L

Lord Bilimoria (CB)

Speaking in the House of Lords on 20 October 2026

Debate

EU, Euratom and UK Agreement on Gibraltar

Contribution

My Lords, on 10 September, I was proud to attend Gibraltar National Day, along with our Minister, the noble Lord, Lord Wood, and a parliamentary delegation. I was there to witness the most impressive speech by the Chief Minister, Fabian Picardo, who is here with us. It was his last national day—he has been Chief Minister for almost 15 years—and his speech focused on what I think came across as his crowning achievement in his tenure: the completion of the UK-EU agreement in respect of Gibraltar. I thank the noble and gallant Lord, Lord Stirrup, for initiating the debate and thank the noble Lord, Lord Barrow, for stepping into his shoes today. I first learned about Gibraltar from Field Marshal Sir John Chapple, who was one of my late father Lieutenant General Faridoon Bilimoria’s best friends. They met as Lieutenant Colonels when my father was posted to the UK. They both rose through their respected Armed Forces and both headed up the Gurkhas in the UK and India. John Chapple became Chief of the General Staff and my father, commander-in-chief of the central army in India. After Sir John retired, he was appointed Governor of Gibraltar. That is when I learned about Gibraltar from that great man. I am very lucky that the current Governor, Lieutenant General Sir Ben Bathurst, is a friend. I learned from him on the ground the role of a governor. It is not a ceremonial role; it is very much an important functional role of being a diplomat, a bridge between Gibraltar and the UK and commander-in-chief of Gibraltar. I saw first hand that it is a role that is respected by Gibraltarians. In the case of Sir Ben Bathurst, he has excelled in this and built phenomenal relations with the community. I commend him for that. He is supported by his tremendous wife, Kate. Gibraltar is a British Overseas Territory. It has always been special. It is a special location at the mouth of the Mediterranean. It is a strategic location and has been for centuries, as the noble Duke, the Duke of Wellington, very well knows. It is reassuring to know that this treaty does not affect in any way the position of Gibraltar when it comes to the UK and the presence of our Armed Forces—and therefore NATO—in Gibraltar. I am chair of the International Chamber of Commerce in the UK and the regional co-ordinator of the ICC in Europe, which covers 35 countries. Gibraltar officially comes under the UK as an overseas territory, but ICC presence is embedded within its chamber of commerce. The ICC is the biggest business organisation in the world, with 45 million businesses. It is well known that Gibraltar has a very strong legal presence; the Chief Minister is a lawyer, and the incoming Chief Minister is a lawyer. The ICC is the world’s number one dispute resolution court, headquartered in Paris; it is regarded as by far the best and the biggest in the world. However, the ICC is also the leading organisation in the world when it comes to trade. It has a seat at the WTO and observer status at the UN, the World Bank and the IMF. I was doing some research: in the Brexit debates that we had, I spoke about Gibraltar three times. In 2017, when we were talking about, “no deal … is better than a bad deal”, I said that, “Gibraltar has suddenly come up”.—[Official Report, 4/4/17; col. 1030.] Later on, I spoke about a “blind Brexit” and warned that, “Spain is already talking about having a veto over Gibraltar”.—[Official Report, 20/11/18; col. 219.] In 2019, in the debate on the withdrawal agreement and political declaration, I warned of a “blindfold Brexit” and said that, “the subject of Spain and Gibraltar has been brought up”.—[Official Report, 14/1/19; col. 42.] Gibraltar is an overseas territory and therefore left the European Union when we withdrew on 31 January 2020. Importantly, Gibraltar was not included in the scope of the TCA, which is why this agreement is so important. This treaty replaces the routine land border checks with relocated border controls at Gibraltar Airport—I take the point from the noble and learned Baroness, Lady Butler-Sloss, about queues, and I am sure they are being addressed—supported by co-operation, information sharing and targeted safeguards. On goods, the treaty substitutes frontier checks with a trading framework including goods, movements, customs and taxation. It allows trade to flow without permanent border infrastructure while ensuring that the integrity of both parties’ markets is maintained. On security and policing, the treaty introduces co-operation mechanisms that enable risks to be managed effectively without reliance on a land border, so there is a fluid land border between Gibraltar and Spain. It is important that people cleared at the airport are now able to travel freely between Gibraltar, Spain and the wider Schengen area and that—this point has not been stressed enough—UK military personnel entering Gibraltar will not be subject to Schengen checks. This will enable our facilities to continue their important operations without interference or interruption. The posting of UK military personnel to serve in Gibraltar with their families will not depend on Schengen border checks, as is the case now, and the UK will decide who will serve in Gibraltar. So much for sovereignty. Let us put Gibraltar into perspective. It has a population of just 38,000 people, compared with our total population of 70 million. Its GDP is £3 billion compared with our £3 trillion, but GDP per head in Gibraltar is £81,000 and our GDP per head is £43,000, so Gibraltar’s GDP is almost double ours. Inflation is roughly the same. There are seven registered Gibraltarians who are unemployed, compared to our unemployment of almost 4.9%. Our debt as a percentage of GDP is approaching 100%, but Gibraltar’s is 21%. Its corporation tax is 15% and ours is 25%. Here is the thing: Gibraltar runs a budget surplus. It does not cost the UK anything; it is an asset to the UK not only as a strategic defence location but economically. It is in no way a burden to the UK, in any sense of the word. It is a small, rich, UK-facing services economy whose labour, goods and visitors come through Spain. Output per head is nearly double the UK’s, and it has four sectors—gaming, shipping, insurance and financial services—much of which is with the UK. Gibraltar’s economy runs on the frontier and is dependent on this free flow of people. Residents of Spain hold 44% of all jobs and 55% of private sector jobs. Some 15,860 registered frontier workers cross daily. Daily visitors from Spain provide 73% of the £300 million of visitor spending. Gibraltar says that it buys about €1 billion from Spain and generates one-quarter of Campo de Gibraltar’s GDP. By the way, that area next door to Gibraltar has the highest unemployment rate of any Spanish city at 29%. When it comes to before and after Brexit, inside the EU Gibraltar’s financial firms could passport into EU markets outside the customs union and Schengen. As many noble Lords said, Gibraltar voted 95.9% to remain in the European Union. Passporting ended on 31 December 2020, and Gibraltar was left out of the trade and co-operation agreement. Five years of this disruptive informal arrangement could not have been of benefit to anybody. People are talking about flashpoints now, such as Spanish officers, the power of the airport and the 90-day or 180-day rule. Can the Minister provide some clarity on that? Dynamic alignment with the European Court of Justice and Spain’s termination lever after four years are issues that we need to look at. The Chief Minister said that no one cleared by Gibraltar has been refused entry by Spain to date. Could Can confirm that that is the case? Can he confirm that this treaty will be extended to cover services, as we have done with the Switzerland agreement, for example? It does not cover services at the moment. We have also heard that, other than in the most exceptional circumstances, the UK will not end the treaty unless three-quarters of Gibraltar’s Parliament or a majority in a referendum support that. On the cost of failure, David Lammy warned in June 2025 that a hard border would place pressure ultimately on the UK taxpayer to pick up the bill. With no agreement covering Gibraltar at the end of the transition, it lost its passporting rights. One example is Bet365, one of our successful companies, which had already moved many of its 500-strong Gibraltar operations to Malta in 2019, citing Brexit uncertainty. Martin Sandbu of the Financial Times argued in July that: “Gibraltar, like Northern Ireland, has been left inside the bloc the UK left”, and, “if it’s good for the Gibraltarians, why not for all UK citizens?” The UK Government ends up seeking closer alignment, and Prime Minister Andy Burnham is talking about plans for a softer Brexit—this is what has been suggested by the Financial Times—which applies to Northern Ireland, not Gibraltar. The Chief Minister replied that the treaty is in fact “a model” for the UK, in effect a common travel area with Schengen, with residents exempt from entry-exit systems, but no freedom of establishment for EU citizens —mobility without free movement. It is worth evangelising. The 1.2 kilometre fence has been removed, frontier workers can now move freely without any checks and 90% of arrivals go on to holiday in southern Spain. Freight dipped for a while and is now back up to 250 to 300 lorries. Where financial services are concerned, we have 37 general insurers, and 40% of UK insurance policies are written by Gibraltar insurers. This is important to our economy. Gibraltar supported the equivalent of 24% of Campo jobs, earning £102 million with a £65 million spend this year, so it is worth it for the Spanish as well. Let us look at the visitor numbers: there were 9.82 million arrivals in 2025. To put that into context, our tourism is 44 million for the whole of the UK, and we are one of the biggest recipients of tourism. This little place gets 9.82 million people—9.26 million by land, 368,000 by sea and 188,000 by air—and they spent £300 million, with day visitors from Spain spending £218 million of that. Trade with the UK is £5 billion in total. I co-chair the All-Party Parliamentary Group on India. The UK-India trade agreement was signed on 24 July 2025 and came into force—wait for this date—on 15 July 2026, the same day as this agreement. Its side letters on territorial extension commit only to discussions on extending the services provisions to the Crown dependencies. Gibraltar is not mentioned. Can the Minister clarify whether it can apply to Gibraltar and whether Gibraltar could join the CPTPP’s services chapter? We are now a full member of the CPTPP, but not for goods. Could the Minister clarify that? I conclude that the UK’s double lock is no transfer of sovereignty against Gibraltar’s freely and democratically expressed wishes and no sovereignty negotiations with which Gibraltar is not content. The freely expressed wishes of the people of Gibraltar are paramount. Gibraltar wants this deal. Gibraltar appreciates this deal. We are proud of Gibraltar. We are lucky to have Gibraltar as part of the United Kingdom.

More from Lord Bilimoria (CB)

Other recent Hansard contributions by the same speaker.

About Hansard

Hansard is the official verbatim record of proceedings in the UK Parliament. Every word spoken in the Commons and Lords is recorded and published — this page is a single contribution from that record.