Contribution
My Lords, the Government have stated that their number one mission is economic growth. Regulation can provide the stability that businesses and the economy need to thrive or it can be a source of roadblocks that inhibit growth. The reality is that current regulation is confusing, time consuming and costly to business. Some 47% of businesses reported in 2024 that regulation was an obstacle to their success, an increase from 45% in 2022. Two in five businesses felt that new post-Brexit regulatory arrangements were more challenging, 93% of businesses use some form of external support to assist in complying with regulation, and the mean amount that business spent on support was £10,745 compared to £6,100 in 2022.
A regulatory system needs to be transparent, consistent and easy to understand. Over time, unnecessary regulatory costs have contributed to a less competitive and less attractive British economy for new investment. This country used to be a magnet for inward investment. Some studies suggest that the impact of red-tape regulatory costs could be as high as 3% to 4% of GDP—we are talking about over £70 billion. A regulatory system needs to encourage new investment and regulate only where necessary and acceptable to keep pace with innovation.
Despite campaigning Brexit as an opportunity to deregulate in the name of freedom and growth, the UK has done relatively little to diverge from EU regulations since. The main reasons are that it would become more difficult to trade with the EU, with a lack of clear strategy of how and when to diverge and the priority of other competing post-Brexit responsibilities. However, there are some exceptions: the banning of live animal exports, establishing new freeports and repealing the bankers’ bonus cap.
In March 2025, the Department for Business and Trade published the regulation action plan, which many noble Lords have spoken about, aiming to overhaul the regulatory system to increase economic growth and cut administrative costs of regulation by 25% by the end of the Parliament. It includes plans to merge or remove regulatory bodies, reform registration and require regulators to increase transparency. Its three main goals are to tackle complexity and burden of regulation; reduce uncertainty across the regulatory system; and challenge excessive risk aversion.
In May 2026, the Industry and Regulators Committee published the report that we are debating, Time is money: How regulators can support growth, in relation to the Government’s action plan. I congratulate the noble Baroness, Lady Hayter, and the members of the committee on the hard work they put into this excellent report. I reiterate, very quickly, the main conclusion of the report that the main contribution for regulators to make in supporting investment and growth is to carry on their duties more efficiently. It is unclear what the broad aim of supporting growth means for individual regulators. The Government have not said whether they want regulators to tolerate more risk or just be more open to innovation. It is the Government’s responsibility—I hope the Minister would agree—to provide strategic guidance with an explicit risk appetite for each regulator, with political cover when government wants a regulator to be more open to risk. Does the Minister agree? It is likely that, to prioritise economic growth, regulators will make trade-offs with other responsibilities, such as consumer, competition or environmental protection. The Government need to clarify the extent to which growth is prioritised, not leave this decision up to the regulators.
The Government may be focusing on the smaller cost of paperwork rather than the larger cost of complying with self-regulation. Cutting administrative costs by 25% could be hit without businesses feeling any change. The committee rightly asked for estimates for the reduction of actual cost compliance.
I am chair of the International Chamber of Commerce in the UK and regional co-ordinator for the ICC in Europe—35 countries. We in the UK and the ICC have been leading the charge on promoting digital trade. Most people do not realise that most trade today is paper-based. If that paper-based trade can be moved to digital, it means that what takes three months takes minutes, and saves billions of dollars or pounds. This is where regulations are coming to help promote this, with the UK as a role model for the rest of the world—does the Minister agree?
Of course, there are different perspectives on regulation. To give an example, the Government are talking about bringing down the costs; the Lib Dems support cutting and consolidating regulation, particularly promoting trade with Europe; and the Conservatives talk about deregulation to encourage growth and repealing regulations surrounding net zero, diversity and inclusion and the Employment Rights Act 2025, which has brought extra regulation. The regulatory culture is far too cautious, according to the Conservatives. The International Chamber of Commerce supports business self-regulation to build trust between businesses, consumers and the public. The CBI—the Confederation of British Industry—of which I was president, supports the recommendations of the small business taskforce on corporate reporting reform, noting
“the test now is delivery … business will want to see that ambition translated quickly into meaningful reductions in the burden they face”.
The CBI recommends an outcomes-based, principle-led approach.
The report has also said, as very well put by the Advertising Standards Authority, that regulation needs to create stable, predictable frameworks that enable businesses to invest and innovate while protecting legitimate public interest. Octopus Energy says very clearly that it is regulation that allowed it, as a new company, to come in not just to gain top market share but to do so by bringing quite a lot of innovative products.
I conclude that the pace of regulation is often a problem, and we need to work on making it faster. Does the Minister agree that this is a primary challenge? AI, which has been brought up, needs to be addressed as well. The only certainty in today’s world is uncertainty. Encouraging investment, innovation and growth is a key part of the vision of the Government’s plan. Most witnesses cited in the report said that regulators need to provide long-term stability and predictability to encourage investment and enable companies to plan ahead.