Contribution
My Lords, I thank the Senior Deputy Speaker for his opening remarks, his clear and neutral presentation, and, above all, the enormous work that he has put into making this an extensive and fair consultation. We are all very grateful to him and his team for that work.
As a relatively new Lord in your Lordships’ House, I approached the new job understanding that it would be very different from the spirit and the actions of the House of Commons and knowing that the task of your Lordships’ House is to tread very carefully so that we can be seen to be doing good work—making a difference, improving and amending—without in any way attempting to usurp the powers of the elected Government, understanding the power of the House of Commons. We generally get that right, I think. When I came here and saw the ancient traditions, as well as some of the more modern customs, they naturally seemed a little strange—as I think they do to many people outside the House—but I saw that many of them were well based in tried customs and practices that worked very well.
Today, we are debating our hours of business; this relates to the large, diverse membership that your Lordships’ House enjoys. It is part of the decision that Parliament and the nation have made that there should be a second, unelected House with a wide range of skills, experience and talent to draw on, which leads to some of the customs and practices that are so clearly embedded and has led to past Sessions of your Lordships’ House deciding that the hours should be as they are today. We are invited to make a choice between four options. There is the “no change” option. Then, as we have heard, there are two mild options around changing one day a little and the slightly bolder option of changing two days a little.
I approach this not as someone who believes that all customs and traditions have to be respected but as a conservative: there is usually a good reason for tradition and custom, and you do not want to destroy unnecessarily ones that are part of our culture and still work. For example, in the other place, during the past year of Lords reform, I was strongly in favour of retirement reform. I thought it essential that there was an opportunity for Lords to retire. There can be a system whereby, if any noble Lord’s judgment is a little wanting as to their aptitudes and capabilities, friendly Whips, friendly parties, family and others involved can help make sure that a sensible decision is made, but, again, this is relevant to our sitting hours. If we change our sitting hours too much, we will deter people from becoming Lords or from remaining Lords when they still have something to offer but need the adapted lifestyle that our rather strange hours produce.
In past debates over hours in the House of Lords, the main case for shifting our hours forward to earlier in the day has been that people have family and caring responsibilities and that those responsibilities tend to be more concentrated in the evenings, when people wish to be with their families, so perhaps we should have family-friendly hours. I see nothing family-friendly in working to 8.30 pm. If we gave up at 8.30 pm rather than 10 pm, people would probably still not get home much before 9.30 pm in most cases, given the difficult transport position in London. Obviously, people who come from a long way away cannot get home anyway and have to stay overnight; for them, it is a nuisance that the House of Lords does not work on, because they would rather that the House worked on but over fewer days so that they could get back to their home for a longer weekend and come in on Monday rather later. So I do not see how the family-friendly bit works.
What I do see is that noble Lords who have other serious jobs would find it more difficult if the hours were brought forward, whereas you can do a very serious job in the morning until lunchtime and then come in and make your contribution to the House of Lords in the afternoon. That seems a sensible approach. There is also the argument that if the hours were changed the working lunch on Tuesdays and/or Wednesdays would disappear because people would need to be in the Chamber at a much earlier hour. That would have an impact on the catering staff and facilities, and it would probably make it more difficult for those who are doing a full-time job in the House of Lords most days, who may wish to have working lunches with people.
Regarding the dinner hour, it is likely that most people would go home and not stay to dinner, whereas quite a few people stay to dinner now. That can be an important collegiate opportunity. I like the feature in the Lords of the cross-party common table, because it gives us a chance to have informal cross-party conversations in a friendly way, which can often be helpful to both the Government and the Opposition in clarifying what we are doing. Again, there would be difficulty for the catering staff and facilities if far fewer covers were served at the dinner hour because we had finished early.
There is also the question of a clash with committees if you drag the sitting hours too far forward into the morning or lunchtime. There is also the issue of educational visits, which would be impaired if the main Chamber started earlier, because people would obviously not have the same access to the building that they have at the moment, when the main facilities are not being used by your Lordships in the morning or at lunchtime.
Putting all that together, I conclude, as someone who is not against good change, that I would keep the present hours as they are because people have arranged their lives around them accordingly. I favour that great diversity. One thing that works, which is difficult to explain to people outside, is that about the right number of Peers seem to turn up for most of the debates and committee scrutiny, and we do not have crowding on the red Benches. Looking at the total membership, you might think that that would be quite a problem. The House is self-regulating: there are enough Peers who want to do a serious job every day and there are enough other Peers with great talent, experience and skills who come in from time to time when those are relevant. That works well and provides a balance.
Members of the public who are concerned about there being too many Peers need to remember that they are paid only if they turn up, which is an excellent part of the system. We get for nothing the experience on tap of all the Peers who do not participate very much, but we pay a day rate for those Peers who turn up regularly and do the real work in the Chamber of scrutinising the Government and opposing or defending their ideas.
In conclusion, I very strongly recommend that we do not tamper with the hours and that we appreciate what we have and do a better job of selling it to the wider public, because I do not think they understand why the membership is so big. They do not understand that it provides extremely good value, given the remuneration system, and they do not understand how we can then harness the experience and talent in the way that we do.