L

Lord Moynihan of Chelsea (Con)

Speaking in the House of Lords on 14 October 2026

Debate

Trade Unions (Right to Access Workplaces) Regulations 2026

Contribution

My Lords, some elements of these regulations are to a degree reasonable. The employer’s response period, which was originally proposed as being one week, is now, following our representations, three weeks, and access agreements are now capped at two years. I acknowledge those things. I also take comfort from the fact that, looking at the speakers’ list, not a single Labour Back-Bencher opposes my noble friend’s amendment. However, none of this changes the fact that the Act squats here as a major destroyer of growth, a gift from the former Prime Minister to the new one helping to fulfil his expressed desire to take our economy back to that decade of strife, the 1970s. Non-unionised companies can thrive, while unionised ones tend to go to the wall. Because of that, nine out of 10 private sector employees are not union members. For most private businesses, this will be their first dealing with unions in decades. In a fiercely competitive global market, companies must be flexible and agile. Unionisation slows decisions, blocks rapid changes of direction and adds red tape. Companies want harmony and co-operation with their workforce, as my noble friend Lord Balfe said, so balanced guidelines are crucial. If they are unbalanced in favour of the union, the company must continually cave in to the union to avoid sanction from this Central Arbitration Committee. There will be onerous weekly union meetings and the potential for CAC complaints if managers even ask workers what took place. With these guidelines, your Lordships will be amazed at how many companies will stop growing at 20 workers, to the direct detriment of the economy. The CAC is being given enormous latitude, with nebulous guidance permitting arbitrary decisions. Its three-person panels comprise a lawyer or academic in the chair, a member from the trade union side and a so-called employer member drawn, in the Government’s recruitment literature, mainly from HR directors and employment relations leaders—not from people who have built businesses. To an HR leader, a union is a normal part of the corporate landscape, so the introduction of a union will seem “manageable”, in the guidelines’ words. However, to an entrepreneur, the person on whom our country’s growth depends, a union is an obstacle to succeeding in a highly competitive world. So I ask the Minister for assurances that, in the promised spring consultation, the Government will propose changes in three areas. First, will they lower the penalties? After consultation, in an extraordinary decision, the Government raised the maximum fine from £150,000 to £500,000. Who consulted them to do that? Fines should not be so large that they drive a company into financial distress or derail its growth, but for many businesses even £75,000 will do that. Secondly, will they protect working time? The weekly visit presumption should go. I saw noble Lords on the Labour Benches nodding when my noble friend Lord Balfe said that a weekly visit was unnecessary and would not be wanted, so why is it here? How can a business with 21 workers cope with weekly visits? Meetings should default to breaks or the ends of shifts. Where they fall in paid time, they should be limited to 30 or, at best, 45 minutes. Thirdly, will they reform the digital access guidelines? Companies should have a right of reply through the same channel and should not be obliged to disseminate unlawful material, which the guidelines oblige them to do now. Beyond meetings, union communications through company channels should also be limited to one a week. Companies must be free to log email delivery and link activity for security purposes, with the monitoring ban agreed to mean only scrutiny aimed at identifying workers’ engagement with union material. Finally, every worker, member or not, should be allowed to unsubscribe. Should the Government lose the next election, much of this will matter less, apart from in the meantime further dramatic losses in economic growth, because an incoming Conservative Government will largely repeal this damaging Act. Until then, I ask the Government: please limit the damage by improving these far too union-friendly guidelines.

More from Lord Moynihan of Chelsea (Con)

Other recent Hansard contributions by the same speaker.

About Hansard

Hansard is the official verbatim record of proceedings in the UK Parliament. Every word spoken in the Commons and Lords is recorded and published — this page is a single contribution from that record.