Contribution
My Lords, I will focus on two points: the NEETs crisis and the essential role of businesses and entrepreneurs in addressing the crisis. The NEETs crisis—the almost 1 million young people not in education, employment or training—was conspicuous by its absence from the Budget, despite the Prime Minister’s welcome acknowledgement that it is an
��economic catastrophe and moral failure”.
We have the publication of Alan Milburn’s review into young people and work to look forward to next week, as my noble friend Lord Balfe referred to in his speech, but, having hoped the review would be published before the Budget, with key measures implemented in the Budget, I want to underscore the fact that this delay will have human consequences and urge the Government to act on the review at pace. In June, the noble Lord, Lord Wilson of Sedgefield, told your Lordships’ House that the report would be out
“some time in September or October”.—[Official Report, 4/6/26; col. 986.]
The media were briefed that it would be published ahead of the Budget to allow speedy implementation.
Having spoken to many young people about the difficulty they are having in finding work, I was disappointed that the Budget did not include any measures of substance to address the NEETs crisis, even if the publication of the full review needed to be delayed. We will now have a further six or 12 months of delay until Alan Milburn’s recommendations for the Treasury are actioned in either the Spring Statement or next year’s Budget.
The million NEETs are a cohort of people who have spent much of their lives waiting. They put their lives on hold for two years during the Covid pandemic. Now they are facing a potential two-year delay from the commissioning of the Milburn review until its implementation. And this delay is not costless. It has real impact on young people’s lives. Alan Milburn’s interim report found that two-thirds of young people who are NEET for less than a year return to education, employment or training the following year. One-third—a very significant number—do not. For those who are unfortunate enough to be NEET for over a year, just 25% stop being workless. That means 75% continue being workless. So the delay in announcing and implementing the review’s recommendations could be catastrophic for people’s lives.
With the review being published next week, I am sure the Minister will already be familiar with its contents. I am not expecting him to reveal the details in his response today, but can he share with us whether the Treasury is looking to implement them in the Spring Statement or whether we will have to wait until next year’s Budget for them to be actioned?
Putting the Milburn review to one side, I turn to the impact of the wider business environment on the employment prospects of young people. At the end of every journey from welfare to work is a job either being provided directly by a business or paid for by the taxes generated by businesses. High energy costs, rising employment costs and an expanding regulatory burden are all making it more difficult for businesses to create jobs. This shows up in the unemployment rate. Rewinding to the 2024 Budget, the OBR’s forecast for the unemployment rate in 2026 was 4%. The same thing in this year’s OBR forecast is 5%. Current unemployment this year is therefore set to be 25% higher than forecast in Rachel Reeves’s first Budget in 2024. This can be reversed only by encouraging and incentivising entrepreneurs to work hard and invest to create jobs for young NEETs and other jobseekers.
The Chancellor promised a Budget for “bloody-minded entrepreneurs”: what we got was thin gruel. The new flagship proposal in the Budget to support entrepreneurs was founders’ relief, but the bar for founders to qualify is hugely restrictive as it stands. I find it astonishing, for example, that DeepMind would not have qualified when it was sold to Google. At the other end of the spectrum, the attack on sole traders will have a devastating effect on those beginning their entrepreneurial journey, and the halving of the business asset disposal relief lifetime limit from £1 million to £500,000 will disincentivise people from starting their entrepreneurial journey. We should always remember that incentives matter. If you tax the risk takers, you lose the job makers, and we need more job makers to help the NEETs.
Some have described this as the “Do no harm” Budget, but inaction makes life no better for the 1 million young people still waiting. I hope they are not kept waiting much longer. It is time for action because, to quote the Prime Minister, inaction on the NEETs crisis is an
“economic catastrophe and moral failure”.