Contribution
My Lords, I, too, thank the Senior Deputy Speaker for scheduling this debate and introducing it so well. It is my honour to follow so many noble Lords’ excellent speeches; I am going to repeat some of them, I am afraid, because so many good points were made.
I, too, see no compelling reasons to change our sitting hours. Our long-established arrangements serve this House well. What problem are we trying to solve? Would these changes create more difficulties than they resolve? I recognise that our present hours do not suit everybody, but any change must bring clear benefits to the House as a whole. These proposed changes would force Members to choose between attending committee meetings and taking part in Chamber business, making it much harder to fulfil both parliamentary responsibilities.
These changes would also leave us less time in the morning to prepare; I really need those hours in the morning. Preparing Questions, speeches and amendments requires research, thought and consultation. Otherwise, we cannot prepare ourselves properly. Squeezing it into a shorter morning will not improve our scrutiny.
Colleagues travelling from outside London would be particularly disadvantaged, as many speakers before me have noted. They already face long journeys, and the uncertainty of delayed or cancelled trains affects them. Earlier sittings would mean leaving home even earlier or travelling the night before, increasing accommodation costs for the taxpayer. And what would we gain? As many noble Lords have mentioned, an earlier start does not guarantee an earlier finish. The noble Lord, Lord Stoneham, mentioned 8.30 pm instead of 10 pm being meaningful but, as many noble Lords have mentioned, unless it is 6 pm instead of 10 pm, it is not very meaningful—an hour and a half at that time of the evening, when we cannot do anything else, is not meaningful. Many colleagues could still be unable to get home in the evening. Unless we also control the volume of business, we risk lengthening the parliamentary day, with greater demands on Members and staff alike.
The Prime Minister has promised
“the biggest rebalancing of power our country has ever seen”,
yet these proposed changes risk pulling this House in precisely the opposite direction by making more London-centric. Personally, I do not have a dog in this fight, because I live three stops away from Parliament, but we need colleagues who live and work across the country. We need the knowledge and practical experience of Peers from the worlds of business, medicine, law, education and science. We will lose those things. Earlier sittings would make those professional commitments harder to maintain, and we would be poorer for losing that experience, as many noble Lords before me have mentioned.
Working lunches and early-evening engagements matter, too. They give us the opportunity to hear directly from experts, charities and the people who are affected by our decisions. These meetings help us do our work properly.
Nor do I see how earlier hours would help families. Colleagues with young children would have to leave home earlier and would still arrive back after bedtime. Where is the benefit for them?
We also need to consider our doorkeepers. Many of them commute into London, and their concerns deserve our attention. We depend on them every day; their working lives matter, too. As we have said before, we have not heard their position on the changing of times.
I care about the character of this House. We should not become a House of full-time professional politicians. Our strength lies in the knowledge we bring from various professions, communities and wider life experience. Our arrangements enable Members to continue their professional work while contributing to the work of this House. The role of this House is to scrutinise legislation, draw on the widest possible experience and enable colleagues from across the country to participate. I see no convincing case that changing our sitting hours to those proposed would help us achieve any of those aims. I therefore support our present arrangements.