L

Lord Purvis of Tweed (LD)

Speaking in the House of Lords on 16 November 2026

Debate

Commonwealth Heads of Government Meeting

Contribution

My Lords, I agree with the noble Lord in paying tribute to Antigua and Barbuda for hosting the summit. That allows me to disagree with everything else he said in the remainder of his contribution. I feel that the Commonwealth remains a globally important network and offers a great deal for our country. It is also where we can play a much greater role in the future of our partner countries, particularly in trade, investment and development. The Commonwealth does not have to exist, but if it did not, we would be closer to a more polarised world, one where there are, increasingly, voices towards transactionalism, rather than one based on co-operation, understanding and mutual agreement. There are few organisations in the world with an equal say between nations of 1 billion people and those of 1 million people. The whole network, from town planners to parliamentarians, adds real value to its members. That is why we must at every opportunity state that the Commonwealth is a force for good. It is worth recording that at this latest CHOGM, the Prime Minister of India was not there; the President of South Africa was not there; Kenya was represented by the deputy president, Nigeria by an official and Pakistan by a high commissioner. There is a reality that, for some, we need to ensure that we re-embolden the very essence of what the Commonwealth is. The leader of the Opposition in the House of Commons and in the media has cited questioning about whether there is a point to CHOGM overall. In debates that we are currently having on the Representation of the People Bill, Conservatives are seeking to disenfranchise Commonwealth citizens from voting in our elections. If the Commonwealth is to succeed, it also needs to be relevant for young people in particular, socially and economically. It is sad that a level of polarisation is now creeping in. There is a school in Tobago the students of which I have had the great pleasure of meeting a number of times. It is called the Roxborough school. I live in Roxborough. Roxborough school in Tobago is named because of the exploitation of plantations for the benefit of our economy. I do not accept the argument that this is historic and historic alone. There are ongoing and contemporary relationships forged because of our exploitative history, but young people are not daunted by the history. They want a future. In my discussions with them, they say they want that future based on respect and opportunity. Over recent years, it has become even harder for them to have scholarships funded for sport or elsewhere in the UK. They struggle massively. It is almost impossible for them to receive funding for this, and it is actively impossible for them to get Home Office support. We are undermining the very relationships that we hope should be dear to us. This is most acute in development partnerships. If we are to recognise our history, it should not be just that we recognise our exploitative relationship; it is about our partnership today with our Commonwealth partners, many of which remain in deep development economy status. This is where the Labour Government should be ashamed. They have made a deliberate policy choice to cut bilateral development partnership funding to our Commonwealth partners from £546 million in 2024-25 to £131 million in 2028-29. That is an ongoing annual cut of 76%, or £415 million. That puts into comparison what any appeal for a reparations fund might be. It is worth noting that in the Caribbean, where these discussions were taking place, our Government have decided to cut the development team by half. The issue is not what the UK is entertaining with regard to reparations for previous exploitations; it is what we are actively cutting now in support for some of the countries most in need. The noble Lord mentioned Malawi, a country I have had the great pleasure of visiting on a number of occasions, which has deep historical links with Scotland in particular. The UK, under this Government, is cutting its development partnership support for Malawi by an astonishing 90%. That is breathtaking in the current situation, where we need to be development partners. It is not just about development support; it is about trading—not giving and receiving, but trading and trade facilitation. The Government are also cutting trade facilitation support, barrier reduction and support for training, especially for women-owned enterprises. I hope the Government will think again. This is not the way of having a relationship with our Commonwealth partners for bilateral relationships. We have seen enormous missed opportunities, and I hope the Government will now change course. I mean no disrespect to the Minister who is responding today, but some of the questions that we are asking are fundamental and I do not expect her to reply to them this evening. But I appeal to the Government: it is not too late to change course, and they need to do so. If we carry on down this track, the remaining support that we have in the Commonwealth will be greatly diminished because we are not a good partner at the moment.

More from Lord Purvis of Tweed (LD)

Other recent Hansard contributions by the same speaker.

About Hansard

Hansard is the official verbatim record of proceedings in the UK Parliament. Every word spoken in the Commons and Lords is recorded and published — this page is a single contribution from that record.