard, what standards will be expected of how trade unions conduct themselves, and how do we protect good employers against trade unions which do not? Can the Minister address that very well-judged concern? My second, very specific question to the Minister is: how is the CAC qualified to make judgments about national security? By definition, it cannot be.
These regulations read less like the balanced and carefully calibrated framework promised to this House and more like a trade union wish list imposed on our job and wealth creators. So, like in the previous debate, I would say enjoy it while it lasts, because we will repeal all the job-killing measures in the Employment Rights Act 2025. I beg to move.