L

Lord Callanan (Con)

Speaking in the House of Lords on 20 October 2026

Debate

EU, Euratom and UK Agreement on Gibraltar

Contribution

My Lords, I also start by thanking the noble Lord, Lord Barrow, for so successfully and cogently introducing the debate on behalf of the noble and gallant Lord, Lord Stirrup, and I thank the committee for its diligent work in scrutinising this agreement. I also welcome the Gibraltar Chief Minister to our debate today. We recognise the significant challenges that have been faced by Gibraltarian residents and businesses in the years prior to this agreement; it is clear that post-Brexit arrangements with the European Union needed to be finalised. The Government have come to this agreement with the support of the Government of Gibraltar, and we on these Benches respect that. Like the noble and learned Baroness, Lady Butler-Sloss, I have visited Gibraltar in a personal capacity since the new agreement came into force provisionally, and she is right about the terrible queues at Gibraltar airport. One of the great things about going to Gibraltar previously was that you were straight in—passport control took seconds. I hope that the frictions that we are now seeing are only temporary. It was right at the start of the agreement, and I am sure that the Gibraltar and Spanish authorities will be working together to change that, because it was not a good experience. We also welcome the fact that the agreement makes no change to the UK’s unquestioned sovereignty over Gibraltar. In that context, as I said, we do not oppose the agreement, but I take the opportunity of our debate today to press the Government on some of its practical effects. Under the agreement, Spanish authorities will have responsibility, as has been said by a number of Members, for Schengen area border checks at the airport and indeed at the port, removing the need for checks at the land border, which have been a serious concern for residents and businesses—indeed, when I was there, the land border had completely disappeared and you could walk across easily into La Línea. The fact that the Spanish authorities will be managing border checks raises some important questions. While I appreciate that law enforcement remains the sole responsibility of the Gibraltarian authorities, Spanish border guards will operate at crossings established at Gibraltar’s port and airport. Will the Minister confirm that those Spanish border guards will be prohibited, for instance, from carrying weapons? As part of the preparatory work ahead of the conclusion of this treaty, Ministers will no doubt have undertaken impact assessments on the effect of border checks managed by Spain. Will the Minister confirm how many British nationals per year the Government believe could be denied entry to Gibraltar by Spanish authorities? I understand that so far none has, but I wonder whether the Government have any estimate of what might happen in an average year. What recourse will be available to those nationals who are then denied entry? I find it peculiar that apparently the Gibraltarian authorities would be able to allow them to enter Gibraltar if the Spanish authorities have denied them entry, because then there would be nothing to stop them travelling onward into the rest of the Schengen area. I think we should be given some clarification. On disagreements and recourse, Part 6 of the treaty establishes a dispute resolution mechanism between the UK and Spain that facilitates a resolution of any dispute that may arise as a result of Spanish administration of the border checks. How would the Minister respond to the comments of the Gibraltar opposition leader, Keith Azopardi, that the concordat between London and Gibraltar on dealing with future issues that could arise from the agreement falls short of his expectation? The elements of the agreement that touch on business, trade and taxation in Gibraltar also deserve close scrutiny. I know that a number of Members have also posed these questions. Will the Minister explain which businesses were consulted when agreeing that Spain would get a joint say over Gibraltarian VAT and excise rates? Have the Government made any assessment of how the level playing field aspect of the treaty could impact trade and co-operation between the UK and Gibraltar? On defence, did the Minister consult with the Armed Forces’ leadership in Gibraltar prior to the conclusion of the agreement to ensure that our service people can still carry out their duties with kit not subject to Spanish export controls? The agreement also establishes a financial mechanism to promote cohesion between Gibraltar and Campo de Gibraltar under Article 299. How much taxpayers’ money—or, rather, Gibraltarian taxpayers’ money—do the Government plan to send to the EU through that mechanism? Will the Minister also confirm what share of the cost of this financial mechanism Spain is shouldering? There is also a longer-term impact of the treaty that we should consider, as my noble friend Lord Jackson indicated. The new residence criteria were announced and, as my noble friend also said, one now has to earn £37,500 per annum and be under 55, which means that many young Britons cannot move to Gibraltar to work. If we add that to the 90-day rule, it makes it almost impossible for a young Briton to go there for any significant period or to relocate unless they are extremely well paid. Prior to these new rules, pensioners could also move if they moved their pension; now it is almost impossible for pensioners to move to Gibraltar. At the same time, of course, Spanish and EU nationals can go any time, for as long or as short a time as they like, with no restrictions. The new residency rules will mean that Britons have much less favourable terms of access and employment than EU nationals. Given that reality and those circumstances, can the Minister say what changes the Government expect to see in the long-term nationality make-up of Gibraltar? If the Government envisage that Gibraltar will become home to significantly more Spanish nationals over time, what impact might that have in any future discussions on UK sovereignty over the Rock? Many of these issues will play out over years to come. I am reminded of the famous quote from Chairman Mao when he was asked about the effects of the French Revolution: he said that it was still too early to say. This is a very complex agreement that will have a significant impact on the future of Gibraltar, for many years to come, far beyond the short-term benefits of smoother trade and border arrangements with the EU. As I said at the outset, we do not oppose this treaty, given the broader context of the unanimous support from the Parliament of Gibraltar. However, I believe that Ministers must be clear-eyed about the impact of the treaty and the risk of future attempts to undermine British sovereignty over Gibraltar, given those effects.

More from Lord Callanan (Con)

Other recent Hansard contributions by the same speaker.

About Hansard

Hansard is the official verbatim record of proceedings in the UK Parliament. Every word spoken in the Commons and Lords is recorded and published — this page is a single contribution from that record.