Contribution
My Lords, I am a new boy, so I feel myself under the lash of my noble friend Lord Blencathra in speaking to this debate. But, having spent less than three years here so far—and probably having not many more than that to go if the age restrictions come into operation—I do not have any big fish to fry. So I can be somewhat objective in looking at this and just use my experience from elsewhere to see whether it is a good idea. All the same, I am hesitant to speak on this, especially as so many noble Lords have said so many good things about it. I hope I can add one or two small points.
I had difficulty figuring out the system of the Lords. It is complicated. The Lords do a huge amount of different things and you have to work hard to understand the system and try to make yourself effective in it. But having figured it out, I have now adapted my lifestyle to the way in which the House works, and I find myself perhaps slightly more effective than I was when I first arrived. Some relatively small changes are now being offered to us, so we have to consider them; that is our situation. The complication is that we debated them already, in 2022. We seem to be adopting the Irish approach to referenda: if you do not vote the right way the first time, we will get you to vote again until you do.
These are not huge changes. Are they important enough to oppose? I have thought about that quite hard, and I think that, yes, they should be, because they worsen things rather than better them, and they constitute a direction of travel that should be stopped right now, just as it was in 2022.
Why do I say that? Well, in former times—perhaps I am one of the few here today to have been there to remember it, given my ancient position—age and outside experience were highly valued attributes in both Houses of this Parliament. It is probably artificial nostalgia to look back to those times and lament their greatness compared with now, but there were certainly some great politicians in those times, most of whom had age and widespread experience from outside these Houses. We have now taken a step to professionalise the other House.
There is much lamenting, which I do not have to rehearse too lengthily, over what that greatly eloquent person, Dominic Cummings, called “PPE bluffers” coming straight out of university, going into some kind of spad work, eventually getting a seat at a fairly early age and staying as professional politicians all of their life. I am sorry if I am boring noble Lords on the other side. That professionalisation has not been for the good. I should not criticise the other House, so can say only what others have criticised its Members for: they are criticised for having very little non-political experience, for doing very little scrutiny and for seeing themselves as professional politicians who believe that for every problem there ought to be a law—“By the way, we know best”—so that laws proliferate and the country is regulated more and more. They are criticised for having form and not substance, and for doing slipshod work. That has been the outcome, according to these critics, of the professionalisation of the other House. Now we have a repeated attempt to do the same for the House of Lords and to move in that direction.
The House of Lords is a part-time House for a reason, and its effectiveness as a revising Chamber is, I argue, unequalled around the world. As we have heard, people complain that there are about 800 Peers, but the vast number of them come in only when their experience is called upon—as other noble Lords have said—and they are an expense to the House of Lords only when they come in. Of those 800 part-time Peers, many have a hinterland, which means that we can call on a plethora of knowledge from them, and that makes us effective as a revising Chamber. It means knowledge of what really works in the real world, not of what works in theory in law. Anything that makes it more difficult to operate that general hinterland held by those Peers is bad for the effectiveness of this House. A hinterland needs access to the outside world to keep going. That access has to take place between 9 am and 5 pm, because that is when the rest of the world operates, so any hour that we take away from noble Peers’ access to the outside world between 9 am to 5 pm cuts off their access to reality.
Every generation wants change. By no means should every change be resisted, but this change should be. Change for change’s sake is no benefit. As my noble friend Lord Moylan pointed out, we have not really heard any strong arguments on the benefits. As my noble friend Lord Redwood and other noble Lords have pointed out, there are multiple disbenefits. The change to the other House made it worse. Why should we want to have similar changes here, however small?
Like any successful long-standing institution, the House of Lords has developed its way of working over many years—in fact, in our case, over many centuries. It has many odd and unique features, each of which has a reason, including the ones we are debating here today. That is why each is jealously guarded. Together, they make up an institution that is now, with the decline in scrutiny in the other House, more important than ever. We should stay as we are.