Contribution
My Lords, I congratulate my noble friends Lady Ussher and Lord Neri on their excellent maiden speeches, and also the noble Baroness, Lady Aglionby, and I look forward to hearing shortly from the noble Baroness, Lady Kitching.
I welcome the fact that the Budget provided targeted help to households facing continuing cost of living pressures. The household energy payment, the abolition of gas standing charges and the extension of the fuel duty freeze will make a real difference to millions of families. In opening the debate, my noble friend Lord Pitt-Watson mentioned that there would be a saving of between £160 and £230 annually on energy bills, depending on family circumstances. These are targeted measures that address everyday concerns, but nobody would suggest that they are anything other than short-term measures.
On the flip side of the coin, tax rates on property and savings income will rise from next April, but 84% of taxpayers are unaffected and half the anticipated revenue will come from the top 10% of households. That, again, is thoughtfully targeted.
The Chancellor announced support for the high street and local communities. Retailers, hospitality businesses, pubs and leisure venues are important employers as well as important community social assets. The enhanced business rates relief will help preserve those jobs, although there is a need for investment to support the revival of town centres, too many of which—as many noble Lords will know—are now in a rather sorry state.
With Labour in Government since 2024, the economy has seen meaningful growth. The noble Lord, Lord O’Neill, pointed to growth of 1.9% up to the third quarter of this year, which, as he said, is considerably higher than the OBR had forecast. GDP is 2.5% higher than it was at the start of this Parliament and the Government will have £15 billion of headroom in the year 2029-2030 and £22 billion in 2030-2031, again according to the OBR. We can only hope that that also turns out to be an underestimate.
The Budget recognised that fiscal discipline matters and the Chancellor did of course remain within the manifesto red lines. That is something I personally regret; I believe that this was an occasion for a new Prime Minister and a new Chancellor to be bolder. I also believe that their predecessors should have been bold in this regard, because of a truism coined by my personal, political and economic hero, John Maynard Keynes, the most influential macroeconomist of the last century. Indeed, he is widely accepted as the father of macroeconomics.
I was delighted to hear my noble friend Lady Ussher declare “I am Keynesian”, although she did say it as if it was something of a revelation. I would like to think that would be a description that fits all on these Benches, but perhaps I am a little out of date. In her powerful maiden speech, it was heartening to hear my colleague, with her vast experience and influence, pinning her colours firmly to the Keynes mast, because it was he who said: when the facts change, I change my opinion. That was the case, I would argue, within six months of the general election, when the state of the economy had been properly evaluated.
The economic facts that existed—or were thought to have existed—when Labour framed the manifesto and came to power were quickly shown to be something else entirely. On that basis, I think a change of opinion was appropriate and could have been defended, allowing for greater borrowing in order to invest. That has not happened, but, at the midpoint of this Parliament, there is still much to build on, and the eagerly awaited Milburn report, the 10-year plan and the spending review will present ample opportunities for that.
I was greatly encouraged to hear the Chancellor announcing a road map for fiscal devolution. From next year, 20% of business rates revenues will go to mayors, and from 2028, an unspecified share of income tax receipts will go to mayors. By the end of the decade, 100% of business rates revenues will be retained locally. My noble friend Lord Pitt-Watson referred to the fact that the Budget will facilitate 10 more areas having mayors or becoming strategic authorities, which very much fits the Prime Minister’s agenda, but the elephant in the room is what happens to the remaining 10% of areas. They face being placed in a kind of no-man’s land. I hope that my noble friend will be able to say what plans the Government have to address that anomaly.
Many noble Lords have mentioned the Milburn report, which is expected to be published next week. The acquisition of skills will be central to that, and the Budget included some practical, welcome steps towards revitalising the skills landscape. Expanding mayoral apprenticeship powers, enforcing training in public procurement, re-entering Erasmus+, restoring the union learning fund and funding specialised technical academies are all significant measures.
I find all the Budget measures that I have touched on not just encouraging but exciting. If they are meaningfully developed, I believe it is more than possible that many people will have begun to see positive changes in their lives by the time we ask for their support for the next stage of the 10-year plan.