L

Lord Jamieson (Con)

Speaking in the House of Lords on 22 October 2026

Debate

Sitting Times of the House

Contribution

My Lords, I echo many of the comments that other noble Lords have made. I, too, thank the Senior Deputy Speaker for this debate and the way in which he introduced it. The key question for me is: what is the problem we are trying to solve, and do the benefits outweigh the disadvantages? A number of noble Lords have spoken about why they believe that there are significantly more disadvantages than advantages. I thank the noble Lord, Lord Stoneham, because it is good to have an advocate to explain why he believes that there are positives to this proposal. He introduced the issue of scrutiny; I would like to come back to that later because it is an important point, although I disagree with him on it. In the consultation, at least, the key point is that this is about enabling noble Lords to return home at a reasonable hour and participate in family life. I echo the opinion of many other noble Lords that, quite frankly, the difference between 8.30 pm and 10 pm to family life, such as putting your children to bed and so on, is pretty small and would not have a dramatic impact; it is similar if you wanted to go out of an evening. So I am not sure that that is really the case—albeit there may be one or two people who live around the corner who would see a significant benefit. The alternative question is on attendance and the quality of debate when we go long into the night. In my two and a half years here, I do not have the experience of many other noble Lords, but I have experienced finishing at one o’clock or two o’clock at night. I have to say, it was not particularly enjoyable. The noble Lord, Lord Stoneham, was right to say that there were only one or two people from each Bench there, but sitting late at night is not an issue of when we start the day; it is about the fact that we have too much poor-quality legislation. I am talking about not the principle of legislation but poor drafting and lots of late amendments coming in. In fact, we are about to debate the Representation of the People Bill. I am told that we are going to get more than 100 government amendments half way through Committee. That is not the right way to do proper scrutiny. If we could fix that, I am sure that we would have much better scrutiny and that it would have a much impact than starting an hour earlier. However, I see a lot of downsides in these proposals. A number of noble Lords have raised the fact that we are a very diverse House; we have a lot of expertise on very different issues. In fact, one of the most interesting debates I heard was on broccoli and Brussels sprouts. That sounds a very esoteric topic, but it was a brilliant debate, going through the whole farming gamut from fertilisers to planting, logistics change and whatever. The reason it was such a good debate is that we had a vast range of people with different niche expertise, and so you realised just what it takes to get a Brussels sprout on your Christmas dinner table and all the things that have to work. I am not so sure that we would have had that interesting debate in the other place. It is just an example of what we can do as scrutiny. I say, as a new Peer, that that is what I have seen because we do not have people with full-time parliamentary careers. They have careers outside this place and bring that knowledge to it. I worry that, if we move towards a full-time professional House, we will completely change the character of the House. That is the thing that most worries me about this. It is a move towards excluding other people who bring so much expertise to the House. My own experience from my only other role in life at the moment, as a councillor, is that one of the benefits of having Monday and Tuesday mornings is that I can stay in my patch, meet residents and attend meetings. If I have to be here an hour and a half earlier all of a sudden, that will be gone. The hour and a half extra I would get in the evening is not meaningful. An hour and a half on a morning is a full morning. When you are halfway through the night, an hour and a half is not a full evening. It will also impact those who commute. I live 90 minutes or so away from here, when the trains are running properly, which means that most days I can commute and go back. When I know I am going to be late, until 10 pm or whatever, I book a hotel. I am sure there are many like me; there are others who, because they live in Scotland or wherever, will stay here all week. What are they supposed to do with that extra hour in the evening? That full morning is much more useful. People have mentioned the collegiate issue of dinner. In every organisation where I have worked, the best work, where you solve the problems and discuss in depth, is done outside the formal meetings—in the Chamber or whatever. It is over dinner or the water- cooler moments. Those are really important. I have had so many incredibly helpful conversations with world-renowned experts down in the canteen, on the Long Table or in the coffee room. The loss of those would be huge because that is brought to the Chamber. In fact, in many instances a problem is solved and is not even brought to the Chamber, so I really care about that for the operation of the House. Oher noble Lords have raised the issue of how committees will work, so I will not go on to it or talk about other meetings, such as the group meetings. When we want to meet with outside parties, meeting in and around lunchtime works incredibly well. I am not so confident of having so many takers to meet in and around 8 pm or 9 pm. Again, that is a loss of the opportunity to engage with outside parties. As others have said, I fear that 8.30 pm will not be seen as a hard stop; it will be a soft stop. It is a lot easier to just nibble away at, whereas at 10 pm, as others have said, people start voting with their feet. Others have raised the issue of staff and facilities and so on, so I will not do so, but I want to get on to the point of scrutiny. Yes, the number of people in the Chamber is an important factor in scrutiny. But even more important is the quality of debate, the diversity of opinions that are there and the expertise of the people involved. If you start excluding people who are not willing to be here because they have other careers or are involved in other organisations, we will weaken our debates. I have been here at 10 pm or even 11 pm with significant numbers of people because it was an important debate and they had real value to add. Yes, I have also been here when there have been only a few people here because, frankly, we were going through the motions—the debate had already happened on the key issues. That diversity of opinion and expertise is absolutely critical, and we cannot lose that from this House. It is something we add in the parliamentary process that does not happen in the other place. I am puzzled. I can see many downsides to this proposal, but little upside. We should not seek change for change’s sake. If the concern is really that we have too many Sittings very late at night, would it not be better to examine why this is the case, rather than facilitating the problem by, in effect, extending the hours of this House?

More from Lord Jamieson (Con)

Other recent Hansard contributions by the same speaker.

About Hansard

Hansard is the official verbatim record of proceedings in the UK Parliament. Every word spoken in the Commons and Lords is recorded and published — this page is a single contribution from that record.