L

Lord Purvis of Tweed (LD)

Speaking in the House of Lords on 20 October 2026

Debate

EU, Euratom and UK Agreement on Gibraltar

Contribution

My Lords, it is a pleasure to follow the noble Lord, and I associate myself with all his remarks and the questions that he raised. I, like others, thank the committee for its work in scrutinising the treaty, and thank the noble Lord, Lord Barrow, for opening the debate and deputising so well for the noble and gallant Lord, Lord Stirrup. I mean no disrespect to the noble and gallant Lord, Lord Stirrup, but I find it reassuring, given the fact that I when visit tricky places I am often met by a diplomat rather than a military person, so I am glad that the noble Lord, Lord Barrow, took on this role today. Like others, I also wish to thank the veritable who’s who, and who was who, in Gibraltar who have been with us today in the Moses Room and pay tribute to the ministerial team and the Administration of the Chief Minister. The partnership that he has with the Deputy Chief Minister Joseph Garcia has been a model of partnership working and has helped to build the consensus that we saw in the Parliament of Gibraltar. I also pay tribute to the many officials and the support that the Chief Minister referred to yesterday evening at the reception marking Gibraltar National Day here in London. I would like to put on record that Jonathan Scott, the head of mission for the Government of Gibraltar in London, and his predecessor Dominique Searle, have been a model of interacting with and briefing parliamentarians. I have often found that our Whitehall Government could perhaps learn lessons from the Government of Gibraltar in offering timely, effective and prescient briefings. That was the experience leading up to the negotiation and conclusion of the treaty, but we have also seen the hard work of the Government of Gibraltar on the treaty’s provisional application since 15 July. We know that this treaty will serve its intended purpose only if it is properly implemented, and that takes a lot of time, effort and co-ordination between officials here in the UK and in Gibraltar. Like other noble Lords in this debate, I have had the privilege of visiting Gibraltar both before and after the Brexit referendum. On my pre-referendum visit, it was outlined to me in clear terms what would be the likely implications for the economy, cross-border frontier working, care, education and tourism if the UK chose to leave the EU. On my post-referendum visit it was little consolation to learn that all that was warned of had happened. The committee’s report rightly stated that Gibraltar has had to balance, in effect, the dual choice about its sovereignty: a vote of 99% of Gibraltarians to stay British and a vote of 96% to stay in the European Union. For some speaking in the debate today, that has been a clear-cut issue, but I think it has been more complex. That is perhaps why it has taken a number of years to ameliorate the impact of the referendum. In fact, a decade on from the referendum and five years on from the exit agreement, we are now finally debating this treaty today, so the suggestion that this has all been rushed and forced on the people of Gibraltar is slightly wide of the mark. Before I continue, I wish to put on record my absolute agreement—I am sure they will be delighted to hear this—with the noble Lords, Lord Frost and Lord Jackson, that the CRaG process is not fit for purpose. They did not have votes in the Lords at the time, but they supported the previous Government who rejected my amendment to the Trade Act to have up and down votes on treaties and trade agreements. In fact, that amendment was passed by this House and rejected by the previous Conservative Governments. But I am sure that their party leadership has heard of their repentance—there is no better place than the Moses Room for noble Lords to repent. I am glad that they are now with me in wanting to remove the barricades to improvements to the CRaG process. There has been some debate today about whether this will undermine part of Brexit, or whether it is the final stage of it. Last week in the House of Commons, the leader of the Opposition, Kemi Badenoch, said that the Prime Minister “is not going to get a better deal””—[Official Report, Commons, 12/10/26; col. 26.] on Brexit. However, now that we are having to resolve this for Gibraltar, as well as the outstanding issues to do with the Falklands and the ongoing issues with the Windsor Framework and the Northern Ireland process, the reality is, of course, that it was a bad deal. Indeed, Gibraltar has had to work very hard to make adjustments to ameliorate some of the challenges that it created. The complications of the Brexit agreement in the Gibraltar context have to be added to the delicate diplomatic relationship with Spain. Sadly, Gibraltar has had direct experience of the economic and personal consequences of frontier disruption. Therefore, the priority has been to ensure timely, enforceable safeguards should there be a political dispute. Even though we may wish for it not to happen or for them not to be needed, they are essential mechanisms. I welcome the dispute resolution mechanisms in the treaty and the UK-Gibraltar concordat signed on 14 July, which adds a lock on termination, if needed, to protect the decision-making autonomy of the Parliament and the people of Gibraltar. This is essential; we all hope that it will not be needed, but nevertheless it has to be in place. The benefits accruing from this treaty are economic and social. Of course, the impact of Brexit was palpable, and this is where I disagree with the noble Lords, Lord Frost and Lord Redwood, in particular. I think that they have slightly misread the fact that Gibraltar was seeking to both correct the challenges of Brexit and make sure there was prosperity for the future. The comments of the noble Lord, Lord Redwood, seem to suggest that there was a huge differential between being part of the European Union customs union and not being part. The reality is that the EU-applied mean tariff around the world is 1.39%. The equivalent in the UK is 1.13%. There is a marginal difference between the tariff rates that the EU and the UK operate post Brexit. Post Brexit, the UK has trading relationships with 73 countries and the European Union with 70 partner countries. But the critical aspect is that the EU is the world’s largest single trade bloc, with 16% of world trade. I wish the UK were part of that trade bloc. I am rather envious of my friends in Gibraltar being part of it. Gibraltarian trade and services being part of that trade bloc is not a disadvantage but potentially an advantage, but it is up to the authorities in Gibraltar to make it work. The most important aspect that we have heard in the debate today, which I think got it wrong, was the indication that sovereignty meant the complete and utter control of all our services. But the reality for Gibraltar, as we have heard elsewhere in the debate, is that over 15,000 workers from Spain travel into Gibraltar daily. This is half the workforce. When it comes to health and care services, it is 3,000 workers a day--some 70% of workers. It is okay from the House of Lords to say that we think that Gibraltar has signed away sovereignty, but when 70% of your care sector operates across a frontier, you have to work with partners pragmatically and sensibly. That is exactly what the treaty is designed to do, and I am glad that the negotiations have been carried out so effectively. It does, however, mean that I have some questions for the Minister. Some lead directly on from those of the noble Lord, Lord Bilimoria, about the interaction we will have with any further UK agreements when it comes to services, because they will now, I presume, require Gibraltar chapters. If that is the case, I hope that, as with this agreement, the Government and Parliament of Gibraltar are included in any of the negotiations, and we establish a negotiation mandate which would then include them. We really want to avoid the absolute nonsense of the previous Government when they forgot to include the Falklands in the negotiation mandate on Brexit at all—so much for sovereignty there. When it comes to dispute resolution, I hope that the Minister might be able to say—in a situation we would not welcome but nevertheless where it may be necessary—how urgently these dispute resolution mechanisms can be applied in the event of disruption on the frontier. Have we made it clear diplomatically to our EU partners that the UK would not hesitate to act at speed if there was disruption? There is little point in having a dispute resolution mechanism that will take a considerable time given the scale of the daily crossings and the essential nature for the Gibraltar care and retail services of those workers crossing the frontier. Of course, we want good co-operation, and it is welcome that the co-operation council is established to oversee the agreement’s operation, co-chaired by a UK Minister and a member of the European Commission. But given that it can make binding decisions as well as non-binding recommendations and amend the agreement itself, can the Minister confirm that the Gibraltar authorities, Ministers and officials will form part of the UK delegation to the co-operation council? How will the co-operation council interact with Parliament? We have under the TCA the parliamentary relationship—what interaction will there be within the two Parliaments over this? I wish to pick up a point made well by the noble and learned Baroness, Lady Butler-Sloss, with regard to the issues that have arisen since provisional application. My understanding is that some Gibraltar residents have been wrongly registered on the EU entry and exit scheme since 15 July. What measures are being taken to ensure that Gibraltar residents are not delayed or refused entry while these records are corrected? I hope that this is a temporary mechanism and that it can be resolved very swiftly. Finally, the noble Lord, Lord Jackson, said that in his view this was the last loose end of Brexit being tied up—but we heard from the noble Lord, Lord Frost, that this now starts to unravel Brexit. I think that neither is right. We have to ensure that the worst elements of the Brexit agreement are reduced. Gibraltarians have had to find a pragmatic and practical solution to address a set of problems which they did not create or want. I commend their work, and we have in the UK Parliament and in the Government in Whitehall a duty to support them, not to second-guess them, and to work hard to ensure that the treaty and the concordat are implemented effectively.

More from Lord Purvis of Tweed (LD)

Other recent Hansard contributions by the same speaker.

About Hansard

Hansard is the official verbatim record of proceedings in the UK Parliament. Every word spoken in the Commons and Lords is recorded and published — this page is a single contribution from that record.