Contribution
My Lords, I rise a little warily as speaker 38 of 57. I suspect parliamentlive.tv’s viewing figures may not trouble the scorers for a six-hour debate on a Budget of little content that seeks to do as little harm as possible, admittedly having learned some of the lessons from the two previous Budgets. Indeed, the markets barely reacted. I will give some credit to the Chancellor for not disturbing our recent GDP growth momentum; today’s third-quarter figures are encouraging and underscore the need for an AI economic strategy.
I will focus on SMEs and the bloody-minded entrepreneurs, but first I will make some brief comments on our public finances. I will follow up on the comments from my noble friend Lady Wheatcroft about the term “breathing space”. To me, this is the act of tinkering at the margins while another year slips by without us addressing the pressing economic issues of our time: debt, deficits, borrowing and a tax burden lurching towards 40% of our GDP. Our interest bill has climbed from £40 billion to £120 billion per annum in the last five years alone, and the OBR tells us that this will structurally settle at between £160 billion and £190 billion in the 2030s—and remember that the OBR has a history of optimism bias.
From debt and deficits, let us turn to three other “D” words: defence, demography and dependency. We have pledged to increase defence spending by some 40%, and it is proving politically impossible to reduce our health, pension and welfare spending, given our ageing and increasingly unhealthy society. That brings me to the final “D” word: devolution. I thought that devolution was the central plank of the Prime Minister’s strategy for growth, but the Budget announcements were small fry: a £1.5 billion borrowing facility and £285 million for good growth funding next year, presumably to be spread to every postcode. Like the noble Lord, Lord Bridges, with all these “D” words, I detect a distinct lack of urgency.
I shall focus on our bloody-minded entrepreneurs. I declare that I was one once, my son is one now, and I work with a range of start-ups and scale-ups, ranging from online platforms to canine matchmaking and community pubs. If we are to turn the dial from 1% to 1.5% growth in GDP to that mission-critical 2.5%, we must nurture and incentivise our small and medium-sized scale-ups that have a vital impact on economic growth. This group has suffered a bloody period: huge increases in employer NICs, outsized minimum wage hikes, restrictive employment practices and soaring energy bills and business rates. This Budget spared them further punishment, but almost nothing has been done to make employment more affordable or to deal with energy bills. While the Minister has trumpeted the fact that business rates relief is going to apply to 70,000 businesses in the high street, what is happening to the other 400,000?
The Chancellor has signalled the return of capital gains tax founders’ relief, which I very much welcome. However, as the noble Lord, Lord Elliott, said, on reading the small print one discovers that founders qualify only if they have delivered three consecutive years of 25% growth in both revenue, which must exceed £10 million, and headcount. That will exclude the vast majority of deserving founders, including those who, despite these headwinds, have created scores or indeed hundreds of valuable new jobs at a steady and sustainable rate over many years. One entrepreneur texted me this morning: “It’s like being asked to reach for the stars after two years of knee-capping”. He points out that the 50% reduction in business asset disposal relief looks set to hit a much larger group of entrepreneurs. I would very much welcome the Minister’s comments on these important measures, because the devil is very much in the detail.
This Budget is an improvement on its predecessors and has taken care not to inflict more damage on SMEs, but tough decisions have been delayed yet again and we still await a strategy for enterprise and economic growth.