Contribution
My Lords, I too thank the noble Lord, Lord Ponsonby, for opening the debate with such patience, a quality he will clearly need because every noble Lord, I suspect, has an opinion—most of us have several—on this issue. It was a bit upsetting for me that we moved rooms, because I had planned to say—I will still say it—that it is appropriate to have this debate in the Moses Room. Moses knew a great deal about long sittings, for 40 years in the wilderness, and not once did anyone propose finishing at 8.30 pm. When he came down the mountain with the Ten Commandments—I have checked them very carefully—not one said, “Thou shalt sit at one o’clock on a Wednesday”. If it was good enough for Moses, it is certainly good enough for me.
Of course, as has been said, we have been here before. In 2022, the committee consulted on this question. Here we are, just four years later, being asked again. I admire the persistence: it reminds me of my grandchildren asking whether they can stay up late. The answer does not change, but the arguments get more creative. Let me declare an interest, which opposes something that the noble Lord, Lord Stoneham, said, and is in support of my noble friend Lord Jamieson. My interest is that I like lunch. A 1 pm start is not a modest procedural tweak, it is an actual assault on one of the House’s oldest and most effective conventions. I shall explain. Much cross-party agreement has been reached over a bowl of soup in the building, many an amendment has been quietly withdrawn over the main course, and more than one Bill has been rescued by the pudding. Move the start to 1 pm and we lose not just a meal but possibly the most productive committee in the House.
We are told that the reward is going to be finishing at 8.30 pm. I have nothing against going home early, especially when Liverpool are playing at 8 pm, but I have sat in this House long enough—11 years this week—to know that “normally around 8.30 pm” may be very optimistic indeed. A Bill does not get any shorter because we start and finish earlier. I do take seriously, of course, the case made about the staff of the House who look after us so well, and their well-being must be part of this decision, and I take seriously the argument that late nights are not family friendly, although I gently observe that for a good number of noble Lords, getting home in time for bedtime is less about the children’s bedtime than about our own.
I turn to the consultation itself. It offers four options. Three of them change or literally tinker, and one of them does not. As a conservative, I found that the choice makes itself. The present arrangements are not perfect—nothing in this place or any place is perfect—but they work. They let Members bring the outside world into the Chamber in the afternoon, having been out in it in the morning. If it is not broken, do not fix it. If it is a little bit broken, please do not fix it either at 1 pm or at 8.30 pm.
I finish by following the words of my noble friend Lady Laing. Who is demanding these changes? If you join a gym, a choir or a golf club, you know that there are certain rules. Much as many people at a golf club might want to start on the fifth tee or wear collarless T-shirts, you have joined the club, you know the rules. When new Members come here to our House, they know the rules and the regulations, and they know what they are signing up to. I am all for change and modernisation where that is appropriate, but I fail to understand, as other noble Lords have said, how some of these changes being discussed will help our deliberations and our effectiveness.
Where in fact are those people wanting changes? The noble Lord, Lord Ponsonby, has given us an opportunity to discuss. It is a bit like the assisted dying Bill and those debates we had every Friday. There was a vow of silence from those who supported the Bill, who then accused those with opposing views of wasting time by advancing arguments and putting forward amendments. I ask: where are those people today who are proposing these changes?