L

Lord Ashcombe (Con)

Speaking in the House of Lords on 14 October 2026

Debate

Trade Unions (Right to Access Workplaces) Regulations 2026

Contribution

My Lords, I declare an interest as an employee of a large multinational employer. I wish to speak against these regulations, not because I oppose trade unions or worker representation but because this Government have chosen to ignore democratic consultation on an unprecedented scale, imposed a framework that will damage the small businesses they claim to champion and crossed a line on employer autonomy from which we may not easily return. This Government consulted on these proposals. Over 1,600 responses came in. As my noble friend Lord Sharpe has mentioned, but I believe it worth repeating, on the central question of weekly access at the heart of this regime, 95.3% respondents disagreed. On the two-working day notice requirement, 92.4% disagreed. These are not marginal objections. They are not even 50:50. They are landside rejections—the kind of number a politician usually sees only in a province he is not expecting to lose—and the Government have ignored them entirely. This is not how government should work. When a consultation returns a verdict this one-sided, there is a democratic obligation either to redesign a policy or to explain with rigour why you are overriding the people you consulted. The Government have done neither. They have simply filed the responses away somewhere dark and ploughed ahead regardless. That should concern this House on principle alone. But the principle is not the only problem. The competence is appalling. The 21-worker threshold catches businesses that never asked for this intrusion and barely have the paperwork to cope with it. The Institute of Directors surveyed 680 business leaders. Only 10 supported the 21-worker threshold and 74% wanted a higher bar. Yet here we are, imposing weekly union access on firms with modest HR capacity, minimal administrative resources and no history of industrial relations complexity. The regulations will create bureaucracy wildly out of proportion to the risk that they address. For retailers with multiple sites, social care providers already stretched to breaking point and universities managing student safety and data protection, this framework is a sledgehammer looking rather pleased with itself over a nut that it has yet to crack. The cost assumptions are thin, in the way that a stage magician’s assurances are thin. The impact assessment does not monetise every business burden. It does not fully capture management time, facilities, paid attendance at access meetings or the opportunity cost of disrupted operations. For public services, social care and local government, these are unfunded costs landing on budgets that are already down to their last few pence down the back of the sofa. The code recommends full pay for workers attending access meetings in work time. The Homecare Association estimates that this could be ruinous in publicly funded care. The Government have not told us how that cost is justified or who is expected to foot the bill—beyond, presumably, hope. Here is what troubles me most. These regulations cross a constitutional line, and do not do so quietly. For decades, we have expected workplace relations to reflect negotiation between employer and union, not a unilateral statutory entitlement handed down from on high. This regime says that, whether you recognise a union or not, the state will now let itself in. That is not a tweak to employment law. It is a fundamental shift in the relationship between employer, worker and state, dressed up in the modest clothing of a statutory instrument. It erodes employer autonomy in ways that will not be undone merely by regretting them later, which is all that this amendment would allow us to do. I do not oppose worker voice. I oppose this vehicle for it. It is one rejected by consultation, imposed without justification, misaligned with business reality and dangerous to the principle of voluntary engagement. This Government have in effect asked the country a question, disliked the answer and gone ahead regardless. I support this amendment and press the Government to return to the drawing board and perhaps, this time, to take on board what comes back.

More from Lord Ashcombe (Con)

Other recent Hansard contributions by the same speaker.

About Hansard

Hansard is the official verbatim record of proceedings in the UK Parliament. Every word spoken in the Commons and Lords is recorded and published — this page is a single contribution from that record.