Contribution
My Lords, I thank all noble Lords for their contributions. I am sorry, but there were so many questions that I am not going to be able to answer all of them. I will try to get through as many as I can, and I am sure that I will be able to get back to noble Lords on others.
I am grateful to the noble and gallant Lord, Lord Stirrup, for securing this debate and to the noble Lord, Lord Barrow, for introducing it. I pay tribute to noble and gallant Lord, Lord Stirrup, as chair of the European Affairs Committee, which has scrutinised this agreement with characteristic rigour and care. I am grateful for the contributions of other noble Lords, and I will try to respond. I have lots of scrawl on my paper, so if I have to peer at my small handwriting, forgive me for a couple of seconds’ pause. I will try to respond to as many points as I can.
I pay particular tribute to noble Baroness, Lady Hooper, and the noble Lord, Lord Bilimoria, who I know have had long positive engagement with Gibraltar over many years. Both of them are highly valued by the people in Gibraltar who I met when I went for Gibraltar National Day.
I was pleased to have the opportunity to discuss the issues raised here with the committee on 15 September, alongside the valuable evidence that it received from the Chief Minister of Gibraltar, to whom I also pay tribute for all his hard work in securing this treaty.
As noble Lords know, the UK-EU agreement in respect of Gibraltar was signed by the UK and the EU on 14 July and has been provisionally applied since 15 July. The agreement brings certainty and predictability to Gibraltar’s relationship with the EU after years of uncertainty following the UK’s departure from the EU. It provides a stable framework for Gibraltar’s future relationship with the EU, while fully guarding British sovereignty, in my view, and the operational autonomy of the UK military facility. The agreement delivers the removal of physical barriers at the Gibraltar-Spain border. It supports the free circulation of people and goods and provides certainty for the nearly 15,000 people who cross the frontier each day for work. It also protects Gibraltar’s economy. I again pay tribute to the noble Lord, Lord Bilimoria, for so vividly painting the picture of the character of the Gibraltar economy and the way in which its dynamics work. The agreement also protects the Gibraltar way of life while strengthening co-operation with the European Union and Spain.
I will come back later to the remarks by the noble Lord, Lord Redwood, which are a fascinating insight into the theology of Brexit, but I am surprised that someone who is so renowned as an apostle of free markets and open trade should be so sceptical about Gibraltar, a territory that has chosen a free trade agreement with its neighbour, but there we go.
Much of the day-to-day implementation of the agreement is being led by His Majesty’s Government of Gibraltar, working closely with the United Kingdom, Spain and the European Commission. As the noble and learned Baroness, Lady Butler-Sloss, and a couple of others remarked, there have been some teething implementation problems. The noble Lord, Lord Callanan, mentioned his trip. When I went to the airport, I was in and out within five minutes. Perhaps they knew that I was coming and that I was going to stand here and talk about it. There have definitely been teething issues. There is no doubt about it. I think everyone would admit that. They are getting better because of daily co-operation between the authorities. Their co-operation is required to make this work. It is progressing well, with thousands of people crossing the land border each day without interruption.
On parliamentary scrutiny, the Government recognise the close interest that Parliament has rightly taken in this agreement. We published the draft text well before signature, laid the final agreement before Parliament in accordance with the CRaG Act and have continued to engage with parliamentarians—I hope that noble Lords agree—throughout this process. I was pleased to give evidence to the European Affairs Committee last month alongside the Chief Minister. Today’s debate has been an important moment for noble Lords to scrutinise this agreement. We remain firmly of the view that this agreement provides the best available outcome for Gibraltar, fully protects sovereignty and defence interests and commands the support of the Government of Gibraltar.
A few noble Lords have mentioned the concordat, namely the agreement of 14 July setting out how the UK and Gibraltar will manage the treaty between them. I thank the noble and learned Baroness, Lady Butler-Sloss, for her kind remarks about that. The noble Lord, Lord Frost, invited me to speculate on Gibraltarian opposition to the concordat. He will understand, I am sure, that I do not want to speculate on opposition views either here or elsewhere. He asked me about updates to the treaty. Any significant updates will of course be provided to Parliament. The noble Lord, Lord Bilimoria, asked whether this treaty will extend to services. The answer is no, it will not extend to services.
Since provisional application began on 15 July, implementation has progressed well. His Majesty’s Government of Gibraltar have led an extensive programme of legislative, operational and infrastructure changes. The UK has fully supported this work alongside implementation on the other side by the European Commission and Spain. As the Committee heard, both we and the Chief Minister are pleased with the progress made so far and the benefits the agreement is already delivering for Gibraltar.
I was struck when the noble Lord, Lord Hannay, talked about the experience of Gibraltar during the Franco years, and the contrast between a Gibraltar that is open to its neighbour and one that is closed off.
The agreement is already providing greater certainty for Gibraltar’s economy, preserving fluid movement across the border and increasing confidence among businesses and investors. Most of all, it provides a stable long-term framework for Gibraltar’s relationship in the future with the European Union.
Most visibly, the removal of routine checks at the Gibraltar-Spain land border is already delivering tangible benefits for workers, residents and businesses on both sides of the frontier. I will return to the thoughts of the noble Lord, Lord Redwood, later, but I think his characterisation of the experience across the land border is a world away from the experience of Gibraltarians and people who work in Gibraltar.
As expected with a treaty this complex, there have been some operational issues, as I say, with implementation but I can assure noble Lords these are being addressed through the channels of communication between military officers, the police and other authorities. I saw this myself when I visited Gibraltar.
We continue to work in lockstep with His Majesty’s Government of Gibraltar to support implementation and mitigate practical issues as they arise. Full ratification of the treaty will provide an additional degree of certainty and permanence for the people and businesses of Gibraltar and Spain that depend on the agreement every day.
One of the agreement’s most significant benefits is the removal of routine immigration checks—about which many noble Lords asked—at Gibraltar’s land border with Spain. This is crucial for the 15,000 people who cross the frontier every day and crucial for Gibraltar’s economy and the prosperity of the wider region. To deliver these benefits while maintaining a fluid border, passengers arriving at Gibraltar Airport undergo, as noble Lords have said, dual immigration controls. As a result, visitors are able to travel onwards into Spain without further checks.
The noble Lord, Lord Frost, asked whether someone denied entry into Schengen would be allowed entry into Gibraltar. In most cases, Gibraltar will recognise Spanish decisions. It can, however, for reasons of, say, humanitarian concerns, in exceptional circumstances allow people into Gibraltar who are rejected by Schengen. This provision applies within the Schengen area to individual countries more generally. Gibraltar residents can always be permitted entry. Time spent in Gibraltar counts towards the EU’s 90 in 180-day rule for non-resident visitors.
I should also have said in response to the noble Lord, Lord Redwood, that there is no restriction on rest-of-world flights to and from Gibraltar.
His Majesty’s Government of Gibraltar have been clear that the significant economic and social benefits of a fluid border outweigh the limitations that these rules impose. As the Chief Minister told the committee, ensuring fluidity at the frontier was the most important issue facing Gibraltar after Brexit, and the agreement provides the solution that Gibraltar sought.
The noble Lords, Lord Callanan and Lord Jackson, asked whether the treaty will discourage British citizens from becoming Gibraltar residents. To be clear, the treaty does not require Gibraltar to impose new residency criteria. As is the case today, residency requirements, including the minimum income threshold that noble Lords mentioned of £37,500 and other eligibility criteria, are not decisions of the UK Government. They are decisions of His Majesty’s Government of Gibraltar. They are not obligations created by the treaty.
The noble Lord, Lord Jackson, raised a number of concerns about residency. I respectfully say to him that he needs to speak to the Chief Minister, as these are rules chosen by the people of Gibraltar and I am sure the noble Lord, Lord Jackson, would respect the democratic wishes of the Government of Gibraltar.
To ensure that young British people are not excluded from moving to Gibraltar, Gibraltar has also introduced an exemption for applicants under 30, as a couple of noble Lords mentioned. Under that exemption, the £37,500 minimum income requirement may be waived. These are all matters for the Chief Minister and his team, but as the Chief Minister made clear to the European Affairs Committee, there is
“absolutely no question of a British person who wants to work in Gibraltar … not being able to come into Gibraltar as a result of this treaty”.
On the question of the customs union, it is “a” customs union, not “the” customs union. It is a freely chosen alignment that the people of Gibraltar, through their representatives, have made.