Contribution
My Lords, I speak as a member of the European Affairs Committee. After we left the European Union, Gibraltar lived on temporary arrangements and, as we have heard, thousands cross from Spain every day to work in Gibraltar. The Chief Minister told our committee that, under the EU’s new entry/exit system, each crossing could have taken 15 to 30 seconds through only two or three lanes. The agreement puts a stop to that and protects the operational autonomy of our military facilities. It was supported unanimously by the Gibraltar Parliament. Many Gibraltarians have family in Spain and, as many in this debate have emphasised, Gibraltar’s economy depends on an effectively functioning frontier. This is equally important, of course, to the Spanish who work in Gibraltar.
Gibraltarians voted by 96%, as we have heard several times, to remain in the European Union, but they also want to remain British Gibraltarians. Offered shared sovereignty with Spain, 17,900 voted against and 187 in favour. The Chief Minister told our committee that the key issue has always been that
“the exclusively British sovereignty of Gibraltar should not be compromised by one iota”.
The noble Lord, Lord Hannay, just told us that he believes that no sovereignty had been conceded, and my noble friend Lord Tugendhat agreed with him. I devote this speech to the key issue of whether British sovereignty is or is not diminished by this agreement.
The Government assert that our sovereignty is untouched. As regards legal title, they are correct, but sovereignty is not just about legal title: it is the power to make your own laws, to set your own taxes, tariffs and trade policy, to decide who may enter your territory, and whether and when to leave an arrangement that no longer serves you.
First, on laws, in the areas the agreement covers, Gibraltar must, unless it wishes the agreement to terminate, align its law with the EU’s not only as it stands today but as it is changed in future, with no vote on how these laws will change. I asked in committee whether Gibraltar would be bound by the product aspects of the AI Act, the product liability directive and the cyber resilience Act. The Chief Minister responded that this was “a murky, grey area”. In other words, it is difficult to know. I have written to the Government, again asking this question, and I know that they are working on a reply.
Secondly, on taxes, Gibraltar’s import duties have been abolished, replaced by a transaction tax whose rate may not fall below the lowest VAT rate in the EU. A joint body with Spain may recommend higher rates where Gibraltar’s are thought to distort trade with Spain. From April 2029, Gibraltar’s excise duty on fuel must be within 6% of Spain’s rates. Therefore, on taxes, sovereignty over a British territory has been lost.
Thirdly, I refer to trade. On Gibraltar’s customs union with the EU affecting British sovereignty, the Minister responded to me that the agreement
“does not touch on sovereignty at all”.
He said, correctly, that Gibraltar was not joining “the” EU customs union but had “a bespoke customs union”. He said that for me to suggest otherwise was “a misrepresentation”. I agree that the two are different, but pointing that out says nothing about whether there has been any loss in sovereignty. It had taken earlier questioning from me for the Minister’s official to confirm that Gibraltar will now be allowed to join the CPTPP only for services, not goods,
“because they are in a customs union with the EU”.
Still not addressing my point about sovereignty, the Minister pointed out that it was
“a customs union that they have chosen to go into”.
But the effect is still that, for those goods, Gibraltar now follows EU rules and EU tariffs.
The Minister’s official and the Chief Minister both said, in effect, that this does not matter much, because Gibraltar exports almost no goods. But they were speaking about manufacturing and exports, when the real effect, as pointed out by my noble friend Lord Redwood, is on imports. On the Government’s own figures, Gibraltar imported some £840 million of goods last year, about a quarter of its GDP. About £360 million of that—43%—came from the United Kingdom.
Under the agreement, goods may now be placed on the Gibraltar market only if they meet EU rules, while Gibraltar’s own government guidance says that goods must enter by land. Foods containing the colouring E171 permitted in Great Britain but banned in the EU; drinks with caps not tethered to the bottle; more importantly, phones and headphones without a USB-C port and goods without the CE mark: each can be sold in Britain, but it appears that none can now be sold in Gibraltar. Goods that Britain itself imports from non-EU countries will incur the EU’s tariff in Gibraltar, which tends to be higher than ours—again, increasing what Gibraltarian consumers will have to pay.
If British goods must meet EU rules, travel through Spain and be cleared at EU customs posts, the natural supplier becomes the Spanish wholesaler a few miles away. It will be surprising if, within a few years, Britain was still Gibraltar’s main supplier of everyday goods. On trade, I think we can agree that the UK has lost not just sovereignty but a market.
Fourthly, on entry, Spanish officials, as we have heard, now carry out Schengen checks at Gibraltar’s own port and airport. The then Minister, Stephen Doughty, compared this to St Pancras, but at St Pancras the arrangement is reciprocal: British officers check passengers in France. Would the Minister care to say where in Spain British officers will be doing the same? When my noble friend Lord Jackson of Peterborough put it to the Minister that Spain can now object to Gibraltar residence permits, it was not specifically rebutted, although others in this debate believe we can be reassured on that point. It remains to me unclear. Gibraltar’s airport, as we have heard, is to be run as a joint venture. All in all, on entry, we have clearly lost sovereignty.
Fifthly, on exit, the UK, except in the most exceptional circumstances and through the concordat, binds itself not to terminate the agreement unless, as we have heard, that is supported by Gibraltar’s Parliament or people. The Minister told us that the concordat does not have any legal standing so, as my noble friend Lord Frost pointed out, it constrains us but not the other side. Spain, which is not a party, has more room. After the four-year review, a Spanish request would commit the EU to take steps towards terminating the agreement—and we have heard about the upcoming elections in Spain, so we know that this is not set in stone.
Our chair asked whether that termination right is one-off or recurring. The Minister’s official was “fairly certain” that it was one-off, and undertook to confirm. However, the Minister’s letter to our chairman did not do so. Possibly the Government do not know—but at least once for sure, and possibly thereafter, the EU would be committed to act on a Spanish request to terminate. If Gibraltar declines a new EU law, the agreement terminates, unless the co-operation council agrees an alternative. The EU side again requires Spain’s consent. We have constrained ourselves, Spain has not and, on exit, therefore, our sovereignty is clearly compromised.
That is an impressive list of compromises of sovereignty. Gibraltar is now bound more closely to the EU and Spain than to us, with arrangements for the future that will draw it ever further in the direction of the EU. How do the current Government view British sovereignty over our 14 overseas territories, which give our country a presence at the gateway to the Mediterranean, in the South Atlantic, in the Indian Ocean and elsewhere? These are territories that, if populated, are home to British peoples.
In May 2025, the Government signed a treaty recognising Mauritian sovereignty over the whole Chagos Archipelago, including Diego Garcia, while agreeing to pay some £10 billion in cash over time—£3.4 billion in net present value. That treaty has, thank goodness, stalled and is not yet in force, but it was signed. Argentina has called again for talks on the Falklands, and the Americans say that they may review their position. In one overseas territory, we have agreed to give sovereignty away completely. In a second, we have agreed that a neighbour’s rules will govern its goods and that a neighbour’s consent will be needed to keep the arrangement working. In a third, our position is threatened. Countries that covet any of the remaining 11 territories are watching carefully.
I have put a series of questions on these points to the Minister in writing, too long to repeat here. I know that his officials are working on them, and I look forward to receiving answers to them. Nothing that I have said today is necessarily an argument against the choice that Gibraltar has made. Rather, it is an argument for honesty about what that choice involves for the UK and its sovereignty, and whether the outcome that is a good thing for British sovereignty. British sovereignty over Gibraltar is much less today than it was a year ago, with a worsening direction of travel. The Committee should be clear about that before this agreement is ratified.