Contribution
My Lords, I congratulate all those who have made their maiden speeches today and I look forward to the maiden speech of the noble Baroness, Lady Kitching of Penistone, who is a fellow councillor.
If we are to have growth, we need to build more homes and the infrastructure that this country needs, yet the OBR reduced its forecast for housebuilding by 190,000. This Government are on track to deliver fewer than the 1 million homes delivered by the previous Conservative Government, and the latest growth statistics show that private housebuilding is down by 4.7%. It is not only an economic failure but a moral failure. There is a housing crisis in England. Our new Prime Minister has said he wants to end rough sleeping, yet 136,000 households are living in temporary accommodation, including 177,000 children, which is up 5% a year.
The OBR report identifies that the cumulative impact of regulatory and fiscal changes outside the planning system have increased the cost, complexity and timescales associated with residential development. With mortgage rates up, housebuilding is simply unviable at a price that people can afford to pay in many parts of the country, which is why we have seen a decline from 182,000 new homes in England in 2022 to 125,000 last year. In London, it is particularly bad, with planning applications down 96% in the last 10 years, and only 754 homes applying for planning permission in the last two months.
The recent report from the CPS estimates that 57% of the cost of building a two-bedroom apartment in Camden is derived from government and mayoral levies and regulations; that is £442,000 out of £775,000. That is a huge burden, which is ultimately paid for by buyers. While it is better outside of London, with fewer mayoral impositions, it is still £224,000 out of £535,000, to given an example from Chelmsford.
London has affordable housing, stamp duty, CIL, corporation tax, developer tax, mayoral CIL, the building safety levy, Section 106, landfill tax, dual aspect, second staircase, the future homes standard, balconies, carbon offset and planning, and that is before we consider environmental costs, nutrient neutrality, biodiversity net gains, the jobs tax and so on. Does the mayor really need to mandate balconies and dual aspects? Surely a buyer can see these for himself or herself, and make their own decision on whether they represent good value.
The private rental market is also suffering. The OBR notes that the increase in property income tax rates and previous measures collectively risk leading to a steady rise in rents. Then there is the impact of the Renters’ Rights Act. Rightmove recently reported a 9% drop in homes available to rent in London, compared with a 6% increase in demand. Despite the much-vaunted affordable homes programme, which the Minister again highlighted, we are also seeing a decline in the building of affordable homes. As we raised during the passage of the Social Housing Bill, curtailing right to buy will see thousands fewer council homes built as there are no proceeds to reinvest.
With the Government’s housing policy failing, what action will they take to get building in our cities and address the huge government and mayoral-imposed costs? How many new social homes will be completed and occupied in this Parliament as a result of the £40 billion social housing programme? What will the Government do to encourage and stimulate the private rental market so that those who wish to rent have the availability that they need? This is a sorry tale. It needs to see confusing and inconsistent regulation and levies reduced, while safety standards are maintained, and it needs simpler taxes. There is a solution, as proposed by my honourable friend in the other place: a £50,000 reduction in the burden of regulation, combined with a single infrastructure levy.