Contribution
My Lords, it is a pleasure to follow the noble Lord. We are debating what may become the first Act of Parliament under Prime Minister Burnham, which is perhaps appropriate given the personal nature of it.
This has been a characteristically interesting debate. I knew that it would be, given the speakers’ list. I enjoyed the curmudgeonly contribution from the noble Lord, Lord Moylan. I am a beneficiary of the Oaths Act 1888, which he referred to. However, I did reflect on the fact that he said it was a rushed measure, which the noble Lord, Lord Murphy, referred to. In my experience, criticism of change is often levelled by those most reluctant and resistant to it. They say it is not the right time or that it is rushed or premature—only to find out, after a little bit of research, that it was previously debated in 1869. In the debate we had not long ago on breaking the automatic right of someone with a peerage to sit in this House until they die, the criticism of haste was presented. I remarked that we had passed a resolution on this very aspect in 1910. Therefore, this Bill cannot by any reasonable measure be described as premature or rushed. It is appropriate. It is just 200 years out of date.
The noble Lord, Lord Wolfson, in his excellent contribution, was right to point out that, if discrimination is on the statute book, it still has an effect simply by being there, and we are rightly changing. The Leader of the House, in her excellent opening of this debate, said that we have been moving over time, slowly but surely. It was a bit more of the slowly than the surely. There was an excellent House of Commons briefing for the proceedings there. I liked a part of it which referred to a debate almost to the day a century ago. The House of Commons was debating Church of England legislation. George Lansbury said that the fact that
“a Jew, an infidel, a Turk, a Buddhist, a Christian Scientist, or a Theosophist may have the right to appoint these people when a Roman Catholic is not allowed this privilege … is perfectly absurd”.—[Official Report, Commons, 3/12/1926; col. 1575.]
That was 100 years ago. So, yes, we have been debating this for quite a while. He was right then. We are right now. Seeing the change is appropriate.
I live north of the border. I will not intervene on the previous discussion with regards to structure of the Kirk. However, for over 100 years, since the Church of Scotland Act 1921, we have had the spiritual, structural and organisational independence of the Kirk. I miss dearly my friend Lord Wallace of Tankerness, who found no distinction between his political, public and religious life as Moderator of the General Assembly. He to me was a model. We disagreed, because I am not spiritual, but I miss him deeply. I am sure that he will be turning in his grave when he hears what I am about to say with regard to disestablishmentarianism.
Interestingly, another of my predecessors as Liberal leader, Viscount Samuel, High Commissioner of Palestine, also was able to bring that public and religious combination together: a Jewish commissioner with a role in the appointment of the Grand Mufti and the Chief Rabbinate at that time. We can learn from history how there can be religious tolerance in organisations. However, fundamentally, I do not believe that faith should ever be the means by which we decide whether that person is fit to hold public office. The only reason why this Bill is needed now is that the Prime Minister of the day, whoever they are and whatever they believe, still plays a part in choosing bishops in the Church of England. It is establishment that creates the problem, not the discriminatory nature of the relief Act.
That is notwithstanding what my noble friend eloquently called his antidisestablishmentarianism. I have been waiting to say that word in Parliament, so I am glad to have the opportunity. His great sincerity highlighted the fact that there are some who believe that there should be establishment. I do not take that view. I believe that in our legislature there should not be reserved places for clerics. As the noble Lord, Lord Birt, said, we are anomalous in the world with regard to that. This is for another time, when it comes to the overall aspect.
Religion should always be an issue of private conscience and never a matter of public policy. I do not believe that the state is bound to profess a religion. Therefore, I do not believe that the political leader should advise on religious affairs, nor that clerics should have reserved places in a legislature. However, since we are not rushing that aspect, in the meantime this Bill needs to pass and we should remove this anomaly. The issue of the wider aspect is for another day, but I hope that day will come.