Contribution
My Lords, I landed this morning from Washington DC, where, in my role as chair of the International Chamber of Commerce—the ICC—and UK and regional co-ordinator for ICC Europe, with 35 countries, I spoke at quite a few events. The last one was with BritishAmerican Business, the British-American chamber of commerce, where I was asked, “What is Britain going to do to solve its fiscal challenges?” My reply was as follows.
On the Budget, the Minister talked about breathing space. I heaved a sigh of relief. I was fearing capital gains tax being equated with income tax. I was fearing wealth taxes. I was fearing, as with the last two Budgets, taxes and national insurance for employers being put up, the erosion of inheritance tax relief for farmers and family businesses, and changes to the non-dom rules, with tens of thousands of millionaires and billionaires leaving the country. The latest estimate is that £160 billion of wealth has left the country. The effect of those last two Budgets was over £50 billion; this one was a mere £7 billion. Phew!
The CBI, of which I was president, said that the Budget
“lacks the bold moves that would have made it easier for firms to invest, hire and grow”.
The ICC majors on trade—it is the largest business organisation in the world, with 45 million businesses, and I say that we cannot simply tax our way to growth; we must trade our way to growth. The only certainty in the business world today is uncertainty, and business craves certainty. Business can plan around a clear rule; it cannot plan around a moving target. Trade makes up 60% of our GDP, yet only one in eight UK SMEs exports goods or services. What more can the Government do to encourage exports? Some 50% of SME applications for trade finance are rejected. What are we going to do about making digital trade compulsory? It will save billions of pounds and it will save time—what takes months can be done in minutes.
For my business, Cobra Beer, hospitality is our industry. It is one of the most heavily taxed sectors of the economy, paying 82p for every £1 of profit. It employs 3.5 million people. I was very happy to see in the Budget that the small business rate relief will take 70,000 firms out of paying business rates. I was also very happy to see entrepreneurship measures. The £10 million of lifetime gains at 10% is fantastic, and the £20 billion for the National Wealth Fund and the British Business Bank is superb.
We have the highest energy prices in Europe and among the highest in the world. On energy security, we have given permission for Jackdaw; why are the Government not giving permission for Rosebank to be approved as well? There are two elephants in the room. One is defence. The Government talk about 3% by 2030 and 3.5% by 2035. Let us do 3.5% right now. We need to do this desperately. What was good in the Budget was the £10 billion of extra support to Ukraine through loans and UK Export Finance guarantees. We must keep supporting Ukraine. Welfare reform, which is desperately needed, is the other elephant in the room.
Let us not forget that frozen income tax thresholds mean that the tax burden reaches a new post-war high every single year. This is the crux of it. The tax burden now is the highest on record, at 39% of GDP. Our spending is the highest on record, at 44% of GDP. You do not need to be an expert in maths to see that that creates a deficit every single year. Yet, in spite of the geopolitical situation, we are still growing at 1% a year, which is a miracle. Our inflation target is 2%, but we are almost double that at over 3.5%. Our gilt yields are among the highest in the G7. Greece borrows at a cheaper rate than we do. The cost of servicing our government debt has risen almost three times, from £39 billion in 2019-20 to £110 billion in 2025-26. This is not a good situation. Borrowing at 100% of GDP is scary. Okay, you could say that America is borrowing at 130% of GDP, but the bottom line is this: when Liz Truss and Kwasi Kwarteng had £45 billion of tax cuts in their Budget with extra borrowing but no OBR forecast, it led to a disaster. To quote James Carville, Bill Clinton’s adviser:
“I used to think if there was reincarnation, I wanted to come back as the president or the pope or a .400 baseball hitter … But now I want to come back as the bond market. You can intimidate everybody”.
The solution to our problems is very clear. We need to bring down spending, reform welfare and reduce taxes and borrowing. That will incentivise investment and growth. That growth will generate jobs, and those jobs will create the taxes that will pay for the public services. We are still the sixth-largest economy in the world. We are still at the top table. We are not a middle power; we are a global power. We have the strongest combination of hard and soft power of just about any country in the world. This economy deserves better and this country deserves better.