L

Lord Bailey of Paddington (Con)

Speaking in the House of Lords on 12 November 2026

Debate

Autumn Budget 2026

Contribution

My Lords, after more than 35 years of working with young people and having experienced unemployment and homelessness myself as a young man, I know what that first job opportunity offers. It provides dignity, routine, confidence and independence. Yet we have 981,000 young people between the ages of 16 and 24 who are now not in employment, education or training. That is 30,000 more than a year ago. Behind those figures is wasted talent and confidence being eroded. The Government point to the jobs guarantee scheme, the youth jobs grant and another £100 million for local apprenticeship services. I do not doubt the good intentions behind this, but we must distinguish between an initiative and a viable job. The jobs guarantee offers a six-month subsidised position, but only after an eligible young person has been seeking universal credit for 18 months while looking for work. Eighteen months is long enough for confidence, skill and hope to be drained away. When those six months come to an end, if the employer still cannot afford a permanent job, that young person risks being returned to where they started, except it has cost the public a lot of money. The effect of this Government’s policies has been an anti-employment strategy, whatever their intentions were. Employers’ national insurance rose from 13.8% to 15%, while the threshold fell from £9,100 to £5,000. The OBR estimates that this will reduce labour supply by the equivalent of over 50,000 workers on average hours, while depressing wages and profits and increasing prices. The Government’s own interim research shows that more than 30% of employers expect to operate with fewer staff and that the annual cost of hiring a young person has risen by £4,000. The Government’s answer to this has been a £3,000 job grant scheme for selected employers. So they have taken away £4,000 and handed over £3,000, attached with conditions and administration, and called it an employment strategy. The Government must stop taking people’s money from their pay packets and stop taking profits from businesses, and congratulating themselves when they return a proportion of this money through an expensive scheme. They had the right instinct in the Autumn Statement in 2023 when they cut national insurance for workers and made full expensing permanent. This Government should recover that instinct and extend employer national insurance relief so that all under-25s, not only those aged under 21, are eligible for this and that apprentices are covered as well. They must strengthen the employment allowance for small firms, simplify apprenticeship funding and judge every youth employment programme by how many young people are still in work 12 months after the public support ends. This brings me to housing. I welcome the announcements to support more affordable housing, but 10,000 additional homes across England, and equity loans for up to 70,000 households, cannot carry the full burden. A subsidised mortgage is of little or no use to a young person without secure earnings. Councils need planning capacity and long-term certainty; smaller builders need viable sites and affordable homes must be built at scale and quickly. The Government must stop treating taxation as a first step and grant applications as a second. Leave more money with workers and businesses, make hiring affordable, build the homes that we need at the quickest pace possible and judge success by sustained outcomes, not enrolments. The best youth employment scheme is a successful business with the confidence and capacity to employ a young person for good.

More from Lord Bailey of Paddington (Con)

Other recent Hansard contributions by the same speaker.

About Hansard

Hansard is the official verbatim record of proceedings in the UK Parliament. Every word spoken in the Commons and Lords is recorded and published — this page is a single contribution from that record.