L

Lord Barber of Chittlehampton (Lab)

Speaking in the House of Lords on 10 November 2026

Debate

Church Appointments (Repeal of Discriminatory Provision) Bill

Contribution

My Lords, I speak warmly in favour of this historically significant Bill and follow some remarkable and distinguished speeches. I start with an aside. My noble friend the Lord Privy Seal and I have had a debate about the number of pages per Bill, which has grown remorselessly over the last 70 years. I am glad to congratulate her on introducing a Bill that will bring the average down. As we have heard, we are amending the Roman Catholic Relief Act 1829 and the Jews Relief Act 1858. Both, at their time, were significant advances in toleration. Catholic emancipation, as we have also heard, had been a major theme of controversy going back decades, but every time proposals reached anywhere near this Chamber, they ran into the formidable barrier of that strong English Protestant identity going back to the Armada. What changed in 1829 and ensured that the Roman Catholic Relief Act reached the statute book were two things. First, the great Daniel O’Connell, who they called the Liberator, had run a huge and peaceful campaign over the previous years among Catholics, largely in Ireland. He won a by-election in County Clare in 1828 on the issue of emancipation, but, under the existing laws, of course, was unable to take his seat in Parliament. Secondly, the Duke of Wellington, revered victor of Waterloo and, by 1829, the Prime Minister, feared civil war in Ireland unless the law changed. Such was his authority at the time, along with Peel’s, that he was able to turn a deeply held Tory opposition to change into reluctant support, so the Bill passed. However, as Wellington said in introducing the Second Reading, he was committed to a Church of England monarchy, which in his view meant that the advice that the monarch received on Church matters needed to be from people who explicitly shared that faith—hence the sections of the Act we are repealing today. Even so, at the time, not everyone in this Chamber backed the Bill. The Bishops at the time were divided. Both Archbishops opposed the entire Bill because, as the Archbishop of Canterbury put it, it was their “duty” to protect the Protestant religion. As soon as the Bill had passed, Daniel O’Connell, to his credit, began advising British Jews on how they might make similar progress. It took a while, but ultimately was far less controversial. Thus, today we are completing that process of Catholic and Jewish emancipation—surely a proud moment for all of us. The passage of this Bill today would signify three ways in which our society has changed wholly for the better in the two centuries since 1829. First, the Church of England itself has changed radically. Not only is the Archbishop of Canterbury a woman—unimaginable to the Duke of Wellington—but throughout the institution, as we have heard, there is an openness to and inclusivity of diverse perspectives. In addition, since Faith in the City in 1985, and even as far back as William Temple, the Archbishop of Canterbury in the 1940s, the Church of England has become a regular advocate of social change. In my time working in the Blair Administration, working with the Church of England on the biggest expansion of Church of England provision of education for many years was a great privilege and pleasure. The second change is that, in parallel, our whole society has also changed radically for the better. Over the decades, first of all, intolerance became tolerance, and then tolerance itself was replaced by an active commitment to diversity and inclusion, as in today’s Bill. We should be collectively proud of that and resist any signs of retreat from it. By the way, responding to the noble Lord, Lord Birt, with whom I had the privilege of working in past years, I would not swap what they have in the US, France, Germany or Italy for what we have here, for the relationship between the Church and state and for the diverse and inclusive society that, for all its faults, we have been able to build. Thirdly, in passing this Bill, we can congratulate our current Prime Minister, Andy Burnham, on successfully defying his distinguished predecessor the Duke of Wellington. As Daniel Maclise’s epic painting in the Royal Gallery over there illustrates, not even Napoleon managed that. I like to imagine that, somewhere beyond his grave in Dublin, there is a gentle smile this evening on the lips of the Liberator, and I commend this Bill to the House.

More from Lord Barber of Chittlehampton (Lab)

Other recent Hansard contributions by the same speaker.

About Hansard

Hansard is the official verbatim record of proceedings in the UK Parliament. Every word spoken in the Commons and Lords is recorded and published — this page is a single contribution from that record.